- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
One Thousand Dollars: Gillian's character, themes and the twist
Describe Robert Gillian, Miss Hayden, Old Bryson and Miss Lauriere with evidence, explain the story's themes of wise spending, love and sacrifice, read its irony, and prepare for the book's discussion questions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe how Gillian changes, with evidence from the story.
- Describe the other characters briefly.
- State the themes and message, and explain the irony.
- Plan answers for the book's two discussion questions.
At the start, Gillian looks like a spoilt young man who laughs at a thousand dollars. By the end he has given up six thousand dollars and his reputation for the woman he loves. This lesson studies that change and what it means.
How Gillian changes
Gillian at the start and at the end
-
At the start
- Laughs at $1,000 as too little
- Used to a large allowance
- Dislikes keeping accounts
- Happy to spend it all on a pendant
-
At the end
- Gives all $1,000 to Miss Hayden
- Gives up $5,000 more for her
- Writes the only account that matters to him
- Accepts being called a waster, and whistles
Characters with evidence
| Character | Quality | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Robert Gillian | Careless with money (at first) | Laughs at the gift; plans to spend it in one lump to avoid accounts. |
| Robert Gillian | Generous and selfless | Gives all the money to Miss Hayden and gives up the $5,000 for her. |
| Robert Gillian | Modest | Hides his good deed and lets the lawyers think he gambled. |
| Robert Gillian | Loving | Calls Miss Hayden the best and dearest woman on earth. |
| Miss Hayden | Quiet, dignified, ill-treated by the will | Lives as the uncle's ward and is left only a ring and $10. |
| Old Bryson | Calm, sarcastic, moralising | Lists good uses of money, then mocks Gillian with the pendant idea. |
| Miss Lauriere | Vain and money-minded | Bored by Gillian; impressed only by a $2,200 necklace. |
| The lawyers | Formal and strict | Follow the will exactly; judge Gillian by his reputation. |
Themes
- What is 'wise' spending? Old Bryson lists useful ways to spend; Gillian finds the wisest of all, giving to someone in need whom he loves.
- Love and sacrifice: Gillian gives up money and his good name so that Miss Hayden will be secure.
- Appearances deceive: the 'black sheep' is the most generous person; the blind beggar is richer than he looks; the lawyers judge wrongly.
- Testing character: the uncle's will is a test, and Gillian passes it in a way the uncle could not have expected.
Irony
The story is full of irony. Gillian passes his uncle's test, yet chooses to be marked as failing it. The lawyers feel disgust for the man who has just behaved best. The money meant for the 'sensible' nephew goes, by his own choice, to the ward the uncle left almost nothing. And the story is told lightly, with jokes about microbes and pendants, until we realise it is about a quiet act of love.
The discussion questions
The book asks whether Gillian did the right thing by giving up $5,000, and whether he agrees with the proverb that a bird in the hand is better than two in the bush, that is, that it is wiser to keep what you have than to risk it for more.
Worked example 1: did Gillian do the right thing?
Plan: take a side, give two reasons, answer the other side. Sample: 'Yes. First, Miss Hayden had lived in the uncle's house and was left almost nothing, so the money gave her security. Second, Gillian loved her and gained happiness, which he valued above money. Some may say he lied to the lawyers and lost money he had earned by spending well, but his lie harmed no one and helped the person who needed it most.'
Worked example 2: the proverb and Gillian
Working: the proverb praises holding on to a sure gain. Gillian does the opposite: he gives away the sure $1,000 and lets go of the $5,000 too. So the proverb does not describe him. Sample answer: 'Gillian does not follow the proverb, because for him the true prize was not money but Miss Hayden's happiness. The story suggests that some things are worth more than the bird in the hand.'
A character's change is the heart of a story: show where he begins, what changes him and where he ends.
Key takeaways: Gillian changes from a careless young man into a selfless, modest lover who sacrifices money and reputation. The story explores wise spending, love and sacrifice, and how appearances deceive. Its irony is that the 'black sheep' is judged a failure at the very moment he behaves best.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which quality does Gillian show by letting the lawyers think he gambled the money away?
- Dishonesty for his own gain
- Selfless modesty: he hides his good deed so Miss Hayden gains
- Laziness
- Fear of the lawyers
Show answer
Answer: B. He gains nothing from the pretence; he loses $5,000 and his good name so that Miss Hayden receives it.
-
2. Which character is shown as vain and interested mainly in costly things?
- Miss Hayden
- Old Bryson
- Miss Lotta Lauriere
- Lawyer Tolman
Show answer
Answer: C. She is bored by Gillian and talks only of a $2,200 necklace, showing she values expensive gifts.
-
3. Why is it ironic that the lawyers shake their heads in disgust at the end?
- They had stolen the money
- They knew the truth all along
- Gillian had insulted them
- They despise Gillian at the very moment he has acted most generously
Show answer
Answer: D. They believe he gambled the money, but he had in fact spent it in the best possible way. Their judgement is the opposite of the truth.
-
4. Which theme do the blind pencil-seller and Gillian's 'black sheep' label both show?
- Appearances can deceive
- Money always brings happiness
- Lawyers are dishonest
- Theatre is a waste of time
Show answer
Answer: A. The poor-looking blind man has savings, and the so-called black sheep proves the most generous. Neither is what he seems.
-
5. How does Gillian's action relate to the proverb 'A bird in the hand is better than two in the bush'?
- He follows it exactly by keeping his money
- He goes against it: he gives away the sure money and gives up more for someone he loves
- He uses it to win the $5,000
- It has nothing to do with money
Show answer
Answer: B. The proverb advises keeping a sure gain. Gillian gives away both the $1,000 and the chance of $5,000, valuing Miss Hayden's happiness above money.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.