- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Status changes: bodies that moved from executive to statutory or constitutional
Recognise the exam favourites whose type changed over time, and answer 'what is it today?' and 'how did it begin?' correctly.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The same body can have more than one answer in a question: 'how did it begin?' and 'what is it today?'. Examiners love this because a student who memorised only one fact gets half of them wrong. This lesson collects the bodies whose type changed, with the dates that matter.
The main stories
| Body | How it began | What changed |
|---|---|---|
| Central Vigilance Commission | Resolution, 1964 | Statutory under the CVC Act, 2003 |
| SEBI | Non-statutory board, 1988 | Statutory powers under the SEBI Act, 1992 |
| Minorities Commission | Resolution, 1978 | Statutory as the NCM under the NCM Act, 1992 |
| National Commission for Backward Classes | Statutory, 1993 | Constitutional status under the 102nd Amendment, Article 338B, 2018 |
| Commission for SCs and STs | Special Officer; later a joint commission (65th Amendment, 1990) | Two commissions under Articles 338 and 338A (89th Amendment, 2003) |
| Planning Commission | Cabinet resolution, 1950 | Replaced by NITI Aayog, another executive body, in 2015 |
Three directions of change appear here. Executive to statutory (CVC, SEBI, Minorities Commission): Parliament gave the body a law of its own. Statutory to constitutional (the Backward Classes Commission): the Constitution was amended to name the body. One body replaced by another (Planning Commission to NITI Aayog): the type stayed the same.
Reading the time in the question
Look for time words. 'Originally', 'first', 'at the time of its creation' ask how the body began. 'Today', 'at present', 'now' ask its current type. A question that says 'which of these was ever a constitutional body?' has a different answer from one that says 'which is a constitutional body now?'. The National Commission for Backward Classes, statutory from 1993 and constitutional since 2018, is a correct answer to both wordings today; before 2018 it was an answer to neither.
Worked example 1: two questions, one body
(a) 'How was the CVC originally set up?' (b) 'What is the CVC's status today?' Step 1: in (a) the word 'originally' points to 1964, a government resolution, so the answer is an executive resolution. Step 2: in (b) 'today' points to the CVC Act, 2003, so the answer is statutory. Notice that neither answer is 'constitutional': the CVC was never named in the Constitution.
Worked example 2: which amendment?
A question asks: which constitutional amendment gave the National Commission for Backward Classes constitutional status? Step 1: the body is a Backward Classes commission, so look for the Article numbered 338B. Step 2: Article 338B was inserted by the 102nd Amendment. Step 3: do not confuse it with the 89th Amendment of 2003, which split the SC and ST commission into two. Answer: the 102nd Amendment. The method is to link the body, the Article number and the amendment number as a trio.
CVC: 1964 resolution, 2003 Act. SEBI: 1988, 1992 Act. Minorities: 1978 resolution, 1992 Act. Backward Classes: Act of 1993, Article 338B by the 102nd Amendment.
Key takeaways
Always ask whether the question is about the beginning or the present. The three executive-to-statutory stories are the CVC, SEBI and the Minorities Commission. The Backward Classes Commission is the main statutory-to-constitutional story, and the Planning Commission to NITI Aayog is a change of body, not of type.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Central Vigilance Commission was originally set up by:
- a government resolution of 1964
- the CVC Act, 2003
- Article 280 of the Constitution
- the Lokpal Act, 2013
Show answer
Answer: A. The CVC began as an executive body by resolution in 1964. The Act of 2003 gave it statutory status.
-
2. The National Commission for Backward Classes was given constitutional status by the:
- 44th Amendment
- 73rd Amendment
- 102nd Amendment
- 89th Amendment
Show answer
Answer: C. The 102nd Amendment inserted Article 338B and made the Commission a constitutional body.
-
3. SEBI received statutory powers through the SEBI Act of:
- 1988
- 1992
- 1997
- 2003
Show answer
Answer: B. SEBI began in 1988 without an Act. The SEBI Act, 1992 gave it statutory powers.
-
4. Which of these has NEVER been a constitutional body?
- Commission for Scheduled Castes
- Central Vigilance Commission
- Finance Commission
- National Commission for Backward Classes
Show answer
Answer: B. The CVC is statutory and was executive before that. The SC commission (Article 338) and the Finance Commission are constitutional, and the Backward Classes Commission became so.
-
5. The Planning Commission was replaced by NITI Aayog. Compared with the Planning Commission, NITI Aayog is:
- a statutory body
- a constitutional body
- a body created by an Act of 2015
- another executive body
Show answer
Answer: D. Both were created by Cabinet resolutions, so NITI Aayog is also an executive body.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.