- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Long chains: mark the peaks and valleys
Read chains of five to seven letters quickly by marking where the direction changes, and list which pairs of letters can and cannot be compared.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A long chain such as A ≥ B > C = D ≤ E < F looks hard, but it breaks into short runs. Within a run the signs all point one way and the letters can be compared. Between runs the direction changes, and the letters across the change usually cannot be compared. This lesson gives a quick way to mark the runs.
The marking method
- Read the chain from left to right and note where the signs change from 'greater' to 'less' or the reverse.
- A letter that is lower than both its neighbours is a valley. A letter higher than both is a peak. Equal signs do not change direction.
- Two letters can be compared only if no peak or valley lies between them.
- For letters in the same run, the relation is strict if at least one sign between them is strict, and non-strict otherwise.
Worked examples
Example 1. A ≥ B > C = D ≤ E < F. The signs run down from A to D and then up from D to F, so C and D form the valley. Certain: A > C, A > D, B > D (a strict sign B > C lies between), D < F and C < F. Not certain: A against E, A against F, and E against C, because each pair has the valley between them.
Example 2. P < Q ≤ R > S ≥ T. The chain rises to R and then falls, so R is a peak. Certain: P < R (P < Q ≤ R), R > S and R > T. Not certain: P against S, P against T, and Q against T, because the peak R lies between them.
Example 3. M = N ≥ O > P = Q. Every sign points the same way, so every pair can be compared. M > P, M > Q, N > Q and O > Q are all true because the strict sign O > P lies between each pair. M ≥ O is true, but M = O is not certain.
Practice set with answers
- X > Y = Z < W ≥ V. Is Y < W true? Yes, since Y = Z < W. Is X > W true? Not certain, because Z is a valley between them.
- K ≤ L < M = N ≥ O ≥ P. Is K < M true? Yes, because L < M is strict. Is L < N true? Yes. Is N > P true? Not certain, since N ≥ O ≥ P has no strict sign.
- A ≥ B > C = D ≤ E < F. Is E > D true? Not certain, because D ≤ E allows equality. Is D < F true? Yes, because E < F is strict.
- P < Q ≤ R > S ≥ T. Is R > T true? Yes, since R > S ≥ T.
Mark the peaks and valleys. Only letters in the same run can be compared.
Key takeaways
- Equal signs never change direction.
- A strict sign anywhere in a run makes the whole run strict.
- A pair across a peak or a valley has no certain relation.
- Look at the run first, then check strictness.
Check your understanding
-
1. A ≥ B > C = D ≤ E < F. Which conclusion definitely follows?
- A > E
- E > C
- A > D
- A < F
Show answer
Answer: C. A ≥ B > C = D has a strict sign and runs one way, so A > D. The other pairs lie across the valley at C = D.
-
2. P < Q ≤ R > S ≥ T. Which conclusion definitely follows?
- R > T
- P > S
- Q > T
- P < T
Show answer
Answer: A. R > S ≥ T runs one way and has a strict sign, so R > T. The other pairs lie across the peak at R.
-
3. M = N ≥ O > P = Q. Which conclusion definitely follows?
- M = O
- P ≥ N
- Q > O
- N > Q
Show answer
Answer: D. N ≥ O > P = Q runs one way and has a strict sign, so N > Q.
-
4. X > Y = Z < W ≥ V. Which conclusion definitely follows?
- X > W
- Y < W
- Z < V
- X > V
Show answer
Answer: B. Y = Z < W gives Y < W. The other pairs lie across the valley at Y = Z.
-
5. K ≤ L < M = N ≥ O ≥ P. Which conclusion does NOT definitely follow?
- K < M
- L < N
- N > P
- M ≥ O
Show answer
Answer: C. N ≥ O ≥ P has no strict sign, so N > P is not certain.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.