- Foundation
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Problems and their remedies: when the response is the effect
Tell apart pairs where a measure is the cause from pairs where the measure is taken because of a problem, and so is the effect.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Some statements describe a problem, such as a theft, a flood or a shortage. Others describe a measure taken in answer to it, such as extra guards, relief camps or rationing. In such pairs the problem is the cause of the measure, and the measure is the effect. This is the reverse of the pattern in the last lesson, where an action produced a result, so it is easy to confuse the two.
Problem, then remedy
- A problem Such as a theft, a flood or a shortage: the cause.
- A measure in answer Such as extra guards, relief camps or rationing: the effect.
The question to ask
- Would this measure have been taken if the problem had not happened?
- Which statement came first in time? A measure follows the problem.
- Does the other statement describe what the measure achieved, such as 'crime fell'? Then the measure is the cause.
| Problem | Measure taken in response |
|---|---|
| A disease outbreak | A vaccination drive |
| Thefts in a colony | More guards and cameras |
| Water shortage | Rationing of water |
| Heavy traffic on a road | A new flyover |
| A flood | Relief camps |
Worked examples
Example 1. I: The colony hired extra guards. II: Several thefts occurred in the colony. Working: The guards were hired because of the thefts. The thefts came first. II is the cause and I is its effect.
Example 2. I: The municipality ran a vaccination drive. II: A disease outbreak was reported. Working: A drive is a response to an outbreak. II is the cause and I is its effect.
Example 3. I: Crime in the colony fell sharply. II: The colony hired extra guards. Working: Here the second statement describes the measure and the first describes what changed after it. Extra guards can reduce crime. II is the cause and I is its effect. The same measure, hiring guards, was the effect in Example 1 and the cause here; the other statement decides.
The other statement decides
-
Measure as effect
- Several thefts occurred
- The colony hired extra guards
- The other statement is the problem
-
Measure as cause
- The colony hired extra guards
- Crime in the colony fell sharply
- The other statement is an improvement
Example 4. I: The water board introduced rationing. II: The reservoir level dropped. Working: Rationing is a response to low water. II is the cause and I is its effect.
Example 5. I: The government opened relief camps. II: A flood destroyed hundreds of homes. Working: Relief camps are set up for people who have lost shelter. The flood came first and the camps followed. II is the cause and I is its effect.
Ask what the other statement is. If it is a problem, the measure is the effect; if it is an improvement, the measure is the cause.
Why the pairs are written this way
Question-setters like to put the measure and the problem side by side because they are easy to reverse. If a student skims and sees 'guards hired' and 'thefts', the eye tends to read the first as the cause, since an action feels like a starting point. The correct reading starts from the reason for the action. Whenever you see a measure, ask, 'Why was it taken?' If the answer is the other statement, the measure is the effect. This takes five seconds and removes one of the most common errors in the topic.
A common slip
Students see the words 'relief', 'campaign' or 'new rule' and conclude that this is the cause because it sounds like an action. The test is not the word but the pair: a measure is the cause only when the other statement describes something that follows from it, such as a fall in crime, fewer accidents or more students. If the other statement describes the trouble that the measure was meant to deal with, the measure is the effect.
Key takeaways
- A measure taken in answer to a problem is the effect of that problem.
- A measure followed by an improvement is the cause of that improvement.
- Let the other statement decide which case you face.
Check your understanding
-
1. I: The town set up a fire station near the market. II: A fire destroyed many shops in the market last year. How are the two statements related?
- II is the cause and I is its effect
- I is the cause and II is its effect
- Both are effects of a common cause
- Both are effects of independent causes
Show answer
Answer: A. The fire station was set up because of the fire.
-
2. I: The government introduced free vaccination. II: The number of cases of the disease dropped. How are the two statements related?
- II is the cause and I is its effect
- I is the cause and II is its effect
- Both are effects of a common cause
- Both are effects of independent causes
Show answer
Answer: B. Vaccination reduces cases.
-
3. I: The number of road accidents on the highway fell. II: The police started checking speed on the highway. How are the two statements related?
- I is the cause and II is its effect
- Both are effects of a common cause
- Both are effects of independent causes
- II is the cause and I is its effect
Show answer
Answer: D. Speed checks lead to safer driving and fewer accidents.
-
4. I: The municipality put up more street lights in the town. II: The town's cricket team won a tournament. How are the two statements related?
- I is the cause and II is its effect
- II is the cause and I is its effect
- Both are effects of independent causes
- Both are effects of a common cause
Show answer
Answer: C. The two events have nothing to do with each other.
-
5. A cyclone struck the coast. I: Fishing boats stayed in the harbour. II: Electric poles fell in many villages. How are the two statements related?
- I is the cause and II is its effect
- II is the cause and I is its effect
- Both are effects of a common cause
- Both are effects of independent causes
Show answer
Answer: C. The cyclone explains both; neither causes the other.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.