- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Judicial review, PIL, activism and contempt: concept traps
Practise what judicial review covers, what a PIL can and cannot do, how suo motu action and amicus curiae work, and the two kinds of contempt, with true-false statement drills.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Concept questions on the judiciary are usually statements to judge true or false. The wrong statements are built from a small set of exaggerations: 'always', 'only', 'any'. This lesson collects the right versions.
Judicial review
Judicial review is the power of courts to examine laws, orders and actions of the legislature and executive and to declare them void if they violate the Constitution. It applies to legislation (Parliament and State Legislatures), to executive and administrative action, and, through appeals, to the decisions of lower courts and tribunals. Its textual supports include Articles 13, 32, 131, 136, 226 and 227. Courts do not review the wisdom of a policy; they review its legality.
Public interest litigation: what and what not
- PIL relaxes locus standi: a person who is not personally injured may sue on behalf of persons who cannot approach the court.
- In epistolary jurisdiction a letter or postcard to the Court can be treated as a petition.
- The Court may act suo motu, on its own motion, on a report or information.
- An amicus curiae is a friend of the court, a lawyer appointed to assist the Court and not representing a party.
- PIL is meant for the public good, not for personal or private disputes, and the Court may impose costs on a petition filed with a motive of publicity or private gain.
Judicial activism and restraint
Judicial activism refers to courts taking an active role in protecting rights and filling gaps, as in the Vishaka guidelines. Judicial restraint is the opposite attitude: courts leave policy to the legislature and the executive. The term judicial overreach is used when critics say the courts have entered the field of lawmaking. These are ideas, not legal rules, so exam statements about them are about meaning.
Contempt of court
| Kind | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Civil contempt | Wilful disobedience of a judgment, order or writ, or wilful breach of an undertaking given to a court | Refusing to obey a court's order to pay |
| Criminal contempt | Scandalising or lowering the authority of a court, prejudicing a trial, or interfering with the administration of justice | Publishing a statement that obstructs a trial |
Both the Supreme Court (Article 129) and the High Courts (Article 215) are courts of record and have power to punish for contempt.
Worked example 1: true or false
Statement: 'In a PIL, only the injured person can approach the court.' Working: PIL relaxes locus standi; a public-spirited person may file for others. Answer: False.
Worked example 2: classify the contempt
Question: A person deliberately ignores a court's order directing the release of wages. Which contempt? Working: Wilful disobedience of an order is civil contempt. Answer: Civil contempt.
Worked example 3: who is an amicus
Question: A senior lawyer is asked by the Court to help it understand a complex law, without representing either side. What is the lawyer called? Working: A friend of the court. Answer: Amicus curiae.
Judicial review tests legality, not policy wisdom. PIL relaxes standing but not good faith. Civil contempt is disobedience; criminal contempt is scandalising, prejudicing or obstructing.
Key takeaways
- Judicial review covers legislative, executive and lower-court action.
- PIL tools: relaxed standing, letter petitions, suo motu action, amicus curiae.
- Contempt: civil is disobedience; criminal is harm to the authority or process of the court.
Check your understanding
-
1. Disobeying a court's order wilfully is
- criminal contempt
- judicial review
- civil contempt
- a public interest case
Show answer
Answer: C. Wilful disobedience of a court order is civil contempt under the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971.
-
2. A lawyer appointed by the Court to assist it without representing a party is called
- an advocate-on-record
- a standing counsel
- a public prosecutor
- an amicus curiae
Show answer
Answer: D. An amicus curiae is a friend of the court.
-
3. When the Court itself takes up a matter on its own motion, it is called
- review jurisdiction
- suo motu action
- original jurisdiction
- special leave grant
Show answer
Answer: B. Suo motu means on its own motion.
-
4. Judicial review tests whether a law
- violates the Constitution
- is wise as a policy
- has public support
- is liked by the executive
Show answer
Answer: A. Courts test legality, not the wisdom of policy.
-
5. Treating a letter as a writ petition is called
- advisory jurisdiction
- original jurisdiction
- epistolary jurisdiction
- appellate jurisdiction
Show answer
Answer: C. Epistolary jurisdiction developed in PIL.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.