- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Original, appellate and special jurisdiction of the Supreme Court in detail
Go beyond the list of jurisdictions: what Article 131 covers and leaves out, how appeals from High Courts reach the Supreme Court, and what special leave under Article 136 means.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Earlier you learned the names of the Supreme Court's jurisdictions. Now we look inside them. The main skill is to decide, for a given case, which route brings it to the Court and which article applies. We take them one at a time with gentle examples.
Original jurisdiction: Article 131
A court has original jurisdiction when a case can begin in that court itself. Under Article 131 the Supreme Court has exclusive original jurisdiction in disputes between the Union and one or more States, between the Union and some States on one side and other States on the other, and between two or more States. Two conditions matter. First, the dispute must involve a question, of law or fact, on which the existence or extent of a legal right depends. Second, a dispute between a State and a private person, or between two private persons, is not covered, so it cannot begin in the Supreme Court under this article. Disputes arising out of certain old treaties and agreements are also kept outside.
Appellate jurisdiction: Articles 132 to 134
Appellate jurisdiction is the power to hear appeals from a lower court. Appeals from a High Court reach the Supreme Court in three families of cases.
| Kind of case | Article | Broad idea |
|---|---|---|
| Constitutional | 132 | The High Court certifies that the case involves a substantial question of law about interpreting the Constitution |
| Civil | 133 | The High Court certifies a substantial question of law of general importance that needs the Supreme Court's decision |
| Criminal | 134 | For example, the High Court reversed an acquittal and sentenced the accused to death, or took a case from a lower court and sentenced to death, or certifies the case as fit for appeal |
Certificates of this kind are issued by the High Court under Article 134A. If the High Court refuses a certificate, the Supreme Court can still be approached through a special route.
Special leave: Article 136
Under Article 136 the Supreme Court may, in its discretion, grant special leave to appeal from any judgment, decree, order or sentence passed by any court or tribunal in India. The exception is a court or tribunal set up under a law relating to the armed forces. Because the power is discretionary, nobody has a right to special leave; the Court grants it when there is a serious question of law or a grave injustice.
Other powers
- Article 137: review of its own judgments, subject to law made by Parliament and the Court's rules.
- Article 139: Parliament may give the Supreme Court power to issue directions, orders and writs for purposes other than those in Article 32.
- Article 139A: the Court may transfer certain cases between itself and High Courts, or from one High Court to another.
Worked example 1: which jurisdiction
Question: Two States quarrel over whether one of them has a legal right to use certain land. Where does the case begin? Working: The parties are States, and the dispute concerns a legal right. That is a dispute covered by Article 131, which only the Supreme Court can hear at the first stage. Answer: In the Supreme Court, in its original jurisdiction.
Worked example 2: a private person and a State
Question: A private company and a State Government dispute a contract. Can the company file directly under Article 131? Working: Article 131 requires parties on both sides to be the Union or States. One side here is a private company. The suit goes to the usual civil courts, and the Supreme Court may be reached later by appeal. Answer: No.
Worked example 3: refused certificate
Question: A High Court refuses to issue a certificate for appeal in a civil case. Is the matter finally closed? Working: The ordinary route under Article 133 needs the certificate, but Article 136 allows the Supreme Court to grant special leave in its discretion. Answer: Not necessarily; the person may apply for special leave.
Article 131: only the Union and States as parties, and a legal right at stake. Articles 132 to 134: appeals with certificates. Article 136: special leave, a matter of discretion.
Key takeaways
- Original jurisdiction under Article 131 is exclusive and limited to Union-State and State-State disputes.
- Appeals from High Courts come under Articles 132 to 134; certificates come under Article 134A.
- Article 136 is wide but discretionary, and it reaches tribunals as well as courts.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these disputes can begin directly in the Supreme Court under Article 131?
- A dispute between two States on a legal right
- A dispute between a citizen and a State
- A dispute between two companies
- A dispute between two private citizens
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 131 covers only disputes in which the Union and/or States are the parties on both sides, and a legal right must be involved.
-
2. A High Court certifies a case as involving a substantial question about interpreting the Constitution. Which article deals with the appeal?
- Article 131
- Article 133
- Article 136
- Article 132
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 132 provides for appeals in cases involving a substantial question of law about the interpretation of the Constitution.
-
3. Special leave to appeal under Article 136 is
- a matter of right in every case
- granted only to the Union Government
- available only against High Court judgments
- granted at the discretion of the Supreme Court
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 136 gives the Court a discretionary power; no one has a right to special leave.
-
4. Which article lets the Supreme Court review its own judgments?
- Article 139
- Article 143
- Article 137
- Article 129
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 137 is the review power. Article 143 is advisory jurisdiction; Article 129 makes it a court of record.
-
5. Certificates for appeal to the Supreme Court are issued by the
- Governor of the State
- High Court concerned
- President of India
- Law Commission
Show answer
Answer: B. Under Article 134A the High Court gives or refuses a certificate for appeal.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.