• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Common causes and independent causes

Tell apart statements that share one cause from statements that have separate causes, and from statements that are both causes.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

When neither statement causes the other, you must decide among three cases. The statements may be effects of one common cause, effects of separate independent causes, or both be causes (of something else). A good test is to ask what single event could explain both statements.

How to decide

When neither causes the other

  • Common cause One thing, such as a flood, strike, festival or drought, explains both.
  • Independent causes Each event has its own reason, and the reasons are not linked.
  • Both are causes Each is a possible reason for some third event.
  • Common cause: one thing (a flood, a strike, a festival, a drought) can reasonably explain both events.
  • Independent causes: each event has its own different reason, and the two reasons are not linked.
  • Both are causes: each statement is a possible reason for some third event, and neither is a result of the other.

Worked examples

Example 1. I: Prices of food grains have risen sharply. II: Many villagers have moved to cities in search of work. Neither explains the other: villagers moving away does not push grain prices up, and higher prices do not by themselves send people to cities. A long drought, however, could explain both: crops fail, so prices rise, and villagers lose their livelihood, so they leave. Both are effects of a common cause (a drought).

A long drought

  • Crops fail
    • Prices of food grains rise (I)
  • Villagers lose their livelihood
    • They move to cities for work (II)
Both are effects of a common cause.

Example 2. I: A bus strike has paralysed the city. II: The price of gold has fallen. The two are unrelated. Both are effects of independent causes.

Example 3. I: There is heavy traffic on all roads. II: Schools in the city have reopened after the holidays. Schools reopening can explain the traffic. II is the cause; I is the effect.

Example 4 (both are causes). I: The company has reduced its prices. II: The company has started a large advertising campaign. Each could lead to higher sales, a third event that is not mentioned. Neither is the result of the other. They are both independent causes (of a possible rise in sales).

Ask: could one event explain both statements? If so, it is a common cause. If the two are unrelated, they have independent causes.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Check direct cause first, then common cause, then independent.
  • A single event that explains both statements is a common cause.
  • Unrelated statements are effects of independent causes.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. I: Prices of food grains have risen sharply. II: Many villagers have moved to cities in search of work. How are the two statements related?

    1. II is the cause and I is its effect
    2. Both are effects of independent causes
    3. Both are effects of a common cause
    4. Both are independent causes
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Neither explains the other directly. A long drought explains both: crops fail, so grain prices rise, and villagers lose their livelihood, so they leave. Both are effects of a common cause.

  2. 2. I: A bus strike has paralysed the city. II: The price of gold has fallen. How are the two statements related?

    1. II is the cause and I is its effect
    2. Both are effects of independent causes
    3. Both are effects of a common cause
    4. Both are independent causes
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A bus strike and a fall in the gold price are unrelated, and no single event explains both. They are effects of independent causes.

  3. 3. I: The company has reduced its prices. II: The company has started a large advertising campaign. How are the two statements related?

    1. II is the cause and I is its effect
    2. Both are effects of independent causes
    3. Both are effects of a common cause
    4. Both are independent causes
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Neither is the result of the other. Each could lead to a third event, higher sales, which is not mentioned. So both are independent causes.

  4. 4. I: There is heavy traffic on all roads. II: Schools in the city have reopened after the holidays. How are the two statements related?

    1. II is the cause and I is its effect
    2. Both are effects of independent causes
    3. Both are effects of a common cause
    4. Both are independent causes
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Schools reopening puts more buses and parents on the roads, which explains the traffic. II is the cause and I is its effect.

  5. 5. I: Roads in the city are waterlogged. II: Many offices closed early. Which single event could best be their common cause?

    1. A cyclone with heavy rain
    2. A price rise in a distant market
    3. A school winning a sports trophy
    4. The opening of a new airport
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Ask what one event could explain both. A cyclone with heavy rain floods the roads and makes offices close early. The other events explain neither.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Mixed cause-and-effect practice

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery