- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
The Prime Minister's powers in practice and their limits
List what the Prime Minister can do, what the President does on his advice, and the checks that limit his power.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
On paper, the Constitution says that the President appoints ministers and dissolves the Lok Sabha. In practice the Prime Minister decides all of this, and the President acts on his advice. Because the post is so powerful, it is useful to list the Prime Minister's powers and then the checks on them, as exam questions often ask for both.
What the Prime Minister can do
- Choose the ministers. The President appoints ministers on the Prime Minister's advice (Article 75(1)).
- Give out portfolios. He decides which minister gets which ministry and can change them.
- Remove a minister. He can ask a minister to resign or advise the President to dismiss him.
- Lead the Cabinet. He presides over its meetings and sets its agenda.
- Lead the House. He is usually the Leader of the House, and the chief spokesperson of the Government.
- Advise on the Houses. The President summons and prorogues the Houses and dissolves the Lok Sabha on the advice of the Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister.
- Link with the President. Under Article 78, he must tell the President of Cabinet decisions.
The checks on the Prime Minister
| Check | How it works |
|---|---|
| The Lok Sabha | He must keep its confidence; a no-confidence motion ends the Government |
| His own party and allies | In a coalition, partners can withdraw support |
| The Cabinet | Decisions are taken collectively, not by him alone |
| The President | Can ask for information (Article 78) and for one reconsideration of advice (Article 74) |
| The courts | Executive acts can be reviewed for legality |
| Public opinion and elections | He must face the voters at least every five years |
In theory, he is called 'first among equals' (primus inter pares) among his colleagues. In practice, a Prime Minister who leads a single party with a large majority has more control than one who leads a coalition of many parties.
Worked example 1: who really does it?
A Prime Minister wants to drop a minister who has lost his trust. How is it done? Step 1: the Prime Minister asks the minister to resign. Step 2: if he does not, the Prime Minister advises the President to dismiss him. Step 3: since ministers hold office during the pleasure of the President (Article 75(2)), the President acts on that advice. So formally the President acts, but the real decision is the Prime Minister's. The same pattern applies to dissolving the Lok Sabha: the President formally dissolves it, on the advice of the Council of Ministers.
Worked example 2: can he do it alone?
Can the Prime Minister alone pass a law? No: a law needs both Houses and the President's assent. Can the Prime Minister alone declare a national emergency? No: the President can proclaim it only on the written advice of the Cabinet, and Parliament must approve it. Can the Prime Minister hold office after losing the confidence of the Lok Sabha? Not for long: he must resign, or advise dissolution. Each answer shows a check at work.
The Prime Minister advises, the President acts. His power rests on the confidence of the Lok Sabha and is checked by the Cabinet, Parliament, the courts and the voters.
Key takeaways
The Prime Minister chooses ministers, allocates portfolios, leads the Cabinet and House, and advises the President on summoning and dissolving the Houses. His power is checked by the Lok Sabha, his allies, the Cabinet, the President's rights under Articles 74 and 78, the courts and the electorate.
Check your understanding
-
1. The President appoints ministers:
- on the advice of the Prime Minister
- on the advice of the Speaker
- on his own choice
- on the advice of the Chief Justice
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 75(1): ministers are appointed by the President on the advice of the Prime Minister.
-
2. The Lok Sabha is dissolved by the President on the advice of the:
- Speaker of the Lok Sabha
- Chairman of the Rajya Sabha
- Council under the Prime Minister
- Chief Justice of the Supreme Court
Show answer
Answer: C. The President acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister.
-
3. Which of these is a check on the Prime Minister?
- His power to give out portfolios
- His role as Leader of the House
- His power to preside over the Cabinet
- The confidence of the Lok Sabha
Show answer
Answer: D. The Prime Minister must keep the confidence of the Lok Sabha; the other three are his powers.
-
4. The phrase 'first among equals' describes the Prime Minister's position among:
- the Chief Ministers
- the members of the Cabinet
- the judges of the Supreme Court
- the Governors
Show answer
Answer: B. In the Cabinet the Prime Minister is first among equals (primus inter pares).
-
5. A national emergency can be proclaimed by the President only on the written advice of the:
- Prime Minister alone
- Speaker
- Cabinet
- Rajya Sabha
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 352(3) requires the written advice of the Cabinet.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.