• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Organ pipe problem set: open pipes, closed pipes and resonance tubes

Find fundamental and harmonic frequencies, identify the type of pipe from its resonances, and use resonance-tube lengths to find the speed of sound.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Questions on air columns follow a handful of patterns. You may be asked for the fundamental of a pipe of given length, for the length that gives a given note, to identify a pipe from the frequencies it resonates at, or to find the speed of sound from a resonance tube experiment. All of them come from the same two results. Take v = 340 m/s unless the question gives another value, and ignore end corrections.

The two results

Fundamental and harmonics
ItemOpen at both endsClosed at one end
Length in terms of λL = λ/2L = λ/4
Fundamentalf₁ = v/(2L)f₁ = v/(4L)
Harmonics presentf₁, 2f₁, 3f₁, ...f₁, 3f₁, 5f₁, ... (odd only)
Gap between neighbouring resonancesf₁2f₁

A useful identification test: if the resonant frequencies are in the ratio 1 : 2 : 3, the pipe is open at both ends; if they are in the ratio 1 : 3 : 5 and the even multiples are missing, it is closed at one end.

Worked examples

Example 1 (open pipe). An open pipe is 0.5 m long. f₁ = 340 ÷ (2 × 0.5) = 340 Hz. The next two harmonics are 680 Hz and 1020 Hz.

Example 2 (closed pipe). A closed pipe is 0.5 m long. f₁ = 340 ÷ (4 × 0.5) = 170 Hz. The next two resonances are 3 × 170 = 510 Hz and 5 × 170 = 850 Hz.

Example 3 (length from neighbouring resonances). A pipe closed at one end resonates at 300 Hz and 500 Hz and at no frequency between them. The gap is 2f₁ = 200 Hz, so f₁ = 100 Hz. The length is L = 340 ÷ (4 × 100) = 0.85 m.

Example 4 (open pipe, neighbouring resonances). An open pipe resonates at 400 Hz and 600 Hz in successive harmonics. The gap is f₁ = 200 Hz. The length is L = 340 ÷ (2 × 200) = 0.85 m.

Example 5 (second harmonic). For an open pipe 0.85 m long, f₁ = 340 ÷ 1.7 = 200 Hz, so the second harmonic is 400 Hz. For a closed pipe of the same length, f₁ = 100 Hz, and there is no 200 Hz resonance at all.

Example 6 (resonance tube). A tuning fork of 500 Hz is held over a tube whose water level is lowered. The first two resonances occur at air-column lengths 17 cm and 51 cm. Successive resonances in a closed tube are λ/2 apart, so λ/2 = 51 − 17 = 34 cm, giving λ = 68 cm = 0.68 m. The speed of sound is v = fλ = 500 × 0.68 = 340 m/s. Using the difference of two lengths removes the effect of the small end correction.

Common traps

  • The third harmonic of a closed pipe is its first overtone, not its second.
  • Using L = λ/2 for a closed pipe or L = λ/4 for an open pipe.
  • Forgetting to convert centimetres to metres in a resonance-tube problem.
  • Assuming a closed pipe has a resonance at 2f₁.

Open pipe: f = n v/2L. Closed pipe: f = (2n − 1) v/4L. Closed tube resonance lengths differ by λ/2.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Identify the pipe type before applying a formula.
  • Neighbouring resonances differ by f₁ in an open pipe and by 2f₁ in a closed pipe.
  • In a resonance-tube experiment the difference of two lengths gives λ/2.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. An open pipe of length 1 m is sounded in its fundamental mode. Take v = 340 m/s. The frequency is:

    1. 340 Hz
    2. 85 Hz
    3. 170 Hz
    4. 680 Hz
    Show answer

    Answer: C. f₁ = v/(2L) = 340 ÷ 2 = 170 Hz.

  2. 2. A closed pipe is 0.25 m long. Take v = 340 m/s. Its fundamental frequency is:

    1. 340 Hz
    2. 170 Hz
    3. 680 Hz
    4. 85 Hz
    Show answer

    Answer: A. f₁ = v/(4L) = 340 ÷ 1 = 340 Hz.

  3. 3. A pipe resonates at 150 Hz and 250 Hz and at no frequency between them. The pipe is:

    1. open at both ends, with fundamental 50 Hz
    2. closed at one end, with fundamental 100 Hz
    3. open at both ends, with fundamental 100 Hz
    4. closed at one end, with fundamental 50 Hz
    Show answer

    Answer: D. 150 : 250 = 3 : 5, with no resonance at 200 Hz, so it is a closed pipe with odd harmonics of f₁ = 50 Hz. An open pipe with f₁ = 50 Hz would also resonate at 200 Hz.

  4. 4. In a resonance tube experiment with a 425 Hz fork, the first two resonances occur at 20 cm and 60 cm. The speed of sound is:

    1. 340 m/s
    2. 170 m/s
    3. 510 m/s
    4. 680 m/s
    Show answer

    Answer: A. λ/2 = 60 − 20 = 40 cm, so λ = 0.8 m. v = fλ = 425 × 0.8 = 340 m/s.

  5. 5. An open pipe is 0.85 m long. Take v = 340 m/s. Its second harmonic has the frequency:

    1. 200 Hz
    2. 300 Hz
    3. 100 Hz
    4. 400 Hz
    Show answer

    Answer: D. f₁ = 340 ÷ (2 × 0.85) = 200 Hz. The second harmonic is 2 × 200 = 400 Hz.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Wave traps and mixed practice

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery