- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Landmark judgments and the doctrines they created: matching practice
Match each landmark case to the principle it laid down, arrange the amending-power cases in order and avoid the usual swaps between look-alike case names.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Case-law questions ask you to match a name with a principle or to put cases in order. Do not try to remember facts of each case. Remember one sentence for each case, and a short story that links them.
The story of the amending power
Can Parliament amend Fundamental Rights? In Shankari Prasad (1951) and Sajjan Singh (1965) the Supreme Court said yes: an amendment under Article 368 is not 'law' under Article 13. In Golaknath (1967) it said no: Parliament cannot take away or abridge Fundamental Rights. In Kesavananda Bharati (1973) the Court found a middle path: Parliament can amend any part of the Constitution, including Fundamental Rights, but cannot destroy its basic structure. In Minerva Mills (1980) the Court added that the limited amending power is itself part of the basic structure.
The Article 21 cases
- A. K. Gopalan (1950): a narrow reading; 'procedure established by law' meant any procedure that a valid law prescribes.
- Maneka Gandhi (1978): the procedure must be fair, just and reasonable, so Articles 14, 19 and 21 are read together.
- Hussainara Khatoon (1979): speedy trial and free legal aid are part of Article 21; an early example of public interest litigation on behalf of undertrial prisoners.
- Olga Tellis (1985): the right to livelihood is part of the right to life.
Cases on the judiciary and the executive
| Case | Principle |
|---|---|
| S. P. Gupta (1981), the First Judges case | The executive's view had primacy in judicial appointments |
| Second Judges case (1993) | The Chief Justice's view, after consulting colleagues, has primacy; the collegium system begins |
| Third Judges case (1998) | Opinion given on a Presidential reference; collegium of the Chief Justice and the four senior-most judges for the Supreme Court |
| S. R. Bommai (1994) | A proclamation under Article 356 is open to judicial review |
| L. Chandra Kumar (1997) | Decisions of tribunals can be tested before the High Courts; judicial review is part of the basic structure |
| I. R. Coelho (2007) | Laws placed in the Ninth Schedule after the Kesavananda Bharati decision can be tested against the basic structure |
| Vishaka (1997) | Guidelines against sexual harassment at the workplace issued before a law existed |
Worked example 1: ordering
Question: Arrange in order of time: Golaknath, Shankari Prasad, Kesavananda Bharati, Sajjan Singh. Working: Shankari Prasad (1951), Sajjan Singh (1965), Golaknath (1967), Kesavananda Bharati (1973). Answer: Shankari Prasad, Sajjan Singh, Golaknath, Kesavananda Bharati.
Worked example 2: matching
Question: Which case held that Parliament may amend any part of the Constitution but may not alter its basic structure, and what happened to the earlier Golaknath view? Working: That is Kesavananda Bharati (1973). It did not allow unlimited amendment, so Golaknath's total bar on amending Fundamental Rights was overruled. Answer: Kesavananda Bharati; Golaknath's view was overruled.
Worked example 3: spot the swap
Question: Which case widened Article 21 by requiring a fair, just and reasonable procedure: A. K. Gopalan or Maneka Gandhi? Working: Gopalan read the article narrowly. Maneka Gandhi made procedure subject to fairness. Answer: Maneka Gandhi.
Shankari Prasad and Sajjan Singh: amendable. Golaknath: not amendable. Kesavananda: amendable but not the basic structure. Minerva Mills: limited amending power is basic. Gopalan narrow, Maneka wide.
Key takeaways
- Keep the amending-power cases in order of date.
- Gopalan and Maneka Gandhi are opposite readings of Article 21.
- Judges cases: First (1981) executive primacy; Second (1993) collegium; Third (1998) collegium of five.
Check your understanding
-
1. The basic structure doctrine was laid down in
- Golaknath v State of Punjab
- Kesavananda Bharati v State of Kerala
- Shankari Prasad v Union of India
- Sajjan Singh v State of Rajasthan
Show answer
Answer: B. Kesavananda Bharati (1973) held that Parliament cannot destroy the basic structure.
-
2. The case holding that Fundamental Rights cannot be amended at all was
- Golaknath v State of Punjab
- Kesavananda Bharati v State of Kerala
- Shankari Prasad v Union of India
- Minerva Mills v Union of India
Show answer
Answer: A. Golaknath (1967). Kesavananda Bharati later overruled this view.
-
3. Which case first introduced the collegium system?
- Second Judges case (1993)
- First Judges case (1981)
- Bommai case (1994)
- Minerva Mills case
Show answer
Answer: A. The Second Judges case gave primacy to the Chief Justice's collegiate opinion.
-
4. Which case held that a proclamation under Article 356 can be judicially reviewed?
- Maneka Gandhi
- Vishaka
- Olga Tellis
- S. R. Bommai
Show answer
Answer: D. S. R. Bommai (1994) held that a proclamation of President's rule is open to judicial review.
-
5. A. K. Gopalan is associated with
- a wide reading of Article 21
- the basic structure doctrine
- a narrow reading of Article 21
- free legal aid as a right
Show answer
Answer: C. Gopalan (1950) read 'procedure established by law' narrowly; Maneka Gandhi later widened it.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.