- Foundation
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Testing a conclusion with numbers
Use small numbers to show that a conclusion can fail, and understand why numbers can disprove a conclusion but cannot prove one.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Sometimes a chain looks confusing and you cannot tell by eye whether a conclusion must be true. A good check is to put small numbers in place of the letters. Numbers are a test tool with one clear rule: they can show that a conclusion fails, but they can never show that it always holds.
The method
- Choose numbers for the letters that obey every statement.
- Check the conclusion with those numbers.
- Try again with another set, for example one where letters that may be equal are equal, and one where they are all different.
- If any set makes the conclusion false, the conclusion is not certain.
If a conclusion comes out true for every set you try, that is only encouraging. The proof must come from the chain itself. But a single set that fails settles the matter: the conclusion is not certain.
Worked examples
Example 1. Statement: P >= Q >= R. Is P > R certain? Try P = 5, Q = 5, R = 5. The statement holds, but P > R is false. So P > R is not certain. By contrast, P >= R holds for every set you try, and the chain proves it.
Example 2. Statement: A > B < C. Is A > C certain? Try A = 5, B = 1, C = 3: A > C is true. Try A = 2, B = 1, C = 4: the statement still holds (2 > 1 < 4), but A > C is false. So A > C is not certain, and neither is A < C.
Example 3. Statement: X = Y > Z. Is X > Z certain? Try X = Y = 4, Z = 1: true. Try X = Y = 9, Z = 8: true. The chain shows why: X = Y and Y > Z, so X > Z. It is certain.
Example 4. Statement: M <= N <= O. Is M < O certain? Try M = N = O = 3: M < O is false. So it is not certain. M <= O is certain.
Example 5 (whole numbers). If x is a whole number with x > 2 and x < 6, the values are 3, 4 and 5. There are exactly 3 of them. Notice that 2 and 6 are left out because the signs are strict.
Choosing good test numbers
Choose numbers that make the statement as 'tight' as it can be. If a sign is >=, try making both sides equal. If two letters are not linked at all, try giving them different orders. For A > B < C, B must be the smallest, but A and C can be in either order, so one set with A bigger and another with C bigger will settle it. Small whole numbers are enough; large numbers only slow you down.
Numbers can disprove a conclusion but they cannot prove it. A proof comes from the chain.
Key takeaways
- Pick numbers that obey all the statements first.
- A single counterexample is enough to reject a conclusion.
- Try a set with equal values wherever the statement allows equality.
- Do not accept a conclusion just because two or three sets support it.
Check your understanding
-
1. For P >= Q >= R, which numbers show that P > R is NOT certain?
- P = 5, Q = 5, R = 5
- P = 6, Q = 5, R = 4
- P = 7, Q = 5, R = 3
- P = 8, Q = 6, R = 2
Show answer
Answer: A. Only the first set makes P > R false while still obeying P >= Q >= R.
-
2. For A > B < C, which numbers show that A > C is NOT certain?
- A = 5, B = 1, C = 3
- A = 3, B = 5, C = 4
- A = 2, B = 1, C = 4
- A = 4, B = 2, C = 3
Show answer
Answer: C. A = 2, B = 1, C = 4 obeys A > B < C, and A > C is false there. The set A = 3, B = 5, C = 4 breaks A > B.
-
3. Given M <= N <= O, which conclusion is certain?
- M < O
- M <= O
- M = O
- M > O
Show answer
Answer: B. M <= N <= O chains to M <= O only, because no sign is strict.
-
4. If x is a whole number with x > 2 and x < 6, how many values can x take?
- 1
- 2
- 4
- 3
Show answer
Answer: D. x can be 3, 4 or 5, which is three values.
-
5. Can a few examples with numbers prove that a conclusion is always true?
- No; numbers only show a failure
- Yes; one example is enough
- Yes; two examples are enough
- Yes; if all are positive
Show answer
Answer: A. Examples can only disprove. Proof comes from the chain.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.