- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
The Rule of the Road, part 1: the old lady, the policeman and the limits of liberty
Follow the first half of A.G. Gardiner's essay - the old lady in the middle of the road, the policeman at Piccadilly Circus, liberty as a social contract and the 'kingdom' where we rule alone - and use its new words.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Say who wrote the essay and what it is about.
- Explain the story of the old lady and what it shows about liberty.
- Explain why the policeman is a symbol of liberty, not tyranny.
- Tell apart matters where we are free and matters where others' liberty limits ours.
- Use words such as chaos, anarchy, curtail, tyranny and insolent.
Lesson 8 of the PSEB English Main Course Book is The Rule of the Road, an essay by A.G. Gardiner, a British journalist and essayist who wrote under the pen name Alpha of the Plough (the book says 'Alpha'). His essays are light, humorous and wise. This one is about rights and responsibilities in society; its central idea is that one person's rights end where another person's rights begin. He makes the point through small, amusing stories called anecdotes.
The old lady in Petrograd
Gardiner begins with a story told by the writer Arthur Ransome from Petrograd (the Russian city now called St Petersburg). A stout old lady was walking with her basket right down the middle of a busy street, confusing the traffic and putting herself in danger. When told that the pavement was for people on foot, she replied that she would walk where she liked, because they now had liberty. Gardiner points out what she missed: if liberty lets a walker use the middle of the road, it also lets a driver use the pavement. The result would be universal chaos - everyone in everyone's way and nobody getting anywhere. Individual liberty would turn into social anarchy.
The policeman at Piccadilly Circus
The world, Gardiner warns, is in danger of becoming 'liberty-drunk' like the old lady. The rule of the road means that to keep everyone's liberty, everyone's liberty must be cut down a little. When a policeman at Piccadilly Circus (a busy London junction) raises his hand and stops your car, you may feel angry at this interference. But a sensible person sees that if he did not stop you, he could stop no one, and the junction would become a whirlpool that nobody could cross. By accepting a small limit on your freedom, you enjoy a social order that makes your freedom real. So the policeman is a symbol of liberty, not of tyranny.
The argument of part 1
- Total freedom for each The old lady walks where she likes.
- Everyone does the same Drivers use the pavement too.
- Chaos Nobody gets anywhere.
- Small limits for all The policeman stops traffic in turn.
- Real liberty Everyone can move safely.
Liberty is a social contract
Liberty, Gardiner says, is not only a personal matter but a social contract - an adjustment of everyone's interests. In things that touch no one else, we may be as free as we like. If he chooses to walk down a London street in a dressing-gown with long hair and bare feet, or to dye his hair, wear odd clothes, or go to bed late, nobody may stop him. Others are free to laugh; he is free not to care. Each of us has a private 'kingdom' where we rule alone and may be wise or silly, strict or easy-going.
But the moment we step out of that kingdom, our liberty is limited by other people's liberty. Gardiner imagines practising the guitar from midnight to three in the morning: on a lonely hilltop, fine; in the street, the neighbours will remind him that his liberty to play must not destroy their liberty to sleep. He adds a sharp observation: we all notice other people's failings in this matter far more easily than our own.
Where am I free?
-
My own kingdom
- My hair, clothes and hobbies
- When I sleep and wake
- Others may laugh; I may ignore them
-
Shared space
- Roads and public places
- Noise that reaches neighbours
- My liberty must fit with theirs
New words from part 1
| Word | Meaning | Our own example |
|---|---|---|
| jolly | cheerful and amusing | We had a jolly time at the picnic. |
| peril | serious danger | Swimming in the flooded canal is full of peril. |
| universal chaos | complete disorder everywhere | Without traffic lights, the crossing would be universal chaos. |
| anarchy | lawlessness; no order or control | When the referee left, the match fell into anarchy. |
| curtail | to reduce or cut short | The school curtailed the lunch break by ten minutes. |
| tyranny | cruel and unfair use of power | The villagers rose against the landlord's tyranny. |
| insolence | rude lack of respect | His insolence towards the umpire cost him the match. |
| maelstrom | a violent whirlpool; a scene of confusion | The station became a maelstrom of people at Diwali. |
Worked example 1: how was the old lady mistaken?
Question: How was the stout old lady mistaken about liberty? Working: state what she thought (liberty means doing as she likes), then what follows if everyone thinks so (drivers on pavements, chaos). Answer: she thought liberty meant walking wherever she liked, forgetting that the same liberty would let drivers go on the pavement; if all did so, the result would be chaos, not freedom.
Worked example 2: what does the policeman symbolise?
Question: What does the policeman at Piccadilly Circus symbolise? Working: he limits each driver for a moment, but that limit lets everyone cross safely. Answer: he is a symbol of liberty, because the small restrictions he imposes create the order in which everyone's freedom to move becomes real.
To keep the liberty of all, the liberty of each must be limited a little.
Key takeaways: The old lady confuses liberty with doing as she pleases; if everyone did so, there would be chaos. The policeman's limits make liberty real. In private matters we are free; in shared spaces our liberty must fit with others'.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why was the old lady walking in the middle of the road?
- The pavement was being repaired
- She was lost
- She believed that liberty allowed her to walk wherever she liked
- A policeman told her to
Show answer
Answer: C. She told those who warned her that she would walk where she liked because they now had liberty.
-
2. What would follow, in Gardiner's view, if everyone used liberty as the old lady did?
- Universal chaos, with nobody getting anywhere
- Faster traffic
- More policemen
- Perfect order
Show answer
Answer: A. If walkers used the road and drivers the pavement, everyone would block everyone else - individual liberty would become social anarchy.
-
3. Why is the policeman a symbol of liberty and not of tyranny?
- Because he is friendly
- Because he lets everyone go at once
- Because he wears a uniform
- Because his small limits create an order in which everyone can move freely
Show answer
Answer: D. Without his interference the junction would be impossible to cross; the small limit he imposes makes freedom real.
-
4. Which of these is a matter of personal liberty, according to the essay?
- Playing a guitar loudly in the street at midnight
- Dyeing one's hair or wearing unusual clothes
- Driving on the pavement
- Walking in the middle of a busy road
Show answer
Answer: B. Hair, clothes and similar private choices affect no one else, so we may do as we like.
-
5. Which sentence uses 'curtail' correctly?
- Rising prices forced the family to curtail its spending.
- She curtailed the song very beautifully.
- The dog curtailed at the postman.
- He curtailed a new house.
Show answer
Answer: A. 'Curtail' means to reduce or cut short - here, to reduce spending.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.