• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

One Thousand Dollars: Lotta Lauriere, the cab driver and the blind man

Retell the middle of the story in your own words: Gillian's visit to Miss Lotta Lauriere, the answers of the cab driver and the blind pencil-seller, and how these meetings change his thinking.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Retell Gillian's three meetings in the correct order.
  • Explain how Miss Lauriere received Gillian and his offer.
  • Say what the cab driver and the blind man answered and what Gillian made of it.
  • Explain where Gillian went next and why.

In this part, Gillian asks three very different people what they would do with a thousand dollars. Each answer teaches him something, and by the end of the lesson he has quietly made up his mind.

Part 4: at the Columbine Theatre

Gillian takes a cab to the theatre where Miss Lotta Lauriere is about to perform. She lets him in but looks bored and reminds him she must go on stage in two minutes. He asks, almost in code, whether she would like a pendant costing a figure followed by three ciphers (zeros), that is, a thousand dollars. She answers carelessly and tells him that a necklace another performer wore the other night cost two thousand two hundred dollars. Then she leaves for her show. The message is clear: a thousand-dollar gift does not impress her, and she cares about what jewels cost, not about Gillian.

Part 5: the cab driver

Back in the cab, Gillian asks the driver what he would do with a thousand dollars. Without a pause the driver says he would open a saloon (a place selling alcohol) and make money hand over fist, and he begins to ask whether Gillian is thinking of something. Gillian cuts him short: he asked only out of curiosity. The answer is about making more money for oneself, and Gillian is not interested.

Part 6: the blind man selling pencils

A few blocks down Broadway, Gillian sees a blind man selling pencils on the pavement. He gets out and asks him the same question. Instead of answering, the blind man takes out a bank deposit book and lets Gillian see it. It shows a balance of $1,785 in the blind man's name. Gillian returns the book without a word and gets back into the cab. The man he thought of as poor already has more money than Gillian's whole inheritance.

Part 7: a question for the lawyer

Gillian now tells the driver to go to the office of Tolman and Sharp on Broadway. There he cheerfully asks Mr Tolman one question: did his uncle leave Miss Hayden anything besides the ring and the ten dollars? Nothing, says Tolman. Gillian thanks him and goes out to his cab. We are not told yet why he asked, but the question shows where his thoughts have turned.

Gillian's journey with the thousand dollars

  1. Club Old Bryson mocks him with the pendant idea.
  2. Theatre Miss Lauriere is bored; $1,000 is too little.
  3. Cab The driver wants a saloon.
  4. Pavement The blind man already has $1,785.
  5. Lawyers Miss Hayden got nothing more.
  6. Uncle's house He goes to see Miss Hayden.
What each answer showed Gillian.
PersonAnswerWhat it showed
Miss LauriereTalks of a $2,200 necklaceShe values costly jewels, not him; $1,000 is nothing to her.
Cab driverOpen a saloonMoney spent only to make more money.
Blind pencil-sellerShows $1,785 in the bankEven a poor-looking man may not need help; the money should go where it is truly needed.

Worked example 1: was Miss Lauriere pleased?

Question: Did Miss Lauriere welcome Gillian, and was she happy with his offer? Working: look at her manner (bored, in a hurry) and her reply (she mentions a necklace that cost more than twice his budget, then walks off). Answer: no; she received him coolly and was not impressed, because a thousand-dollar pendant seemed cheap to her compared with the $2,200 necklace she had admired.

Worked example 2: did Gillian like the driver's answer?

Question: Did Gillian like the cab driver's answer? How do you know? Working: find Gillian's reaction. He stops the driver's question and says he asked only out of curiosity, then tells him simply to drive on. Answer: no; he showed no interest in the saloon idea and quickly ended the conversation.

When a character asks the same question of several people, compare the answers: the writer is showing us his choices.

Key takeaways: Miss Lauriere is bored and unimpressed by a $1,000 pendant; the driver wants a saloon; the blind pencil-seller already has $1,785 saved. After these meetings, Gillian asks the lawyer whether Miss Hayden got anything more, learns she did not, and heads for his uncle's house.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What did Miss Lotta Lauriere mention when Gillian spoke of a pendant?

    1. That she disliked jewellery
    2. A necklace another performer wore that cost $2,200
    3. That she would rather have flowers
    4. That she was leaving the theatre for ever
    Show answer

    Answer: B. She talked about a necklace costing two thousand two hundred dollars, showing that a $1,000 gift did not impress her.

  2. 2. What did the cab driver say he would do with a thousand dollars?

    1. Buy a new cab
    2. Give it to the poor
    3. Open a saloon
    4. Travel to New Hampshire
    Show answer

    Answer: C. He answered at once that he would open a saloon and make plenty of money.

  3. 3. How did the blind man answer Gillian's question?

    1. He showed Gillian his bank deposit book with a balance of $1,785
    2. He asked Gillian for the money
    3. He said he would buy more pencils
    4. He refused to speak
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Instead of answering, he showed his bank book. It held more money than Gillian's whole inheritance.

  4. 4. Where did Gillian go immediately after talking to the blind man?

    1. Miss Hayden
    2. Miss Lauriere
    3. The club
    4. The lawyers
    Show answer

    Answer: D. He told the driver to go to Tolman and Sharp, where he asked whether Miss Hayden had been left anything more. This is the book's own question 10.

  5. 5. What did Gillian ask Mr Tolman on this visit?

    1. Whether he could have more money
    2. Whether Miss Hayden had been left anything besides the ring and ten dollars
    3. Whether the will could be changed
    4. Whether Old Bryson was an heir
    Show answer

    Answer: B. His only question was about Miss Hayden's share. Tolman said she got nothing more, which prepares for what Gillian does next.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery