- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Separate statements and three-conclusion sets
Join statements given on separate lines and decide which of three conclusions follow, in the answer format 'only I', 'I and II' and so on.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A common format gives two or three separate statements and then three conclusions, I, II and III. The answer options list which conclusions follow, such as 'only I' or 'I and III'. The method has two stages: first join the statements into a chain, then test each conclusion on its own.
Method
- Join the statements at their shared letters, reversing a statement if needed.
- Write the joined chain and mark peaks and valleys.
- Test each conclusion separately: true, or not certain.
- Choose the option that lists exactly the conclusions that are certainly true.
A conclusion that is merely possible does not follow. Only a conclusion that holds in every case allowed by the statements follows.
Worked examples
Example 1. Statements: A ≥ B; B > C; D = C. Conclusions: I. A > D; II. B > D; III. A = D. Join: A ≥ B > C = D. A strict sign lies between A and D, so I is true. B > C = D gives II true. III is false, because A is strictly greater than D. Answer: I and II follow.
Example 2. Statements: P < Q; R ≤ Q; S > P. Conclusions: I. S > Q; II. R < S; III. P < R. Q is above both P and R, and S is above P. Nothing links S with Q, nothing links R with S, and nothing links P with R. Answer: none follows.
Example 3. Statements: M ≥ N; N ≥ O; O = P. Conclusions: I. M ≥ P; II. M > P; III. P ≤ N. Join: M ≥ N ≥ O = P. All signs are non-strict, so M ≥ P is true and P ≤ N is true, but M > P is not certain. Answer: I and III follow.
Example 4. Statements: A ≤ B; C ≥ B; D < A. Conclusions: I. D < C; II. D < B; III. C > A. Join: D < A ≤ B ≤ C. A strict sign lies between D and C, and between D and B, so I and II are true. Between A and C all signs are non-strict, so III is not certain. Answer: I and II follow.
Example 5. Statements: X ≥ Y; Y > Z; W = X. Conclusions: I. W > Z; II. W > Y; III. Z ≥ W. Join: W = X ≥ Y > Z. I is true because of the strict sign Y > Z. II is not certain, since W may equal Y. III says the opposite of I, so it is false. Answer: only I follows.
Example 6 (a conclusion that is false). Statements: P ≤ Q; R > Q; S ≥ R. Conclusions: I. S > P; II. S ≥ Q; III. P ≥ S. Join: P ≤ Q < R ≤ S. A strict sign lies between P and S, so I is true. Between Q and S there is also the strict sign Q < R, so S ≥ Q is true, and in fact S > Q. III says P is at least S, the opposite of I, so it is false. Answer: I and II follow. Notice how the strict sign in the middle of the chain carries through to both ends.
The order in which the statements are printed does not matter. Look for the letters they share and arrange them yourself. It also helps to underline, on the question paper, the two letters named in each conclusion before you search for a path between them.
Join first, test each conclusion alone, and accept only those that must be true.
Key takeaways
- Do not test conclusions before the chain is built.
- A possible conclusion is not a certain conclusion.
- A conclusion that contradicts the chain is false, not just uncertain.
- Check the answer options for the exact combination, such as 'I and III'.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statements: A ≥ B; B > C; D = C. Conclusions: I. A > D; II. B > D; III. A = D. Which follow?
- Only I
- I and II
- II and III
- All three
Show answer
Answer: B. A ≥ B > C = D gives A > D and B > D. A = D is false.
-
2. Statements: P < Q; R ≤ Q; S > P. Conclusions: I. S > Q; II. R < S; III. P < R. Which follow?
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- I and III follow
- None follows
Show answer
Answer: D. Q is above both P and R, and S is also above P. None of the three pairs is linked.
-
3. Statements: M ≥ N; N ≥ O; O = P. Conclusions: I. M ≥ P; II. M > P; III. P ≤ N. Which follow?
- I and III follow
- Only II follows
- II and III follow
- All three follow
Show answer
Answer: A. M ≥ N ≥ O = P has no strict sign. M ≥ P and P ≤ N are true, but M > P is not certain.
-
4. Statements: A ≤ B; C ≥ B; D < A. Conclusions: I. D < C; II. D < B; III. C > A. Which follow?
- Only III follows
- I and III follow
- I and II follow
- All three follow
Show answer
Answer: C. D < A ≤ B ≤ C gives D < C and D < B. C > A is not certain because A ≤ B ≤ C has no strict sign.
-
5. Statements: X ≥ Y; Y > Z; W = X. Conclusions: I. W > Z; II. W > Y; III. Z ≥ W. Which follow?
- I and II follow
- II and III follow
- I and III follow
- Only I follows
Show answer
Answer: D. W = X ≥ Y > Z gives W > Z. W > Y is not certain, and Z ≥ W is false.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.