- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Joining separate statements
Combine two or three separate statements that share a letter into one chain, and see when the shared letter lets you compare the outer letters and when it does not.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
So far the statement was a single line. In many questions the statements are separate: 'P > Q' on one line and 'Q >= R' on another. The conclusion may involve letters that never appear together. The job is to join the lines at the letter they share.
How to join
- Find the letter that appears in both statements.
- Write the first statement so that the shared letter is at its right-hand end, and the second so that it is at its left-hand end (reverse a statement if needed).
- Join them into one chain and check that the signs along the chain run in the same direction.
- If the shared letter is higher than both of the others, or lower than both, the outer letters cannot be compared.
| Shape of the joined chain | Result for the outer letters |
|---|---|
| Both links run the same way (A > B > C) | They can be compared |
| Shared letter is above both (A < B > C) | No relation |
| Shared letter is below both (A > B < C) | No relation |
Worked examples
Example 1. Statements: A > B; B >= C. Conclusion: A > C. B is the shared letter. Joining gives A > B >= C, with a strict sign in the chain, so A > C is true.
Example 2. Statements: P < Q; R < Q. Conclusion: P < R. Q is above both P and R, so the chain would be P < Q > R. P and R cannot be compared. The conclusion is not certain.
Example 3. Statements: M >= N; K <= N. Conclusion: M >= K. Rewrite the second statement as N >= K. Now M >= N >= K, so M >= K is true. M > K is not certain, because all three may be equal.
Example 4 (three statements). Statements: X > Y; Y = Z; W >= X. Conclusion: W > Z. Order the lines so each hands over to the next: W >= X > Y = Z. A strict sign lies in the chain, so W > Z is true.
Example 5. Statements: A >= B; B >= C. Which of A >= C and A > C is certain? A >= B >= C gives A >= C only, since no sign is strict. So A >= C is certain, A > C is not.
Example 6 (a statement that needs turning round). Statements: P > Q; R >= S; Q = R. Conclusion: P > S. The shared letters are Q and R, which are equal. Write P > Q = R >= S. A strict sign lies in the chain, so P > S is true, and so is P >= S. The line R >= S did not need turning round, but an equal sign lets you swap Q and R freely, which is why the three lines join into one chain.
Always read the conclusion first and note which two letters it names. Then look for a path through the statements from one to the other. If no path exists, or the path bends at a peak or a valley, the conclusion is not certain.
Join the statements at their shared letter. If that letter is above both or below both, the outer letters have no relation.
Key takeaways
- Rewrite statements so the shared letter sits in the middle.
- A shared letter that is a peak or a valley breaks the chain.
- One strict sign anywhere in a same-direction chain makes the whole relation strict.
- With three or more statements, build the chain one line at a time.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statements: P > Q; Q >= R. Which conclusion is definitely true?
- R > P
- P > R
- P = R
- Q > P
Show answer
Answer: B. P > Q >= R joins into a chain with a strict sign, so P > R.
-
2. Statements: P < Q; R < Q. Which conclusion is definitely true?
- P is less than R
- P is greater than R
- P is equal to R
- No relation is fixed
Show answer
Answer: D. Q is above both P and R, so P and R cannot be compared.
-
3. Statements: M >= N; K <= N. Which conclusion is definitely true?
- M >= K
- M < K
- K > M
- M = K
Show answer
Answer: A. K <= N reads N >= K, so M >= N >= K and M >= K.
-
4. Statements: X > Y; Y = Z; W >= X. Which conclusion is definitely true?
- Z > W
- W = Z
- W > Z
- Y > W
Show answer
Answer: C. W >= X > Y = Z gives W > Z.
-
5. Statements: A >= B; B >= C. Which of these is NOT certain?
- A >= C
- C <= A
- A >= B >= C
- A > C
Show answer
Answer: D. No sign is strict, so A, B and C may all be equal. A > C is not certain.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.