- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Where is Science Taking Us?, part 2: the aims of science and what the world needs
Follow the second half of the talk: the two material aims of science, its true ultimate goal, the small moral advance the world waits for, the hope of a better human brain, and the writer's hopeful ending.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State the two apparent aims of science.
- Explain what the writer thinks the ultimate goal should be.
- List the non-material qualities the world is waiting for.
- Explain his hope that science may one day improve the human brain.
- Explain why he wishes he had another hundred years.
In the second half of the talk Dr Pennycuick asks what science is really after, and answers that its present aims are too narrow. Then, surprisingly, he ends not in gloom but in hope.
The two apparent aims of science
- Conquest of the environment: to understand and control everything material in the world, large or small, and bring all its powers within human reach.
- Mysteries of the body: to understand the countless chemical and physical processes that make the human body work.
Both aims are material. The writer accepts them but says they cannot be the final goal.
The ultimate goal
The real goal, he says, if there is one, must be to understand everything that makes life worth living and to enrich all that life means. That goes beyond material things, because human beings need more than food, clothing, shelter and knowledge of how the stomach works.
The small advance the world is waiting for
What the world needs most is not another world-shaking discovery in nuclear physics, chemistry or medicine. It is a small advance, even a slight one, in charity, understanding, forbearance, tolerance, justice and mercy. The world, he says, is waiting for this, and waiting anxiously. But these are non-material things, and here science has been helpless: it cannot even help us tell good from evil.
What science gives and what the world needs
-
Material gains of science
- Machines in every field of life
- Flight and travel under the sea
- Enough food could be produced for all
- Longer lives through medicines
- More hours of leisure
-
Non-material needs
- Charity and mercy
- Understanding of one another
- Forbearance (patience)
- Tolerance
- Justice
- Knowing good from evil
A hope for the future
This may not always be so. The writer thinks science might one day improve the human brain. Not its structure, which he calls the greatest miracle of all, but its function: its capacity and power of reasoning. He has little doubt that humans will one day improve on the natural human being and gain enough reason and understanding to abolish war. Whether people will also understand one another better, and when, remains to be seen.
The ending
He returns to the title question. In spite of the ups and downs of the present, we are going somewhere. Hard times lie ahead, but he calls those who fear the future cowardly in spirit, because life is becoming ever more interesting and exciting. He ends by wishing he had another hundred years to live and see what comes.
New words from this part
| Word | Meaning | Our own example |
|---|---|---|
| conquest | complete control gained over something | The conquest of smallpox was a victory for medicine. |
| ultimate | final, most important | Her ultimate aim is to become a doctor. |
| forbearance | patience and self-control towards others | The teacher listened to the noisy class with great forbearance. |
| tolerance | willingness to accept views or ways different from one's own | Tolerance helps neighbours of different faiths live in peace. |
| abolish | to end something completely by law or decision | The school has abolished the fine for late library books. |
| vicissitudes | changes of fortune, ups and downs | The family stayed together through all the vicissitudes of life. |
| intriguing | very interesting because unusual or mysterious | The detective found an intriguing clue. |
| craven | cowardly | It was craven of him to run away and leave his friend. |
Worked example 1: the ultimate aim
Question: What should be the ultimate aim of science? Working: separate the apparent aims (control of the environment, understanding the body) from what the writer calls the final goal. Answer (about 50 words): Science now aims at material things: conquering nature and understanding how the body works. The writer says its ultimate aim should be to understand and enrich everything that makes life worthwhile. People need more than food and shelter; science should help them grow in charity, tolerance, justice and mercy.
Worked example 2: a hundred more years
Question: Why does the writer wish to live another hundred years? Working: look at the last paragraph. He admits there are troubles ahead but says life is becoming more interesting and exciting, and he hopes for great changes, even an end to war. Answer: he is an optimist and is eager to see where science will lead, so he wishes he had a hundred more years to watch it happen.
Science's aims today are material. Its ultimate goal should be to enrich all that makes life worthwhile; the world waits for a small advance in charity, tolerance, justice and mercy.
Key takeaways: science aims to conquer nature and understand the body, but its final goal should be a richer human life. The world needs a small moral advance more than a big discovery. The writer hopes science may improve human reasoning enough to end war, and he faces the future with excitement, not fear.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these is one of the two apparent aims of science named by the writer?
- To abolish war at once
- To teach people how to use leisure
- To understand the chemical and physical workings of the human body
- To decide what is good and evil
Show answer
Answer: C. The two aims he names are the conquest of the material environment and the understanding of the material mysteries inside the human body.
-
2. What advance does the writer say the world is really waiting for?
- A small advance in charity, tolerance, justice and mercy
- A great discovery in nuclear physics
- A faster machine for travel
- A new medicine to lengthen life
Show answer
Answer: A. He says the world does not need another earth-shaking discovery but a slight advance in charity, understanding, forbearance, tolerance, justice and mercy.
-
3. What kind of improvement in the brain does the writer think science might bring?
- A change in its shape
- A larger brain size
- A structural improvement
- A functional improvement in reasoning power
Show answer
Answer: D. He says it would not be structural, because the brain's structure is already a miracle, but functional: an increase in its capacity and power of reasoning.
-
4. What is the writer's attitude to the future at the end of the talk?
- Afraid and gloomy
- Hopeful and eager
- Uninterested
- Angry with scientists
Show answer
Answer: B. He admits hard times lie ahead but calls those who fear the future cowardly, says life is getting more exciting, and wishes for another hundred years. That is a hopeful, eager attitude.
-
5. What does 'forbearance' mean?
- Patience and self-control towards others
- Great strength of body
- A ban on something
- A sudden change of fortune
Show answer
Answer: A. Forbearance is patient self-control, especially when others try us. A sudden change of fortune would be a vicissitude; a ban comes from abolishing something.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.