• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Timeline questions: ordering cases and amendments from 1950 to 2011

Place the Champakam, Golaknath, Kesavananda and Minerva Mills cases and the amendments that touched Part IV in the correct order and answer year-gap questions.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Chronology questions on Part IV ask you to arrange events or to find which came first. The facts are few, but they are easy to jumble. The best technique is a single timeline, learnt once, and the habit of linking each case to the amendment around it.

The timeline

Cases and amendments
YearEventLink to Part IV
1950Constitution commencesPart IV in force
1951State of Madras v. Champakam Dorairajan; First AmendmentFundamental Rights prevail over Directive Principles; the Amendment responds with Article 15(4)
1967Golaknath v. State of PunjabFundamental Rights cannot be amended by Article 368
197124th and 25th AmendmentsThe 25th inserts Article 31C, protecting laws for Article 39(b) and (c)
1973Kesavananda Bharati v. State of KeralaBasic structure; first part of Article 31C upheld, review-bar struck down
197642nd AmendmentAdds 39A, 43A, 48A and Part IVA; extends Article 31C to all Directive Principles
197844th AmendmentAdds clause (2) to Article 38
1980Minerva Mills v. Union of IndiaThe extension of Article 31C struck down; balance of Parts III and IV is basic structure
199273rd AmendmentArticle 40 leads to Part IX
200286th AmendmentArticle 21A, Article 45 changed, Article 51A(k)
201197th AmendmentArticle 43B

Next, keep a second small table of what the amendments added to Part IV, because dates for Articles are asked as often as dates for cases.

Amendments that changed Part IV
Amendment (year)Effect on Part IV
42nd (1976)Added Articles 39A, 43A and 48A; extended Article 31C
44th (1978)Added clause (2) to Article 38 on reducing inequalities
73rd (1992)Gave effect to Article 40 through Part IX
86th (2002)Changed Article 45; added Article 21A and Article 51A(k)
97th (2011)Added Article 43B on cooperative societies

1951 Champakam, 1967 Golaknath, 1973 Kesavananda, 1976 42nd Amendment, 1980 Minerva Mills. Cases and the amendments that answer them come in pairs: 1971 25th Amendment and 1973 Kesavananda; 1976 and 1980.

— Rule to remember

Worked example 1: arrange in order

Arrange: Minerva Mills, 25th Amendment, Champakam, 42nd Amendment, Kesavananda. Working: Champakam 1951; 25th Amendment 1971; Kesavananda 1973; 42nd Amendment 1976; Minerva Mills 1980. The correct order is Champakam, 25th, Kesavananda, 42nd, Minerva Mills.

Worked example 2: gaps

How many years passed between the 42nd Amendment and the 86th Amendment? 2002 minus 1976 equals 26. Between Kesavananda and Minerva Mills? 1980 minus 1973 equals 7. Between Champakam and Minerva Mills? 1980 minus 1951 equals 29. Be careful to subtract the earlier year from the later one.

Worked example 3: before or after?

A statement says: 'Article 39A was in the Constitution when Kesavananda was decided in 1973.' Article 39A was inserted by the 42nd Amendment in 1976, three years after 1973. So the statement is false. Another statement: 'Article 40 was in the Constitution in 1950.' True, since it is in the original text, though it led to Part IX only in 1992.

Worked example 4: which decade?

In which decade were the cooperative societies Article and the Article on education added? Article 21A and the changed Article 45 came in 2002, the 2000s; Article 43B came in 2011, the 2010s. A trap is to assume both came by the same Amendment.

Key takeaways: learn the sequence 1951, 1967, 1971, 1973, 1976, 1980; link each case to the amendment around it; compute gaps by subtraction; treat Articles inserted by amendments as absent before those years.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which of these is the earliest?

    1. Kesavananda Bharati
    2. Golaknath
    3. Champakam Dorairajan
    4. Minerva Mills
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Champakam was decided in 1951, Golaknath in 1967, Kesavananda in 1973 and Minerva Mills in 1980.

  2. 2. Article 31C was inserted by the

    1. 24th Amendment
    2. 42nd Amendment
    3. 25th Amendment
    4. 44th Amendment
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 31C was inserted by the 25th Amendment in 1971.

  3. 3. Minerva Mills (1980) came

    1. Before the 42nd Amendment
    2. After the 42nd Amendment
    3. Before Kesavananda
    4. In 1976
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The 42nd Amendment was in 1976 and Minerva Mills in 1980, which struck down its extension of Article 31C.

  4. 4. How many years separate Kesavananda Bharati (1973) and Minerva Mills (1980)?

    1. Seven
    2. Six
    3. Eight
    4. Nine
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 1980 minus 1973 equals seven.

  5. 5. Article 43B was inserted in

    1. 1976
    2. 2002
    3. 2011
    4. 1992
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The 97th Amendment of 2011 inserted Article 43B on cooperative societies.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery