• Practice
  • About 12 min
  • 5 practice questions

Constitutional versus non-constitutional: comparison

Practise the differences in origin, independence and removal between constitutional and non-constitutional bodies.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

A direct comparison is a typical question. Learn the dimensions along which the two groups differ.

Comparison

Two groups
FeatureConstitutionalNon-constitutional
SourceConstitutionAct or resolution
Security of tenureWritten into the ConstitutionDepends on the Act or resolution
AbolitionNeeds a constitutional amendmentCan be done by an Act or by executive decision
ExamplesElection Commission, CAG, UPSCNHRC, CVC, NITI Aayog

Worked example 1: abolition

Question: Why can NITI Aayog be replaced more easily than the CAG? Working: NITI Aayog exists by executive decision; the CAG by Article 148. Answer: The CAG needs a constitutional amendment to abolish.

Worked example 2: type

Question: The Finance Commission is under Article 280. What type? Working: Named in the Constitution. Answer: Constitutional.

Constitutional: protected by the text. Non-constitutional: protected only by the Act or order that created it.

— Core contrast

Key takeaways: Tenure protection and ease of abolition separate the two groups.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Abolishing a constitutional body requires

    1. only an executive decision
    2. only a court order
    3. only a state law
    4. a constitutional amendment
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A body created by the Constitution can be abolished only by amending the Constitution.

  2. 2. The Finance Commission is provided for in Article 280. What type of body is it?

    1. Statutory
    2. Executive
    3. Constitutional
    4. Non-statutory advisory
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A body named in the Constitution is constitutional.

  3. 3. The security of tenure of a non-constitutional body's members

    1. is written into the Constitution
    2. depends on the Act or resolution that created it
    3. is decided by each member
    4. does not exist in any form
    Show answer

    Answer: B. For constitutional bodies tenure protection is in the Constitution; for others it depends on the Act or resolution.

  4. 4. Which of these is non-constitutional?

    1. Central Vigilance Commission
    2. Finance Commission
    3. Union Public Service Commission
    4. Election Commission
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The CVC is statutory. The Finance Commission, UPSC and Election Commission are constitutional.

  5. 5. Why can NITI Aayog be replaced more easily than the CAG?

    1. NITI Aayog is a court
    2. The CAG was set up by a Cabinet resolution
    3. NITI Aayog is named in the Constitution
    4. NITI Aayog exists by executive decision, while the CAG exists under Article 148
    Show answer

    Answer: D. An executive body can be replaced by executive decision; abolishing the CAG would need a constitutional amendment.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery