- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Either-or conclusions
Recognise the three pairs of conclusions where one of the two must be true when neither follows on its own.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Sometimes two conclusions are given and neither can be proved alone, but one of them has to be true. This happens when the two conclusions are complementary: together they cover every possibility.
Complementary pairs
| If conclusion 1 is | and conclusion 2 is | Either 1 or 2 is true |
|---|---|---|
| X > Y | X <= Y | Yes |
| X < Y | X >= Y | Yes |
| X = Y | X is not equal to Y | Yes |
These pairs cover every case. If X > Y is false, then X <= Y must be true, and the reverse. Notice that X >= Y with X <= Y does not form a pair in the usual exam convention, because both are true when X = Y.
The conditions
Either-or needs all three
- Same two letters Both conclusions involve the same pair of letters.
- Neither follows alone Test each conclusion on its own first.
-
Together they cover all cases
- X > Y with X <= Y
- X < Y with X >= Y
- X = Y with X is not equal to Y
- The two conclusions must involve the same two letters.
- Neither conclusion can be proved on its own.
- Together they must cover all possibilities (one of the complementary pairs above).
Worked examples
Example 1. Statement: A > B < C. Conclusions: I. A > C. II. A <= C. B is smaller than both, so A and C cannot be compared, and neither conclusion follows alone. They are a complementary pair on the same letters. Either I or II is true.
Example 2. Statement: P >= Q <= R. Conclusions: I. P < R. II. P >= R. Neither follows, because of the valley at Q. These are a complementary pair (P < R and P >= R). Either I or II is true.
Example 3. Statement: M > N > O. Conclusions: I. M > O. II. M <= O. I follows alone (M > N > O). So II must be false, and the answer is only I follows. Either-or is checked only when neither follows alone.
Example 4. Statement: A > B < C. Conclusions: I. A > C. II. A < C. Neither follows, but A = C is also possible, so these two do not cover all cases. Neither follows; this is not an either-or case.
Either-or or neither?
-
Pair covers every case
- Example 2: P < R and P >= R
- Neither follows alone
- Answer: either I or II is true
-
Pair leaves a case out
- Example 4: A > C and A < C
- A = C is also possible
- Answer: neither follows
Either-or needs: same two letters, neither follows alone, and the two conclusions together cover all possibilities.
Key takeaways
- Test each conclusion alone first.
- Check that the pair covers all cases.
- > with <= and < with >= are the common complementary pairs.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which pair of conclusions about X and Y is complementary (together they cover every case)?
- X > Y and X < Y
- X >= Y and X <= Y
- X > Y and X <= Y
- X = Y and X > Y
Show answer
Answer: C. X > Y and X <= Y cover all cases: if one is false the other must be true. X > Y and X < Y leave out X = Y, and X >= Y with X <= Y are both true when X = Y.
-
2. Statement: X < Y > Z. Conclusions: I. X > Z. II. X <= Z.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Either I or II follows
- Neither follows
Show answer
Answer: C. X and Z are both below Y, so neither conclusion follows alone. They are on the same two letters and > with <= is a complementary pair, so either I or II follows.
-
3. Statement: P > Q = R. Conclusions: I. P > R. II. P <= R.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Either I or II follows
- Neither follows
Show answer
Answer: A. P > Q = R gives P > R, so I follows on its own and II is false. Either-or is checked only when neither follows alone.
-
4. Statement: A <= B >= C. Conclusions: I. A > C. II. A < C.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Either I or II follows
- Neither follows
Show answer
Answer: D. A and C cannot be compared (peak at B). But A > C and A < C leave out A = C, so they are not complementary. Neither follows.
-
5. Statement: M < N <= O. Conclusions: I. M >= O. II. M < O.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Either I or II follows
- Neither follows
Show answer
Answer: B. M < N <= O gives M < O, so II follows on its own and I is false.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.