- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Organ pipe problem set: open pipes, closed pipes and resonance tubes
Find fundamental and harmonic frequencies, identify the type of pipe from its resonances, and use resonance-tube lengths to find the speed of sound.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Questions on air columns follow a handful of patterns. You may be asked for the fundamental of a pipe of given length, for the length that gives a given note, to identify a pipe from the frequencies it resonates at, or to find the speed of sound from a resonance tube experiment. All of them come from the same two results. Take v = 340 m/s unless the question gives another value, and ignore end corrections.
The two results
| Item | Open at both ends | Closed at one end |
|---|---|---|
| Length in terms of λ | L = λ/2 | L = λ/4 |
| Fundamental | f₁ = v/(2L) | f₁ = v/(4L) |
| Harmonics present | f₁, 2f₁, 3f₁, ... | f₁, 3f₁, 5f₁, ... (odd only) |
| Gap between neighbouring resonances | f₁ | 2f₁ |
A useful identification test: if the resonant frequencies are in the ratio 1 : 2 : 3, the pipe is open at both ends; if they are in the ratio 1 : 3 : 5 and the even multiples are missing, it is closed at one end.
Worked examples
Example 1 (open pipe). An open pipe is 0.5 m long. f₁ = 340 ÷ (2 × 0.5) = 340 Hz. The next two harmonics are 680 Hz and 1020 Hz.
Example 2 (closed pipe). A closed pipe is 0.5 m long. f₁ = 340 ÷ (4 × 0.5) = 170 Hz. The next two resonances are 3 × 170 = 510 Hz and 5 × 170 = 850 Hz.
Example 3 (length from neighbouring resonances). A pipe closed at one end resonates at 300 Hz and 500 Hz and at no frequency between them. The gap is 2f₁ = 200 Hz, so f₁ = 100 Hz. The length is L = 340 ÷ (4 × 100) = 0.85 m.
Example 4 (open pipe, neighbouring resonances). An open pipe resonates at 400 Hz and 600 Hz in successive harmonics. The gap is f₁ = 200 Hz. The length is L = 340 ÷ (2 × 200) = 0.85 m.
Example 5 (second harmonic). For an open pipe 0.85 m long, f₁ = 340 ÷ 1.7 = 200 Hz, so the second harmonic is 400 Hz. For a closed pipe of the same length, f₁ = 100 Hz, and there is no 200 Hz resonance at all.
Example 6 (resonance tube). A tuning fork of 500 Hz is held over a tube whose water level is lowered. The first two resonances occur at air-column lengths 17 cm and 51 cm. Successive resonances in a closed tube are λ/2 apart, so λ/2 = 51 − 17 = 34 cm, giving λ = 68 cm = 0.68 m. The speed of sound is v = fλ = 500 × 0.68 = 340 m/s. Using the difference of two lengths removes the effect of the small end correction.
Common traps
- The third harmonic of a closed pipe is its first overtone, not its second.
- Using L = λ/2 for a closed pipe or L = λ/4 for an open pipe.
- Forgetting to convert centimetres to metres in a resonance-tube problem.
- Assuming a closed pipe has a resonance at 2f₁.
Open pipe: f = n v/2L. Closed pipe: f = (2n − 1) v/4L. Closed tube resonance lengths differ by λ/2.
Key takeaways
- Identify the pipe type before applying a formula.
- Neighbouring resonances differ by f₁ in an open pipe and by 2f₁ in a closed pipe.
- In a resonance-tube experiment the difference of two lengths gives λ/2.
Check your understanding
-
1. An open pipe of length 1 m is sounded in its fundamental mode. Take v = 340 m/s. The frequency is:
- 340 Hz
- 85 Hz
- 170 Hz
- 680 Hz
Show answer
Answer: C. f₁ = v/(2L) = 340 ÷ 2 = 170 Hz.
-
2. A closed pipe is 0.25 m long. Take v = 340 m/s. Its fundamental frequency is:
- 340 Hz
- 170 Hz
- 680 Hz
- 85 Hz
Show answer
Answer: A. f₁ = v/(4L) = 340 ÷ 1 = 340 Hz.
-
3. A pipe resonates at 150 Hz and 250 Hz and at no frequency between them. The pipe is:
- open at both ends, with fundamental 50 Hz
- closed at one end, with fundamental 100 Hz
- open at both ends, with fundamental 100 Hz
- closed at one end, with fundamental 50 Hz
Show answer
Answer: D. 150 : 250 = 3 : 5, with no resonance at 200 Hz, so it is a closed pipe with odd harmonics of f₁ = 50 Hz. An open pipe with f₁ = 50 Hz would also resonate at 200 Hz.
-
4. In a resonance tube experiment with a 425 Hz fork, the first two resonances occur at 20 cm and 60 cm. The speed of sound is:
- 340 m/s
- 170 m/s
- 510 m/s
- 680 m/s
Show answer
Answer: A. λ/2 = 60 − 20 = 40 cm, so λ = 0.8 m. v = fλ = 425 × 0.8 = 340 m/s.
-
5. An open pipe is 0.85 m long. Take v = 340 m/s. Its second harmonic has the frequency:
- 200 Hz
- 300 Hz
- 100 Hz
- 400 Hz
Show answer
Answer: D. f₁ = 340 ÷ (2 × 0.85) = 200 Hz. The second harmonic is 2 × 200 = 400 Hz.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.