The argument of part 1
- Total freedom for each The old lady walks where she likes.
- Everyone does the same Drivers use the pavement too.
- Chaos Nobody gets anywhere.
- Small limits for all The policeman stops traffic in turn.
- Real liberty Everyone can move safely.
Where am I free?
-
My own kingdom
- My hair, clothes and hobbies
- When I sleep and wake
- Others may laugh; I may ignore them
-
Shared space
- Roads and public places
- Noise that reaches neighbours
- My liberty must fit with theirs
| Word | Meaning | Our own example |
|---|---|---|
| jolly | cheerful and amusing | We had a jolly time at the picnic. |
| peril | serious danger | Swimming in the flooded canal is full of peril. |
| universal chaos | complete disorder everywhere | Without traffic lights, the crossing would be universal chaos. |
| anarchy | lawlessness; no order or control | When the referee left, the match fell into anarchy. |
| curtail | to reduce or cut short | The school curtailed the lunch break by ten minutes. |
| tyranny | cruel and unfair use of power | The villagers rose against the landlord's tyranny. |
| insolence | rude lack of respect | His insolence towards the umpire cost him the match. |
| maelstrom | a violent whirlpool; a scene of confusion | The station became a maelstrom of people at Diwali. |
To keep the liberty of all, the liberty of each must be limited a little.
Key takeaways: The old lady confuses liberty with doing as she pleases; if everyone did so, there would be chaos. The policeman's limits make liberty real. In private matters we are free; in shared spaces our liberty must fit with others'.