- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Understanding the argument: main ideas, tone and answering questions
Trace how the essay builds its argument, separate material gains from non-material needs, describe the writer's tone, and write clear short answers on the essay's ideas in your own words.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Outline the essay in a few steps.
- Explain the writer's main idea in one or two sentences.
- Describe his tone and point of view, with evidence.
- Write 50-word answers to questions on the essay.
- Form your own view on science and human happiness.
An essay has no characters or plot. Its 'story' is its argument. When you understand the steps of the argument, every question on it becomes easier, because each question points to one step.
The essay in five steps
How the argument moves
- The question Where is science taking us?
- Values Science has weakened moral and spiritual values.
- Machines Great material power has brought new problems faster than solutions.
- Aims and goal Its aims are material; its final goal should be a richer life.
- Hope Science may improve reasoning; the future is exciting.
The main idea
Science has given us enormous material power but has done nothing to make us wiser, kinder or more just; what the world needs now is moral progress, and the writer hopes that science itself may one day help bring it.
The writer's tone and point of view
| Tone | Evidence (in our own words) |
|---|---|
| Questioning | He keeps asking questions: what is life, what is science after, what are its aims? |
| Critical but fair | He praises science's material triumphs but shows the problems they bring. |
| Worried | He calls war the worst example and says morals are struggling far behind. |
| Hopeful | He thinks science may improve reasoning enough to end war. |
| Enthusiastic | He says life is becoming more exciting and wishes for another hundred years. |
Notice that the writer is not against science. He is a scientist speaking to the public. His complaint is that science has been allowed to race ahead while human values stand still. This balance is important in answers: do not write that he thinks science is bad.
Material and non-material
A key pair of ideas in the essay is material (things that can be touched, measured or made: food, machines, medicines) and non-material (qualities of mind and spirit: charity, tolerance, justice, mercy, the meaning of life). Science deals well with the first and is helpless, the writer says, with the second.
Worked example 1: a list answer
Question: List the material triumphs of science and the non-material needs that would make the world better. Working: collect the gains from part 1 and the qualities from part 2. Answer (about 50 words): Science has filled life with machines; it lets us fly, travel under the sea, grow enough food for everyone, live longer and enjoy more leisure. But to make the world better we need non-material things: charity, understanding of one another, forbearance, tolerance, justice and mercy, and the ability to tell good from evil.
Worked example 2: ethics and morals
Question: What has happened to ethics and morals in the modern world, according to the writer? Working: find where he uses the word 'floundering'. He says science has pushed war so far forward that ethics and morals are struggling hopelessly behind. Answer: moral thinking has not kept pace with scientific power; we have weapons that can kill vast numbers, but not the wisdom or goodness to stop using them.
Think for yourself
The book invites discussion: are people happier than their forefathers? Is man the master or the slave of machines? A good answer weighs both sides. For example: phones connect families across the world, yet they can also keep us from talking to the people beside us. Tractors save hours of labour, yet that free time is wasted if we do not use it well. Give examples from your own life, and reach a balanced conclusion.
Read an essay as an argument: question, reasons, examples, conclusion. Name the writer's tone and prove it.
Key takeaways: the essay moves from a question, through the failures and dangers of the machine age, to the true goal of science and a hopeful ending. The writer is a balanced critic of science, not its enemy. Answer questions by finding the right step of the argument and putting it in your own words.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which statement best describes the writer's view of science?
- Science is evil and should be stopped.
- Science has solved all human problems.
- Science has great material power but has not improved human values.
- Science is only about machines.
Show answer
Answer: C. He praises science's material triumphs but says it has been helpless in moral matters such as charity and justice. He is a balanced critic, not an enemy of science.
-
2. Which of these is a non-material need named in the essay?
- Tolerance
- Petrol
- Medicines
- Shelter
Show answer
Answer: A. Tolerance is a quality of mind and character, not a thing. Petrol, medicines and shelter are material things.
-
3. Which word best describes the tone of the writer's ending?
- Bitter
- Despairing
- Mocking
- Optimistic
Show answer
Answer: D. He says life is becoming more interesting and exciting and wishes for another hundred years: an optimistic tone.
-
4. Why does the writer call war the worst example of the problems science creates?
- Wars stopped all scientific work.
- Science has increased the power to kill far beyond our moral control.
- Wars were caused by scientists alone.
- Machines are never used in war.
Show answer
Answer: B. He says science has pushed war so far forward that ethics and morals are left struggling behind: our power to destroy has outgrown our wisdom.
-
5. In the essay, what is the main job of the questions the writer keeps asking?
- To show that he has no answers at all
- To make listeners think and to lead them through his argument
- To test the listeners' knowledge of science
- To fill time in the broadcast
Show answer
Answer: B. His questions (what is life, what is science after) guide the listener step by step and make them think along with him. He does give answers, so he is not simply puzzled.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.