- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Testing conclusions and either-or
Test several conclusions against a chain and recognise the complementary pair that gives an either-or answer.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A typical question lists a statement chain and two or three conclusions. Test each conclusion on its own. If neither of two conclusions follows but they cover all possibilities, then either one of them follows.
Complementary pairs
- X > Z and X ≤ Z
- X ≥ Z and X < Z
Worked example 1
A ≥ B > C = D. I. A > D. II. B ≥ D. III. A = C. A ≥ B > C gives A > C, and C = D gives A > D, so I follows. B > C = D gives B > D, so II follows. A = C is false because A > C, so III does not follow.
Worked example 2
X ≥ Y ≤ Z. I. X > Z. II. X ≤ Z. Y is below both, so nothing links X and Z; neither follows alone. But X > Z and X ≤ Z cover every possibility, so either I or II follows.
Neither follows alone, but the pair is complete: either-or.
Key takeaways: test each conclusion separately, and apply either-or only to a complete complementary pair.
Check your understanding
-
1. P > Q ≥ R = S. Conclusions: I. P > S. II. Q ≥ S. III. P > R. Which follow?
- All three
- Only I
- Only I and II
- Only III
Show answer
Answer: A. P > Q ≥ R = S gives P > S and P > R (a strict sign in the chain), and Q ≥ R = S gives Q ≥ S. All three follow.
-
2. A ≥ B ≤ C. Conclusions: I. A ≥ C. II. A < C.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Either I or II follows
- Neither follows
Show answer
Answer: C. B is below both A and C, so neither conclusion follows alone. ≥ with < on the same letters covers every case, so either I or II follows.
-
3. X > Y = Z. Conclusions: I. X ≤ Z. II. X > Z.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Either I or II follows
- Neither follows
Show answer
Answer: B. X > Y = Z gives X > Z, so II follows on its own and I is false.
-
4. M ≤ N > O. Conclusions: I. M > O. II. M < O.
- Only I follows
- Only II follows
- Either I or II follows
- Neither follows
Show answer
Answer: D. M and O cannot be compared (N is above both), so neither follows alone. But M = O is also possible, so > and < do not cover every case. Neither follows.
-
5. Which pair of conclusions is a complete complementary pair?
- X > Z and X < Z
- X ≥ Z and X ≤ Z
- X ≥ Z and X < Z
- X = Z and X > Z
Show answer
Answer: C. X ≥ Z and X < Z cover every case with no overlap. X > Z and X < Z leave out equality; X ≥ Z and X ≤ Z overlap when X = Z.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.