• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Scenario and assertion-reason practice on Part IV

Apply the rules of Part IV to short scenarios and assertion-reason questions, using Article 37, Article 31C and the Articles added by amendments.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The last stage of practice is applying what you know to a situation. Exam questions on Part IV give a short story, such as a law, a petition or an order, and ask what the position is. The same rules solve them: Part IV is not enforceable, it guides the State, and it works through laws, amendments and the courts' reading of rights.

The rules to apply

  • Article 37: Part IV is not enforceable by any court, but is fundamental in the governance of the country.
  • Article 31C (first part): a law giving effect to Article 39(b) or (c) cannot be challenged for violating Article 14 or 19, as upheld in Kesavananda.
  • After Minerva Mills: Parts III and IV are balanced; neither is absolute.
  • Reading into rights: courts use Part IV to give meaning to Article 21 and to test restrictions.
  • For assertion-reason: judge A, judge R, then ask whether R explains A.

Scenario method: name the Article, decide if it is a right, a directive or a duty, then ask whether a court can enforce it directly.

— Rule to remember

Worked example 1: the petition

A group petitions the High Court to order the State to enact a uniform civil code, citing Article 44. What is the position? Article 44 is a Directive Principle, not enforceable under Article 37. The court has no power to order a legislature to make a law. The petition fails on that ground, though a court may remark on the matter in a judgment, as the Supreme Court did in Shah Bano and Sarla Mudgal.

Worked example 2: a law on resources

A state law takes over some private forests to distribute them for the common good, and is challenged as violating Article 14. How will the court view it? If the law truly gives effect to the policy in Article 39(b), the first part of Article 31C protects it from a challenge under Article 14 or 19, as the Supreme Court upheld in Kesavananda. The court can still check whether the law really serves that policy. A law to serve a different Directive Principle could not claim this protection after Minerva Mills.

Worked example 3: assertion-reason

A: Directive Principles cannot be enforced by a court. R: Article 37 says they are not enforceable by any court. Both are true and R explains A, so option 1.

A: Article 21A is a fundamental right. R: Article 45 directs the State to provide early childhood care and education. Both are true, but R does not explain A, since Article 45 concerns children below six and Article 21A concerns six to fourteen. Option 2.

A: Fundamental Duties can be enforced by a writ. R: Fundamental Duties are in Part IVA. A is false, R is true. Option 4.

Worked example 4: a worker's claim

A woman doing the same work as a man is paid less in a government department and cites Article 39(d). What is the best legal route? Article 39(d) is a Directive Principle and cannot be enforced alone. But read with Articles 14 and 16, the Supreme Court in Randhir Singh enforced 'equal pay for equal work'. The writ is under Articles 14 and 16, guided by Article 39(d).

Key takeaways: name the Article, classify it, and decide whether a court can enforce it directly; Part IV works through laws and through Articles 14, 16 and 21; keep the Article 31C story in order: 1971, 1973, 1976, 1980.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A court is asked to order the legislature to enact a uniform civil code. The court will

    1. Order Parliament to enact it within a year
    2. Order the Governor to enact it
    3. Decline, since Article 44 is not enforceable
    4. Enact it itself
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 44 is a Directive Principle and, under Article 37, cannot be enforced by a court.

  2. 2. A: Directive Principles cannot be enforced by a court. R: Article 37 says so. The correct option is

    1. A true, R false
    2. Both true, R explains A
    3. Both true, R does not explain A
    4. A false, R true
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 37 is exactly the provision that makes Part IV non-enforceable.

  3. 3. A: Article 21A is a fundamental right. R: Article 21A was inserted by the 42nd Amendment. The correct option is

    1. Both true, R explains A
    2. A false, R true
    3. Both true, R does not explain A
    4. A true, R false
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Article 21A is a fundamental right, so A is true. It was inserted by the 86th Amendment in 2002, so R is false.

  4. 4. Which case enforced 'equal pay for equal work' with the help of Article 39(d)?

    1. Randhir Singh
    2. Olga Tellis
    3. Hussainara Khatoon
    4. Minerva Mills
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Randhir Singh v. Union of India (1982) read Article 39(d) together with Articles 14 and 16.

  5. 5. A law is made to give effect to Article 39(b). After Kesavananda, it is protected from challenge under

    1. Article 21 alone, since it protects life and liberty
    2. Article 32 alone, since it provides the remedy
    3. Articles 14 and 19, under the first part of Article 31C
    4. Article 226 alone, since it concerns the High Courts
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The first part of Article 31C, upheld in Kesavananda, protects such laws from a challenge under Articles 14 and 19.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery