The 'why' test
- Ask 'why?' of statement I Does statement II answer it?
- Ask 'why?' of statement II Does statement I answer it?
- The answer to 'why' is the cause The one it explains is the effect.
- Check timing A cause comes before its effect.
Example 1: cause, then effect
- Heavy rains destroyed onion crops Statement II: the cause.
- The price of onions rose sharply Statement I: the effect.
Ask 'why did this happen?' of each statement. The statement that answers it is the cause.
- A cause explains why; an effect is what is explained.
- Ask 'why?' of each statement.
- A cause comes before its effect in time.