- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Running the Supreme Court: acting and ad hoc judges, benches and precedent
Learn how the Court works from day to day: acting Chief Justice, ad hoc and retired judges, constitution benches, rules of court, the bar on practising after retirement and the binding force of precedent.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A court is more than its judges; it needs rules for who sits, how many sit, and what happens when a seat is empty. The Constitution answers each of these in a few short articles. This lesson walks through them in the order a student might wonder about them.
When the Chief Justice is absent
Under Article 126, if the office of Chief Justice of India is vacant, or the Chief Justice is absent or unable to perform the duties, the President appoints another Supreme Court judge to perform them. Article 124(2) says other judges are appointed by the President after consulting such judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts as the President thinks necessary, and the Chief Justice of India is always consulted in appointing a judge other than the Chief Justice.
Ad hoc judges and retired judges
- Article 127 (ad hoc judge): if there are not enough judges to hold or continue a session, the Chief Justice of India, with the previous consent of the President and after consulting the Chief Justice of the High Court concerned, may request a High Court judge who is qualified to be a Supreme Court judge to sit for a period.
- Article 128 (retired judges): the Chief Justice of India may, with the President's previous consent, request a retired Supreme Court or High Court judge to sit and act as a Supreme Court judge, with the judge's consent.
- Article 130 (seat): the Court sits in Delhi, or at other places the Chief Justice appoints with the President's approval.
Benches and rules of court
Most cases are heard by small benches. Article 145(3) fixes a minimum of five judges for deciding any case that involves a substantial question of law about interpreting the Constitution, and for hearing a reference from the President under Article 143. Such a bench is called a constitution bench. A larger bench can reconsider a decision of a smaller one, which is why important questions are sent to a larger bench. Article 145(1) allows the Court, with the approval of the President and subject to law made by Parliament, to make rules about its practice and procedure. Officers and staff of the Court are appointed by the Chief Justice (Article 146).
Rules about judges after retirement and about pay
Under Article 124(7), a person who has been a Supreme Court judge cannot plead or act in any court or before any authority in India after retirement. Salaries and allowances of judges are charged on the Consolidated Fund of India and cannot be changed to a judge's disadvantage after appointment, except under a Financial Emergency.
Precedent: why Article 141 matters
The law declared by the Supreme Court is binding on all courts in India (Article 141). In a judgment, the ratio decidendi is the legal principle that was necessary for the decision, and it binds lower courts. An obiter dictum is a remark made in passing; it is respected but does not bind. Article 144 adds that all civil and judicial authorities must act in aid of the Supreme Court.
Worked example 1: size of bench
Question: A case needs the Court to decide a substantial question about the interpretation of the Constitution. A bench of three judges has been formed. Is it enough? Working: Article 145(3) requires at least five judges for such a case. Three is below the minimum. Answer: No; a bench of at least five is needed.
Worked example 2: binding force
Question: The Supreme Court decides a question of law in a case from one State. Is a High Court in a different State bound by it? Working: Article 141 makes the law declared by the Supreme Court binding on all courts in India, not just those in the State of the case. Answer: Yes.
Worked example 3: after retirement
Question: Can a retired Supreme Court judge appear as an advocate before a High Court? Working: Article 124(7) bars such a person from pleading or acting before any court or authority in India. Answer: No.
Five judges at least for constitutional questions; Article 141 binds all courts; no pleading after retiring from the Supreme Court; the ratio binds, the obiter does not.
Key takeaways
- Article 126 deals with an acting Chief Justice; Articles 127 and 128 with ad hoc and retired judges.
- Article 145(3) sets the minimum five-judge bench for constitutional questions.
- Ratio decidendi is binding; obiter dicta are persuasive only.
Check your understanding
-
1. The minimum number of judges needed to decide a substantial question about interpreting the Constitution is
- two
- three
- five
- seven
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 145(3) fixes a minimum of five judges for such cases and for references under Article 143.
-
2. Which article provides for the appointment of an acting Chief Justice of India?
- Article 126
- Article 125
- Article 127
- Article 130
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 126 allows the President to appoint another judge to perform the duties when the Chief Justice's office is vacant or the Chief Justice is absent.
-
3. An ad hoc judge of the Supreme Court is drawn from the
- High Court judges qualified for the Court
- senior advocates chosen by the Bar
- district judges picked by a Governor
- retired officers named by the President
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 127 allows a High Court judge qualified for the Supreme Court to be requested to sit as an ad hoc judge.
-
4. The part of a judgment that has binding force on lower courts is called
- obiter dictum
- a dissenting note
- a mere headnote
- ratio decidendi
Show answer
Answer: D. The ratio decidendi is the legal principle necessary for the decision. Obiter dicta are remarks made in passing.
-
5. After retirement, a Supreme Court judge may not plead before
- the Supreme Court and High Courts only
- any court or authority in India
- a High Court or tribunal only
- a tribunal or commission only
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 124(7) bars pleading or acting before any court or authority in India.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.