- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Choosing the arrangement of figures for everyday groups
Decide for each pair of groups whether all, some or none of one belong to the other, and draw the figures that match: inside, overlapping or separate.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A well-known kind of question names three everyday groups, such as Roses, Lotuses and Flowers, and asks which diagram of three figures fits. Behind every such question is a small piece of dot-situation reasoning. For each pair of groups, decide whether the first lies inside the second, overlaps it, or is separate from it. Then put the three decisions together.
Three questions for each pair
| Fact about the groups | Figures | Example |
|---|---|---|
| All A are B | A drawn inside B | All roses are flowers |
| Some A are B, and some are not | A and B overlap | Some women are teachers |
| No A is B | A and B separate | No rose is a lotus |
Use only facts that are true everywhere. If you are not sure whether some members of two groups can match, think of one clear example. A group that can have even one member in common with another overlaps it.
Putting it together
| Groups | Pair facts | Diagram |
|---|---|---|
| Roses, Lotuses, Flowers | Roses and Lotuses separate; both inside Flowers | a large figure holding two separate figures |
| Banyan, Trees, Plants | Banyan inside Trees; Trees inside Plants | three figures, each inside the next |
| Teachers, Women, Cats | Teachers and Women overlap; Cats separate from both | two overlapping figures and one apart |
| Animals, Dogs, Pet animals | Dogs and Pet animals inside Animals; Dogs and Pet animals overlap | a large figure holding two overlapping figures |
| Mothers, Women, Men | Mothers inside Women; Men separate from both | two figures, one inside the other, and one apart |
| Students, Girls, Cricketers | every pair overlaps | three figures overlapping each other |
Worked examples
Example 1. Groups: Mothers, Women, Men. All mothers are women (inside). No woman is a man, so Women and Men are separate, and no mother is a man, so Mothers and Men are separate. Diagram: a small figure for mothers inside the figure for women, and a third figure for men standing apart.
Example 2. Groups: Cricketers, Women, Teachers. Some cricketers are women, and some are not. Some cricketers are teachers. Some women are teachers. No group is wholly inside another, and every pair has something in common. Diagram: three figures overlapping one another, with all seven regions. A woman who is a teacher and plays cricket shows that the centre region exists.
Example 3. Groups: Tigers, Lions, Cats. All tigers are cats and all lions are cats; no tiger is a lion. Diagram: a large figure for cats holding two separate figures. This is the same diagram as for Roses, Lotuses and Flowers: two separate groups inside a third.
Inside for all, overlap for some, separate for none. Decide each pair, then draw the three together.
Traps
- Using 'some' where you mean 'all'. If every member of A is a member of B, draw A inside B.
- Letting a pair that never meets overlap in the drawing. Lions and tigers are separate, even though both are cats.
- Overlooking a fact that makes two groups overlap, such as a person being both a doctor and a teacher.
- Choosing a diagram because it looks tidy. Only the pair facts decide.
Key takeaways. Test each pair with 'all', 'some' and 'none', then combine the three results in one drawing.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which diagram fits Roses, Lotuses and Flowers?
- three figures overlapping each other
- two separate figures inside a larger one
- each figure inside the next one
- two figures overlapping and one apart
Show answer
Answer: B. No rose is a lotus, so those figures are separate, and both are flowers, so both lie inside the figure for flowers.
-
2. Which diagram fits Banyan, Trees and Plants?
- each figure inside the next one
- three figures standing apart
- three figures overlapping each other
- two separate figures inside a larger one
Show answer
Answer: A. All banyans are trees and all trees are plants, so the figures nest one inside the next.
-
3. Which diagram fits Teachers, Women and Cats?
- three figures overlapping each other
- each figure inside the next one
- two figures overlapping inside a third
- two figures overlapping and one apart
Show answer
Answer: D. Some women are teachers, so those two overlap. No cat is a woman or a teacher, so the cats stand apart.
-
4. Which diagram fits Animals, Dogs and Pet animals?
- a large figure holding two overlapping figures
- a large figure holding two separate figures
- three figures overlapping each other
- each figure inside the next one
Show answer
Answer: A. Dogs and pet animals are all animals, so both lie inside. Some dogs are pets and some are not, so those two overlap.
-
5. Which diagram fits Students, Girls and Cricketers?
- each figure inside the next one
- a large figure holding two overlapping figures
- three figures overlapping each other
- three figures standing apart
Show answer
Answer: C. Some students are girls, some students play cricket and some girls play cricket, and none of these groups is wholly inside another. So every pair overlaps.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.