- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
The Chief Minister and the State Council of Ministers
See how the State executive mirrors the Union executive, with the Governor, the Chief Minister and the Legislative Assembly.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The States have a parliamentary system just like the Union. Each State has a Governor as the formal head, a Chief Minister as the real head of the Government and a Council of Ministers that answers to the Legislative Assembly. If you know the Union system, learning the State one is mostly a matter of changing the names.
The pairs
| Union | State |
|---|---|
| President | Governor |
| Prime Minister | Chief Minister |
| Council of Ministers (Article 74) | Council of Ministers (Article 163) |
| Lok Sabha | Legislative Assembly |
| Attorney General (Article 76) | Advocate-General (Article 165) |
| Prime Minister informs the President (Article 78) | Chief Minister informs the Governor (Article 167) |
How the State Government is formed
The Governor appoints the Chief Minister (Article 164). By convention he invites the leader of the party or group that has a majority in the Legislative Assembly. The other ministers are appointed by the Governor on the advice of the Chief Minister. The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly, which means that it must resign if the Assembly passes a motion of no confidence. The Legislative Council, in the States that have one, cannot remove the Government.
The Chief Minister's role
- Head of the Council of Ministers; advises the Governor on the appointment of ministers.
- Gives out portfolios and can reshuffle ministers.
- Link between the Governor and the Council: he must tell the Governor the decisions of the Council and furnish information the Governor asks for (Article 167).
- Leader of the majority party in the Assembly, and chief spokesperson of the State Government.
- Advises the Governor on summoning and proroguing the Assembly and on its dissolution.
Size of the State Council
Since the 91st Amendment, 2003, the Council of Ministers in a State cannot be larger than 15 per cent of the strength of the Assembly. But a State's Council must have at least 12 ministers, including the Chief Minister.
Worked example 1: the size
An Assembly has 200 members (illustrative). Fifteen per cent of 200 is 30, so the Council can have up to 30 ministers. Another Assembly has 60 members. Fifteen per cent of 60 is 9, but the minimum is 12, so the Council can have 12. For an Assembly of 100 members, 15 per cent is 15, which is above 12, so the maximum is 15. The rule is: take 15 per cent, then check against the minimum of 12.
Worked example 2: who is responsible to whom?
The Legislative Council of a State rejects a Government bill. Must the Chief Minister resign? No. The Council of Ministers is responsible only to the Legislative Assembly, as the Council of Ministers at the Union is responsible only to the Lok Sabha. A loss in the Legislative Council, like a loss in the Rajya Sabha, does not remove the Government. Now suppose the Assembly passes a no-confidence motion. The Council of Ministers must resign, including the Chief Minister.
State: Governor appoints the Chief Minister; ministers on the Chief Minister's advice; Council responsible to the Legislative Assembly; size 15 per cent, minimum 12.
Key takeaways
The State executive mirrors the Union executive: Governor for President, Chief Minister for Prime Minister, Assembly for Lok Sabha. The Council is responsible to the Assembly. The size is limited to 15 per cent of the Assembly with a floor of 12.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Chief Minister of a State is appointed by the:
- President
- Governor
- Speaker of the Assembly
- Prime Minister
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 164: the Governor appoints the Chief Minister.
-
2. The State Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the:
- Governor
- Legislative Council
- Legislative Assembly
- High Court
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 164(2) makes the Council responsible to the Legislative Assembly.
-
3. An Assembly has 160 members. The maximum size of the Council of Ministers is:
- 12
- 16
- 20
- 24
Show answer
Answer: D. 15 per cent of 160 = 24, which is more than 12.
-
4. The Chief Minister's duty to give information to the Governor is in:
- Article 167
- Article 78
- Article 165
- Article 164
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 167 sets out the Chief Minister's duties towards the Governor.
-
5. The minimum number of ministers in a State Council, including the Chief Minister, is:
- 9
- 10
- 11
- 12
Show answer
Answer: D. The 91st Amendment fixed a minimum of 12.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.