- Foundation
- About 11 min
- 5 practice questions
Collective and individual responsibility
Understand how ministers are answerable to Parliament, together and as individuals.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Responsibility is the heart of a parliamentary system. Ministers have to answer to the legislature for their decisions. There are two kinds.
Collective responsibility (Article 75(3))
The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha. This means all ministers share responsibility for the decisions of the Cabinet. They sink or swim together. If the Lok Sabha passes a no-confidence motion, the whole Council must resign. All ministers must publicly support Cabinet decisions; a minister who disagrees has to resign.
Individual responsibility (Article 75(2))
Ministers hold office during the pleasure of the President. In practice a minister can be asked to resign or be dismissed on the advice of the Prime Minister if his work or conduct is found wanting, even when the Council retains the confidence of the House.
Other points
- No legal responsibility of a minister for an order of the President: courts cannot inquire into the advice given by ministers (Article 74(2)).
- A minister may speak in either House though he is a member of only one; he may vote only in the House of which he is a member.
Worked examples
Example 1. The Cabinet decides a policy. One minister thinks it is wrong but publicly defends it. This follows collective responsibility.
Example 2. The Lok Sabha has 540 members in an example; a no-confidence motion gets 260 votes in favour and 270 against. The motion is defeated, so the Council continues.
| Type | Article | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Collective | 75(3) | The whole Council answers to the Lok Sabha |
| Individual | 75(2) | Ministers hold office at the President's pleasure |
Collective responsibility: sink or swim together.
- Collective responsibility is to the Lok Sabha; the whole Council resigns together.
- Individual responsibility means ministers serve at the President's pleasure, in practice the Prime Minister's.
- Ministers must support Cabinet decisions publicly.
Check your understanding
-
1. Collective responsibility of the Council of Ministers to the Lok Sabha is laid down in
- Article 74(2)
- Article 75(2)
- Article 78
- Article 75(3)
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 75(3) makes the Council of Ministers collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha. Article 75(2) is the basis of individual responsibility.
-
2. A minister strongly disagrees with a Cabinet decision. Under collective responsibility he must
- support it in public, or resign
- vote against it in the Lok Sabha and stay in office
- appeal to the Supreme Court against it
- ask the President to veto it
Show answer
Answer: A. All ministers must publicly support Cabinet decisions; they sink or swim together. A minister who cannot do so has to resign.
-
3. Article 74(2) provides that
- every order of the President must be countersigned by a minister
- no court can inquire into what advice the ministers gave the President
- ministers are collectively responsible to the Rajya Sabha
- the Prime Minister must inform the President of all Cabinet decisions
Show answer
Answer: B. Under Article 74(2) the question whether any, and if so what, advice was tendered by ministers to the President cannot be inquired into in any court.
-
4. Individual responsibility of ministers rests on which provision?
- Ministers are elected by the Rajya Sabha
- Ministers serve a fixed five-year term
- Ministers hold office during the pleasure of the President (Article 75(2))
- Ministers are appointed by the Speaker
Show answer
Answer: C. Under Article 75(2) ministers hold office during the pleasure of the President, exercised in practice on the Prime Minister's advice. A minister can be removed even when the Council keeps the House's confidence.
-
5. A minister who is a member of the Rajya Sabha
- can vote in both Houses
- cannot speak in the Lok Sabha at all
- can vote in the Lok Sabha only on Money Bills
- can speak in the Lok Sabha but can vote only in the Rajya Sabha
Show answer
Answer: D. A minister may speak and take part in the proceedings of either House, but may vote only in the House of which he is a member.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.