- Foundation
- About 11 min
- 5 practice questions
The Indian judiciary: an integrated system and its independence
Understand the single integrated court system, judicial review and the safeguards that keep judges independent.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The judiciary interprets the law, settles disputes and protects the Constitution. In India there is one integrated system of courts: the Supreme Court at the top, High Courts below it, and subordinate courts under them. Unlike a federation such as the USA, India does not have separate court systems for the Union and the States.
Features
- Single hierarchy: Supreme Court, High Courts, district and subordinate courts.
- Judicial review: courts can strike down laws and executive actions that violate the Constitution.
- Independence: judges are protected from pressure by the legislature and the executive.
- Guardian of the Constitution and of Fundamental Rights.
How independence is protected
- Security of tenure: a Supreme Court judge can be removed only by a special process.
- Salaries and allowances are fixed and are charged on the Consolidated Fund; they are not voted by Parliament and cannot be reduced to the judge's disadvantage except in a financial emergency.
- Conduct of judges cannot be discussed in Parliament except on a motion for removal.
- The Supreme Court can punish for contempt, since it is a court of record.
- Article 50 (Directive Principle) calls for the separation of the judiciary from the executive in public services.
Worked examples
Example 1. Is there a separate State Supreme Court? No. The Supreme Court is the apex court for the whole country, and each State has a High Court.
Example 2. A law violates Article 14. Who can declare it void? A High Court or the Supreme Court, through judicial review.
| Level | Court |
|---|---|
| Top | Supreme Court |
| State level | High Court |
| District level | District courts |
| Below district | Subordinate courts |
One integrated judiciary, independent of the executive, guardian of the Constitution.
- India has a single integrated judiciary headed by the Supreme Court.
- Judicial review makes courts the guardian of the Constitution.
- Tenure, salary and contempt powers protect judicial independence.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Indian court system is best described as
- a single integrated system
- a dual system with separate Union and State courts
- a set of independent State court systems
- a system with no court above the High Courts
Show answer
Answer: A. India has one hierarchy: the Supreme Court, High Courts and subordinate courts. The USA, by contrast, has separate federal and state courts.
-
2. Salaries of Supreme Court judges are
- voted every year by Parliament
- charged on the Consolidated Fund and not voted by Parliament
- fixed by the Chief Justice
- paid from the Contingency Fund
Show answer
Answer: B. Charging salaries on the Consolidated Fund protects judges from pressure; they cannot be reduced to their disadvantage except in a financial emergency.
-
3. Which Directive Principle calls for separating the judiciary from the executive?
- Article 39A
- Article 44
- Article 50
- Article 48
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 50 directs the State to separate the judiciary from the executive in its public services.
-
4. The power of courts to declare a law unconstitutional is called
- judicial activism
- contempt of court
- advisory jurisdiction
- judicial review
Show answer
Answer: D. Judicial review lets courts strike down laws and actions that violate the Constitution.
-
5. Which of these does NOT protect the independence of judges?
- Parliament can freely debate a judge's conduct at any time
- Security of tenure
- Salaries charged on the Consolidated Fund
- Power to punish for contempt
Show answer
Answer: A. The conduct of judges cannot be discussed in Parliament except on a motion for removal; free debate would weaken independence.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.