- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Which statement is true? Reading the dots back
Test statements that use every, some and no against a table of dots, and find the false ones with a single counterexample.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Not every question asks for a dot. Some give a picture with dots and ask which statement about it is true. Typical statements are 'every dot in the circle is in the square', 'some dot is in the triangle only' and 'no dot is in both the circle and the triangle'. The method is to test the statements one at a time against the table of codes, stopping at the first dot that settles each.
What each kind of statement needs
| Statement form | True when | False when |
|---|---|---|
| Every dot in A is in B | each dot with A also has B | one dot has A but not B (a counterexample) |
| Some dot is in A and B | at least one dot has both A and B | no dot has both |
| No dot is in both A and B | no dot has both A and B | one dot has both |
| Some dot is in A only | a dot has the code A alone | no dot has the code A alone |
A single dot settles an 'every' statement as false, or a 'no' statement as false, or a 'some' statement as true. To prove an 'every' or 'no' statement true, you must go through all the dots.
Worked examples
The picture. Dots: 1 in C only, 2 in CS, 3 in CST, 4 in S only, 5 in ST, 6 outside every figure. Circle C, square S, triangle T.
Example 1. 'Every dot in the circle is in the square.' Circle dots: 1, 2, 3. Dot 1 has the code C, which is not in the square. A counterexample, so the statement is false.
Example 2. 'Every dot in the triangle is in the square.' Triangle dots: 3 (CST) and 5 (ST). Both are in the square. No counterexample, so true.
Example 3. 'No dot is in both the circle and the triangle.' Dot 3 has the code CST, so it is in both. False.
Example 4. 'Some dot is in the triangle only.' Is any code T alone? No dot has it. False.
Example 5. 'Some dot is in exactly two figures.' Dot 2 (CS) is. True.
Every: hunt for one dot that breaks it. No: hunt for one dot that has both. Some: hunt for one dot that fits. A single dot settles the hunt.
Traps
- Reversing a statement. 'Every dot in the triangle is in the square' does not say that every dot in the square is in the triangle (dots 2 and 4 are in the square but not in the triangle).
- Forgetting the centre. A dot with all three letters is in 'both' of any two figures.
- Counting the dot outside the figures as a counterexample to 'every dot in the circle is in the square'. It is not in the circle, so it is irrelevant.
- Accepting 'some' as 'all'. One dot is enough.
Key takeaways. Write a code for each dot, and test each statement by the single dot that could break or confirm it. Check the whole list before calling an 'every' or 'no' statement true.
Check your understanding
-
1. Dots: 1 is C, 2 is CS, 3 is CST, 4 is S, 5 is ST, 6 is outside. Which statement is true?
- Every dot in the triangle is in the square.
- Every dot in the circle is in the square.
- No dot is in both the circle and the triangle.
- Some dot is in the triangle only.
Show answer
Answer: A. The triangle holds dots 3 (CST) and 5 (ST), and both are in the square. Dot 1 breaks 'every dot in the circle is in the square', dot 3 breaks 'no dot is in both the circle and the triangle', and no dot is T alone.
-
2. Dots: 1 is C, 2 is S, 3 is CS, 4 is T. Which statement is false?
- Some dot is in the circle and the square.
- No dot is in both the square and the triangle.
- Every dot in the circle is in the square.
- Some dot is in the triangle only.
Show answer
Answer: C. Dot 1 is in the circle but not the square, so 'Every dot in the circle is in the square' is false. The other three statements are true: dot 3 is CS, no dot is ST, and dot 4 is T.
-
3. Dots: 1 is CS, 2 is CT, 3 is ST. Which statement is true?
- Some dot is in the circle only.
- Every dot is in the square.
- Some dot is in exactly one figure.
- No dot is in all three figures.
Show answer
Answer: D. The codes have two letters each, so no dot is in all three. The other statements fail: no dot is in the circle only, dot 2 (CT) is not in the square, and no dot is in exactly one figure.
-
4. Dots: 1 is CST, 2 is CS, 3 is outside. Which statement is true?
- Every dot in the square is in the circle.
- Every dot is in the triangle.
- Some dot is in the triangle only.
- No dot is in both the circle and the square.
Show answer
Answer: A. The square holds dots 1 and 2, and both are in the circle. The others fail: dot 2 is not in the triangle, no dot is T alone, and dots 1 and 2 are in both the circle and the square.
-
5. Dots: 1 is C, 2 is S, 3 is T, 4 is outside. Which statement is true?
- Some dot is in the circle and the square.
- No dot is in two figures.
- Every dot is in a figure.
- Some dot is in all three figures.
Show answer
Answer: B. Every code has at most one letter, so no dot is in two figures. Dot 4 is outside, which breaks the 'every dot is in a figure' statement.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.