- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Selection committees and binding force: a comparison drill
Compare who recommends the heads of key bodies, count members in the committees, and tell binding orders from recommendations.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Two kinds of detail appear again and again in questions: who sits on the committee that recommends the head of a body, and whether the body's decisions bind anyone. Because the committees overlap, a table makes them easy; because the numbers are small, they lend themselves to counting questions.
The five selection committees
| Body | Committee (members) | Size |
|---|---|---|
| NHRC | PM (chair), Speaker of Lok Sabha, Deputy Chairman of Rajya Sabha, Leaders of Opposition in both Houses, Union Home Minister | 6 |
| Central Information Commission | PM (chair), Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha, a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the PM | 3 |
| CVC | PM (chair), Union Home Minister, Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha | 3 |
| CBI Director | PM, Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha (or leader of the single largest opposition party), Chief Justice of India or a Supreme Court judge nominated by him | 3 |
| Lokpal | PM, Speaker, Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha, Chief Justice of India or a nominee judge, an eminent jurist | 5 |
The President formally appoints the heads of the NHRC, CIC, CVC and Lokpal on these recommendations. Note the pattern: the Prime Minister is on every committee, and so is the Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha. The judiciary sits on two (the CBI Director's and the Lokpal's).
Binding or only advisory?
- Binding: the Information Commission's orders on second appeals, the National Green Tribunal's orders (an appeal lies to the Supreme Court), and tribunal decisions generally.
- Recommendatory: the NHRC and State Human Rights Commissions, the NCW, the NCPCR, the Law Commission and the CVC's advice to departments.
- Planning and policy advice only: NITI Aayog, which cannot allocate funds.
Worked example 1: counting seats
How many committee seats are there in total across the five committees, and how many distinct offices? Step 1: seats = 6 + 3 + 3 + 3 + 5 = 20. Step 2: list distinct offices: Prime Minister, Speaker, Deputy Chairman of the Rajya Sabha, Leader of Opposition (Lok Sabha), Leader of Opposition (Rajya Sabha), Home Minister, a nominated Cabinet Minister, the Chief Justice (or nominee) and an eminent jurist. That makes 9. Step 3: check the repeats: the Prime Minister and the Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha each appear 5 times, the Home Minister twice (NHRC, CVC), the Speaker twice (NHRC, Lokpal) and the Chief Justice twice (CBI Director, Lokpal).
Worked example 2: who is the odd one out?
Question: which of these is NOT on the committee that recommends the Central Vigilance Commissioner? (a) Prime Minister, (b) Union Home Minister, (c) Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha, (d) Chief Justice of India. Step 1: the CVC committee has exactly three members: (a), (b), (c). Step 2: the Chief Justice sits on the committees for the CBI Director and the Lokpal, not on the CVC's. Answer: (d).
Prime Minister and Leader of Opposition (Lok Sabha) are on all five committees. NHRC 6, CIC 3, CVC 3, CBI Director 3, Lokpal 5.
Key takeaways
Memorise the committee sizes 6, 3, 3, 3, 5 and the two members who appear everywhere. Then learn the exceptions: the Home Minister is on the NHRC and CVC committees, the Speaker on the NHRC and Lokpal committees, the Chief Justice on the CBI and Lokpal committees. Separate binding bodies (Information Commission, NGT) from recommendatory ones (NHRC, NCW, Law Commission).
Check your understanding
-
1. How many members are there in the committee that recommends the NHRC chairperson?
- 6
- 3
- 4
- 5
Show answer
Answer: A. The committee has six members: the Prime Minister, the Speaker, the Deputy Chairman of the Rajya Sabha, the two Leaders of Opposition and the Home Minister.
-
2. The Chief Justice of India (or a nominee) is a member of the selection committee for the:
- Lokpal
- Central Information Commission
- Central Vigilance Commission
- NHRC
Show answer
Answer: A. The CJI or his nominee sits on the committees for the Lokpal and the CBI Director. The other three committees have no judge.
-
3. Which of the following is on ALL five selection committees discussed?
- The Speaker of the Lok Sabha
- The Union Home Minister
- The Prime Minister
- The Chief Justice of India
Show answer
Answer: C. The Prime Minister chairs or sits on every one of the five. The Speaker, Home Minister and Chief Justice appear on only two each.
-
4. Orders that are binding on public authorities are passed by the:
- NHRC
- National Commission for Women
- Law Commission
- Information Commission on appeals
Show answer
Answer: D. The Information Commission can order disclosure and impose penalties. The NHRC, NCW and Law Commission only recommend.
-
5. The total number of seats across the NHRC, CIC, CVC, CBI Director and Lokpal committees is:
- 17
- 20
- 18
- 19
Show answer
Answer: B. Add the sizes: 6 + 3 + 3 + 3 + 5 = 20.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.