- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Immediate cause and effect, and the five answer types
Learn the standard five answer options of a cause-and-effect question and how to choose between them.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
In exams the answer choices are fixed. You need to know what each option means so that you can pick the right one quickly. Here are the five standard choices, with the question you ask to decide each.
The five options
The five options
- I is the cause, II its effect Does I explain II?
- II is the cause, I its effect Does II explain I?
- Effects of independent causes Are I and II caused by different, unrelated things?
- Effects of a common cause Is there a single reason that could explain both?
- Both are independent causes Are I and II both reasons for something else?
| Option | Meaning | Question to ask |
|---|---|---|
| I is the cause and II is its effect | I led to II | Does I explain II? |
| II is the cause and I is its effect | II led to I | Does II explain I? |
| Both are effects of independent causes | Each has its own separate cause; they are unrelated to each other | Are I and II caused by different, unrelated things? |
| Both are effects of a common cause | One event caused both | Is there a single reason that could explain both? |
| Both are independent causes | Each can cause something; neither is the effect of the other | Are I and II both reasons for something else? |
In real exam wording, the second and third options often read 'Both I and II are effects of independent causes' and 'Both I and II are effects of some common cause'. In either, the statements are not cause and effect of each other.
Worked examples
Example 1. I: A shopkeeper reduced prices. II: A new bridge opened in the city. The two events are not related. Each has its own cause. Both are effects of independent causes.
Example 2. I: Many schools in the town were closed. II: Several roads in the town were waterlogged. The most natural single reason for both is a heavy flood or rain in the town. Both are effects of a common cause.
Independent or common cause?
-
Independent causes
- A shopkeeper reduced prices
- A new bridge opened in the city
- Not related: each has its own cause
-
A common cause
- Many schools in the town were closed
- Several roads were waterlogged
- A heavy flood or rain explains both
Example 3. I: The price of petrol has gone up. II: The cost of transporting vegetables has increased. Why is the transport cost higher? Because fuel costs more. I is the cause and II is its effect.
Example 4. I: A large number of students are studying in the library. II: The examinations will start next week. The exams explain the studying. II is the cause and I is its effect.
First test whether one statement explains the other. Only if neither does, test for a common cause or independence.
Key takeaways
- Know the five answer types.
- Test for direct cause first.
- A common cause explains both statements; independent causes are unrelated.
Check your understanding
-
1. I: The price of petrol has gone up. II: The cost of transporting vegetables has increased. How are the two statements related?
- I is the cause and II is its effect
- Both are effects of independent causes
- Both are effects of a common cause
- Both are independent causes
Show answer
Answer: A. Why is transport costlier? Because fuel costs more. I explains II, so I is the cause and II is its effect.
-
2. I: Many schools in the town were closed. II: Several roads in the town were waterlogged. How are the two statements related?
- II is the cause and I is its effect
- Both are effects of independent causes
- Both are effects of a common cause
- Both are independent causes
Show answer
Answer: C. Neither explains the other: closed schools do not flood roads, and the roads alone need not shut schools. Heavy rain or a flood in the town explains both, so both are effects of a common cause.
-
3. I: A shopkeeper reduced his prices. II: A new bridge opened in the city. How are the two statements related?
- II is the cause and I is its effect
- Both are effects of independent causes
- Both are effects of a common cause
- Both are independent causes
Show answer
Answer: B. The two events are not linked, and no single event explains both. Each has its own separate reason, so both are effects of independent causes.
-
4. What does the option "Both are effects of a common cause" mean?
- Statement I caused statement II
- Each statement has its own unrelated cause
- Both statements are reasons for some third event
- One single event caused both statements
Show answer
Answer: D. A common cause is one event that explains both statements. Separate unrelated causes is "independent causes", and both being reasons for a third event is "both are independent causes".
-
5. I: A large number of students are studying in the library. II: The examinations will start next week. How are the two statements related?
- II is the cause and I is its effect
- Both are effects of independent causes
- Both are effects of a common cause
- Both are independent causes
Show answer
Answer: A. Why are so many students studying? Because the exams are near. II explains I, so II is the cause and I is its effect.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.