- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Where is Science Taking Us?, part 1: big questions and the machine age
Follow the first half of Dr S. W. Pennycuick's talk: the new question about science, its failure in moral and spiritual matters, the power of machines and the problems science creates, and learn its new words.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Say who wrote the essay, what kind of text it is and when it was given.
- Explain the two big questions the writer begins with.
- Explain why he says science does 'less than nothing' for moral and spiritual values.
- Describe the good and bad sides of the machine age that he points out.
- Use words such as ethical, spiritual, flounder and overwhelming correctly.
The second lesson of the PSEB Class 10 English Main Course Book is Where is Science Taking Us? by Dr S. W. Pennycuick. It was first a broadcast talk given from Adelaide in Australia; the book notes it was delivered around the 1950s, a few years after the Second World War. So it is an essay that argues a point, not a story. Read it as an argument: what is the writer's question, what reasons does he give, and what does he conclude?
Two big questions
The writer begins with the oldest question people have asked: what is the meaning of life, where are we going, and what drives us to work and worry? Then he adds a newer question that is forcing itself on our attention: where is science taking us? The old question has been with us since people first began to think; the new one has arisen only because science has become so powerful.
Science and moral and spiritual values
First he asks what science does for ethical values (ideas of right and wrong) and spiritual values (matters of the human spirit). Material things are the daily business of science, but what about the non-material? He says the answer is worse than 'nothing'. Science has stressed material explanations so heavily that many people are confused and wonder whether a human being is only a machine moved by forces beyond his control. In other words, science has not just failed to help our values; it has weakened people's belief in them.
The age of the machine
Next he turns to material things, the stronghold of science. This is the age of the machine: machines are in fields, factories, homes and streets. We can fly without wings and travel under the sea without gills. But machines also let us kill other people in huge numbers. The essay says that machines give the people of busy industrial countries the power of hundreds of servants each; his point is that people now command enormous mechanical power.
What this power has brought
- Food, but not for all: before the war it looked possible, for the first time in history, to feed, clothe and house every person on earth; that would have been one of science's greatest triumphs. Yet the world has often been full of food while people went hungry. Science produces goods but cannot control what happens to them.
- Leisure without wisdom: machines give us more free time each year but do not teach us how to use it. They give us mechanical habits of mind and weaken the spirit of adventure.
- Longer lives, new problems: modern medicines keep adding to the average length of life, so the older age group grows crowded. The writer gives figures for the United States in his time and asks who will support all these people. Society will have to readjust.
- War: the worst example. Science has pushed the power of war so far ahead that ethics and morals are left struggling far behind.
He sums this up with an image: science creates problems faster than they can be solved. Humanity is caught in a vicious circle, always trying to catch up and never getting closer, and there is no sign that the flood of new discoveries will stop.
The vicious circle the writer describes
- New discovery Science gives a new machine or medicine.
- New power People can do more: produce, travel, live longer, fight.
- New problem Hunger amid plenty, idle leisure, crowded old age, war.
- Struggle to catch up Society and morals try to adjust, but too slowly.
Then back to step 1: New discovery
New words from this part
| Word | Meaning | Our own example |
|---|---|---|
| ethical | to do with right and wrong | Copying in a test is not ethical. |
| spiritual | to do with the human spirit or soul, not the body | Prayer gives her spiritual strength. |
| flounder | to struggle helplessly, not knowing what to do or say | Without notes, the speaker began to flounder. |
| animated | full of life and movement; here, moved or driven | The children had an animated discussion about the match. |
| overwhelming | very great or very strong | The team won by an overwhelming margin. |
| teeming | full of, crowded with | The station was teeming with passengers before Diwali. |
| leisure | free time | He spends his leisure reading. |
| vicious circle | a situation in which one problem causes another that makes the first worse | Stress stopped her sleeping, and lack of sleep added to her stress. |
Worked example 1: 'less than nothing'
Question: Why does the writer say science is doing less than nothing for moral and spiritual values? Working: 'nothing' would mean no effect. 'Less than nothing' must mean a harmful effect. What harm does he name? Science's material teachings have been so over-stressed that people doubt whether they are anything more than machines. Answer: instead of supporting moral and spiritual values, science has weakened them, by making people think that only material things matter.
Worked example 2: hunger amid plenty
Question: What does the writer mean when he says science produces the goods but has no control over the consequences? Working: find his example. Science made it possible to grow enough food for everyone, yet people still starved while food lay unused. The failure lay not in production but in how people shared and used it. Answer: science can make things, but how they are used, fairly or unfairly, wisely or foolishly, depends on human values that science does not supply.
The argument so far: science is strong in material things, weak in moral ones, and creates problems faster than we can solve them.
Key takeaways: Dr Pennycuick's broadcast talk asks where science is taking us. Science has weakened moral and spiritual values, and the machine age, for all its power, has brought hunger amid plenty, leisure without wisdom, an ageing population and terrible war, trapping us in a vicious circle.
Check your understanding
-
1. What kind of text was 'Where is Science Taking Us?' originally?
- A short story
- A newspaper report
- A broadcast talk
- A poem
Show answer
Answer: C. The book says it is taken from a broadcast talk by Dr S. W. Pennycuick from Adelaide, Australia. That is why it speaks directly to listeners and asks many questions.
-
2. Why does the writer call the question 'Where is science taking us?' a newer question?
- Only recently has science become powerful enough to raise it.
- People never thought about life before.
- Science was invented in the 1950s.
- It was first asked in Australia.
Show answer
Answer: A. The question about the meaning of life is as old as thinking itself, but science has only recently grown so powerful that we must ask where it is leading us.
-
3. According to the writer, what happened to food before and during the war?
- Science failed to produce enough food.
- Machines destroyed all the crops.
- Everyone was well fed for the first time.
- There was plenty of food, yet people went hungry.
Show answer
Answer: D. He says it looked possible to feed everyone, but the world was often full of food while people starved. Science made the goods but could not control how they were used.
-
4. What does the writer say machines fail to do with the extra leisure they give us?
- They fail to teach us how to use it.
- They fail to give us any leisure at all.
- They fail to make us work harder.
- They fail to keep us healthy.
Show answer
Answer: A. He says the machine age gives us more free hours every year but fails to teach us how to use them well.
-
5. Which sentence uses 'flounder' correctly?
- The flounder of the hill was steep.
- Asked a question he had not prepared for, he began to flounder.
- She flounders the rice before cooking.
- The machine is a flounder of power.
Show answer
Answer: B. To flounder is to struggle helplessly, not knowing what to say or do. Only the sentence about the unprepared speaker uses the verb with this meaning.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.