- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Mixed practice: Supreme Court against High Court, removal arithmetic and statement questions
Compare the Supreme Court and High Courts point by point, work out the votes needed to remove a judge, and apply a method for statement and assertion-reason questions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Mixed questions put two courts side by side and ask you to spot the difference. This lesson gives you a comparison table, a method for numerical questions on removal, and a checklist for statement questions. The numbers in the worked examples, such as seat counts, populations, dates and amounts for imaginary cases, are illustrative and are not official figures.
Supreme Court against High Court
| Point | Supreme Court | High Court |
|---|---|---|
| Appointed by | President, after consultation with judges | President, after consulting the Chief Justice of India, the Governor and the Chief Justice of the High Court |
| Qualification | Citizen; High Court judge for 5 years, or High Court advocate for 10 years, or distinguished jurist | Citizen; judicial office for 10 years, or High Court advocate for 10 years |
| Retirement age | 65 | 62 |
| Writ power | Article 32, for Fundamental Rights | Article 226, for Fundamental Rights and any other purpose |
| Court of record | Article 129 | Article 215 |
| Removal | Address of both Houses, majority of total membership and two-thirds of members present and voting | Same procedure |
| Advisory jurisdiction | Article 143 | None |
| Original jurisdiction in Union-State disputes | Article 131 | None |
Removal arithmetic
Removal needs an address from each House, passed by (1) a majority of the total membership of that House and (2) at least two-thirds of the members present and voting. Both conditions must be met, so the number you need is the larger of the two.
Worked example 1: a large attendance
Question: In an illustrative House with 540 members, 450 are present and voting. How many votes are needed? Working: Two-thirds of 450 is 300. A majority of the total membership of 540 is 271 (more than half of 540, which is 270). The larger figure is 300. Answer: 300 votes.
Worked example 2: a small attendance
Question: In an illustrative House with 245 members, only 100 are present and voting. How many votes are needed? Working: Two-thirds of 100 is 66.67, so at least 67. A majority of the total membership of 245 is 123 (more than 122.5). The larger figure is 123. Answer: 123 votes. The total-membership condition is the one that matters when attendance is low.
Worked example 3: years in service
Question: A person becomes a High Court judge at 52 and is later appointed to the Supreme Court at 58. For how many years in all can the person hold judicial office, if the person serves until retirement? Working: From 52 to 58 as a High Court judge is 6 years. As a Supreme Court judge the retirement age is 65, so 65 - 58 = 7 more years. Total 6 + 7 = 13 years. Answer: 13 years.
A method for statement questions
- Read each statement alone and decide true or false before looking at the options.
- Underline words like 'only', 'always', 'any', 'all'. Such statements are usually false.
- Check the court: many wrong statements give a Supreme Court feature to a High Court.
- Check the number: 62 or 65, five or ten years, one-half or two-thirds.
- Choose the option that matches your true-false pattern.
Assertion and reason
Assertion: A High Court can issue writs for purposes beyond Fundamental Rights. Reason: Article 226 says writs may be issued for enforcement of Fundamental Rights and for any other purpose. Working: The assertion is true, and the reason is the correct explanation. Answer: Both true, and the reason explains the assertion.
Larger of the two numbers: a majority of the total membership, and two-thirds of those present and voting. Supreme Court 65, High Court 62; Article 32 for rights only, Article 226 for rights and any other purpose.
Key takeaways
- Use the table to catch swapped features.
- In removal arithmetic, compute both thresholds and choose the larger.
- Words like 'only' deserve suspicion.
Check your understanding
-
1. In a House of 300 members with 270 present and voting, the minimum votes needed to remove a judge is
- 151
- 163
- 201
- 180
Show answer
Answer: D. Two-thirds of 270 is 180. A majority of the total membership of 300 is 151. The larger figure is 180, which is the answer.
-
2. Advisory jurisdiction under Article 143 belongs to the
- High Court
- District Court
- Supreme Court
- Sessions Court
Show answer
Answer: C. Only the Supreme Court has advisory jurisdiction under Article 143.
-
3. A High Court judge retires at 62. A person appointed at age 50 and retiring at the normal age serves for
- 10 years
- 12 years
- 15 years
- 8 years
Show answer
Answer: B. 62 - 50 = 12.
-
4. The statement 'High Courts can issue writs only for Fundamental Rights' is
- false, because of Article 226
- true, because of Article 32
- true, because of Article 227
- false, since writs are not allowed
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 226 allows writs for any other purpose too.
-
5. A qualification of ten years as an advocate of a High Court applies to
- Supreme Court judges only
- High Court judges only
- neither kind of judge
- judges of both courts
Show answer
Answer: D. The ten-year advocate route exists for both courts, though the Supreme Court also has other routes.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.