• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Theme, style and message: rights and duties, with paragraph writing

Understand the essay's theme of individual liberty and social responsibility, how Gardiner argues through anecdotes, his humorous and ironic tone, and write a paragraph on 'Rights and Duties Go Together'.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State the theme of the essay in two or three sentences.
  • Explain 'Liberty is not a personal affair only, but a social contract'.
  • Describe Gardiner's method and tone.
  • Write a well-organised paragraph on rights and duties.

Questions on this essay often ask for its theme or for an explanation of one of its key lines. This lesson brings the ideas together.

The theme

The essay is about the balance between individual liberty and social responsibility. We are free in matters that concern only ourselves; where our actions affect others, our freedom must be adjusted to theirs. Liberty without limits destroys itself, because everyone's unlimited liberty collides. Good conduct rests on consideration for others, and it is shown less in great deeds than in small daily manners.

'Liberty is a social contract'

A contract is an agreement in which each side gives something and gets something. In society, each of us gives up a little freedom - waiting at the signal, keeping noise down - and in return gets order and safety, in which real freedom is possible. Gardiner calls this an accommodation of interests: everyone's interests are fitted together.

How Gardiner argues

Anecdote or examplePrinciple it illustrates
The old lady in the roadUnlimited liberty leads to chaos
The policeman at Piccadilly CircusSmall limits make liberty real
Dressing-gown, dyed hair, odd hatsWe are free in purely personal matters
Guitar at midnightOur liberty ends where others' begins
The loud passengerConsideration is the base of good conduct
The street pianoSome clashes have no easy answer
The child's educationSociety may step in when we harm others

Gardiner's method

  1. An amusing anecdote
  2. A general principle
  3. A new example that tests the principle

Then back to step 1: An amusing anecdote

Each example leads to a principle, and the next example tests it again.

Tone and style

  • Humorous: the 'liberty-drunk' world, the lady attracting pianos like wasps to jam.
  • Ironic: the talker believes he gave everyone a wonderful journey; the essay ends hoping he will reflect.
  • Honest and modest: Gardiner admits he cannot solve the street-piano case.
  • Conversational: he speaks to the reader as 'you' and uses everyday examples.
  • Persuasive: he moves from small stories to a large idea the reader cannot easily reject.

Writing a paragraph: Rights and Duties Go Together

Plan: a topic sentence; what rights and duties are; an example; why they cannot be separated; a conclusion.

Worked example 1: a model paragraph

Every right we enjoy comes with a duty attached. If I have the right to use the public park, I also have the duty to keep it clean for the next visitor. A student who wants a quiet library must also study silently there. When people demand rights but forget duties, as the old lady in Gardiner's essay did, everyone's rights collapse into disorder. Rights and duties are two sides of one coin: by doing our duty, we protect the rights of others, and they, in turn, protect ours. (About 95 words: topic sentence, two everyday examples, a link to the lesson, a conclusion.)

Worked example 2: 'Can we do whatever we like?'

Question: Can we do whatever we feel like doing? Working: the answer has two parts - yes in personal matters, no where others are affected - each with an example. Answer: Only in matters that concern ourselves alone, such as our clothes or hobbies. Where our actions touch others, as with noise at night or using the road, we must limit our liberty so that it does not interfere with theirs.

My liberty ends where your liberty begins.

Key takeaways: The theme is the balance of personal liberty and social responsibility. Gardiner argues through amusing anecdotes leading to principles, in a humorous, ironic and conversational style. A good paragraph on rights and duties shows, with examples, that each right brings a duty.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which sentence best states the theme of the essay?

    1. Trains should be quieter
    2. Personal liberty must be balanced with consideration for others' liberty
    3. Everyone should learn the guitar
    4. Policemen are cruel
    Show answer

    Answer: B. All the anecdotes lead to one idea: our freedom must fit with the freedom of others.

  2. 2. Why does Gardiner call liberty a 'social contract'?

    1. Because it is written on paper
    2. Because only lawyers understand it
    3. Because each person gives up a little freedom and gets order and safety in return
    4. Because it can be bought
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Like a contract, it involves give and take: small limits in exchange for an order that makes freedom real.

  3. 3. What is Gardiner's main method of argument?

    1. Amusing anecdotes that lead to general principles
    2. Statistics and charts
    3. Quotations from laws
    4. A single long story
    Show answer

    Answer: A. He uses the old lady, the policeman, the guitar, the passenger and the street piano to reach his principles.

  4. 4. Which example shows Gardiner's honesty and modesty?

    1. Describing the policeman
    2. Studying the Blue-book
    3. Choosing his child's school
    4. Admitting he cannot settle the street-piano dispute
    Show answer

    Answer: D. He openly says he cannot decide whose liberty should give way, since both tastes are reasonable.

  5. 5. What makes the essay's last line ironic?

    1. It is written in verse
    2. The loud passenger, who thought he had pleased everyone, is the one who most needs to reflect
    3. It praises the policeman
    4. It asks for the old lady's pardon
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The man believed he had given everyone an illuminating journey; Gardiner gently hopes he will learn from the essay.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery