• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Right, directive or duty? Three-way sorting questions

Sort provisions on the same subject into Part III, Part IV or Part IVA by asking who is addressed and whether a court can enforce it.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The most common trap in this topic is the same subject appearing in all three Parts. Education, the environment, children and equality are each covered by a right, a directive and sometimes a duty. The method for sorting is the same each time: find who is told to act, then check the Article number.

The sorting questions

  1. Is the person told to act a citizen? If yes, think Part IVA, Article 51A.
  2. Is the State told to aim at something, with no right to claim it? Think Part IV, Articles 36 to 51.
  3. Is it something an individual can claim and a court enforce, such as a freedom or a protection? Think Part III, Articles 12 to 35.
Same subject, three Parts
SubjectPart III (right)Part IV (directive)Part IVA (duty)
Education21A: free and compulsory education, six to fourteen45: early childhood care and education below six51A(k): parent or guardian
Environment21 (read to include a healthy environment)48A: protect environment, forests, wildlife51A(g): citizen
Children at work24: no work in hazardous employment below fourteen39(e), (f): protect health and childhoodNot applicable
Equality of people14 to 1846: promote interests of weaker sections51A(e): harmony and brotherhood
Legal help22: lawyer of choice; 21: fair procedure39A: equal justice and free legal aidNot applicable

Who is told to act? Citizen: Part IVA. State told to aim: Part IV. Individual can claim in court: Part III.

— Rule to remember

Worked example 1: sort eight provisions

Sort: Article 19, Article 40, Article 51A(a), Article 21A, Article 44, Article 51A(h), Article 24, Article 47. Working: Part III: 19, 21A, 24. Part IV: 40 (panchayats), 44 (uniform civil code), 47 (nutrition and public health). Part IVA: 51A(a), 51A(h). Counting: three, three and two make eight.

Worked example 2: odd one out

Which of these is not a Directive Principle: Article 39A, Article 43B, Article 21A, Article 48A? Article 39A (legal aid), 43B (cooperatives) and 48A (environment) are in Part IV. Article 21A is a fundamental right in Part III. The odd one out is 21A.

Worked example 3: same amendment, different parts

Match: (a) Article 21A, (b) Article 43B, (c) Article 51A(k) with (1) Part IV, (2) Part IVA, (3) Part III. Working: (a) is a right, so 3. (b) is a directive, so 1. (c) is a duty, so 2. Answer: a-3, b-1, c-2. Which of the three came from the 86th Amendment? (a) and (c), both in 2002; (b) came from the 97th Amendment in 2011.

Worked example 4: the environment

A student is asked: 'Article 48A and Article 51A(g) both protect the environment. What is the difference?' Answer: 48A is a directive to the State, in Part IV, and not enforceable. 51A(g) is a duty of the citizen, in Part IVA, and also not enforceable. Neither is a right. The right to a healthy environment has been read into Article 21 by the courts.

Key takeaways: sort by who is addressed; remember the same-subject table; the 86th Amendment gives 21A and 51A(k) together; neither Part IV nor Part IVA is enforceable.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Free legal aid as a directive is in

    1. Article 39A
    2. Article 21A
    3. Article 24
    4. Article 51A(k)
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 39A is in Part IV. Article 21A is a right.

  2. 2. A duty of the citizen to protect the natural environment is in

    1. Article 48A (State's directive)
    2. Article 21 (right to life)
    3. Article 51A(g) (citizen's duty)
    4. Article 47 (public health)
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 51A(g) is a duty; Article 48A is a directive.

  3. 3. Which of these is a fundamental right?

    1. Article 45
    2. Article 24
    3. Article 43B
    4. Article 51A(i)
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 24 prohibits child labour in hazardous work and is in Part III.

  4. 4. Which pair is correctly matched?

    1. Article 45: the right to education from six to fourteen
    2. Article 21A: a directive addressed to the State alone
    3. Article 48A: a duty placed upon every citizen of India
    4. Article 51A(k): duty of the parent or guardian
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Article 51A(k) is the duty of a parent or guardian. Article 45 is a directive, 21A a right and 48A a directive.

  5. 5. Which Amendment inserted Article 43B?

    1. The 97th
    2. The 42nd
    3. The 86th
    4. The 73rd
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 43B on cooperative societies was inserted by the 97th Amendment in 2011.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery