- Practice
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Constitutional versus non-constitutional: comparison
Practise the differences in origin, independence and removal between constitutional and non-constitutional bodies.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A direct comparison is a typical question. Learn the dimensions along which the two groups differ.
Comparison
| Feature | Constitutional | Non-constitutional |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Constitution | Act or resolution |
| Security of tenure | Written into the Constitution | Depends on the Act or resolution |
| Abolition | Needs a constitutional amendment | Can be done by an Act or by executive decision |
| Examples | Election Commission, CAG, UPSC | NHRC, CVC, NITI Aayog |
Worked example 1: abolition
Question: Why can NITI Aayog be replaced more easily than the CAG? Working: NITI Aayog exists by executive decision; the CAG by Article 148. Answer: The CAG needs a constitutional amendment to abolish.
Worked example 2: type
Question: The Finance Commission is under Article 280. What type? Working: Named in the Constitution. Answer: Constitutional.
Constitutional: protected by the text. Non-constitutional: protected only by the Act or order that created it.
Key takeaways: Tenure protection and ease of abolition separate the two groups.
Check your understanding
-
1. Abolishing a constitutional body requires
- only an executive decision
- only a court order
- only a state law
- a constitutional amendment
Show answer
Answer: D. A body created by the Constitution can be abolished only by amending the Constitution.
-
2. The Finance Commission is provided for in Article 280. What type of body is it?
- Statutory
- Executive
- Constitutional
- Non-statutory advisory
Show answer
Answer: C. A body named in the Constitution is constitutional.
-
3. The security of tenure of a non-constitutional body's members
- is written into the Constitution
- depends on the Act or resolution that created it
- is decided by each member
- does not exist in any form
Show answer
Answer: B. For constitutional bodies tenure protection is in the Constitution; for others it depends on the Act or resolution.
-
4. Which of these is non-constitutional?
- Central Vigilance Commission
- Finance Commission
- Union Public Service Commission
- Election Commission
Show answer
Answer: A. The CVC is statutory. The Finance Commission, UPSC and Election Commission are constitutional.
-
5. Why can NITI Aayog be replaced more easily than the CAG?
- NITI Aayog is a court
- The CAG was set up by a Cabinet resolution
- NITI Aayog is named in the Constitution
- NITI Aayog exists by executive decision, while the CAG exists under Article 148
Show answer
Answer: D. An executive body can be replaced by executive decision; abolishing the CAG would need a constitutional amendment.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.