- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
The Rule of the Road, part 2: the loud passenger, the guitar, the street piano and small manners
Follow the second half of the essay - the talkative man in the railway carriage, the right way to practise the guitar, the clash over street pianos, the limits on a parent's freedom and the importance of small acts of conduct - and learn its new words.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe how the writer was disturbed on his train journey and what the man lacked.
- Explain the guitar and street-piano examples.
- Explain why we must be a 'judicious mixture' of anarchist and socialist.
- Explain the essay's conclusion about small matters of conduct.
In the second half Gardiner turns from roads to everyday behaviour, using a personal experience and a few neighbourly quarrels to make his point.
The talkative passenger
One morning Gardiner boarded a train at a country station, planning an hour's hard study of a Blue-book (an official government report). He was reading it not for pleasure but as work, the way a lawyer studies a case - and work, unlike a good novel, needs quiet. At the next station two men got in, and one of them talked loudly and pompously to his friend for the rest of the journey about every subject under the sun. Gardiner did not complain; he felt the man would only have thought him rude. The talker probably left believing he had given everyone a most educational journey. He meant no harm, but he lacked social sense - he was not, in Gardiner's phrase, a 'clubbable' man, someone fit to be good company.
From this Gardiner draws a key principle: reasonable consideration for the rights and feelings of others is the foundation of social conduct.
The guitar, the attic and the flower beds
Returning to the guitar, Gardiner says a learner has every right to practise in his own house, even if it annoys the neighbours - but it is his duty to keep the nuisance as small as possible. He should practise in the attic with the window shut, not in the front room with the window open, blasting noise into the neighbours' ears. Disturbing their quiet on purpose is as rude as walking uninvited into their garden and trampling their flower beds.
When liberties clash
Some clashes seem impossible to settle. Gardiner's friend X, good-natured but quick-tempered, rushes out angrily to send away any street piano he hears. Nearby lives a lady who adores street pianos and attracts them as jam attracts wasps. Whose liberty should give way? Gardiner honestly admits he cannot say - liking street pianos is as reasonable as disliking them - and jokes that he would love to hear Sancho Panza (a sensible character in Cervantes' novel Don Quixote) solve the riddle.
Neither complete anarchists nor complete socialists
In this complex world, Gardiner concludes, we can be neither complete anarchists (people who reject all control) nor complete socialists (here: people who let society decide everything). We must be a judicious mixture of both, protecting both individual and social liberty. As a parent, he will let no authority decide which school his child goes to, whether the child studies science or arts, or plays cricket or football - these are personal matters. But if he refused to educate his child at all, or raised him as a savage or a pickpocket, society would rightly insist on a minimum of education. No one has the liberty to be a nuisance to neighbours or to make a child a danger to the community.
The conclusion: small matters
It is in small matters of everyday behaviour - in keeping the rule of the road - that we show whether we are civilised. Great moments of heroism and sacrifice are rare; it is our little daily habits with other people that make life sweet or bitter. Gardiner ends with gentle irony: he hopes his friend from the railway carriage will think about this.
Part 2 at a glance
-
Train journey
- Loud talker; no social sense
- Consideration is the base of good conduct
-
Guitar
- Right to practise
- Duty to keep the noise small
-
Street piano
- A clash with no easy answer
-
Child's education
- Choice of school: personal
- No education at all: society objects
-
Conclusion
- Small daily manners show if we are civilised
New words from part 2
| Word | Meaning | Our own example |
|---|---|---|
| swot | (informal) hard study, especially for an exam | She had an hour's swot before the test. |
| pompous | trying to seem important; self-important | His pompous speech bored the audience. |
| irascibility | a tendency to get angry quickly | The old man's irascibility kept the children away from his garden. |
| dote on | to love or like too much | Grandparents often dote on the youngest child. |
| trespass | to enter someone's land without permission | Do not trespass in the orchard. |
| primeval savage | a wild, uncivilised person of the earliest times | Education lifts us far above the primeval savage. |
| judicious | wise and sensible | A judicious mix of study and rest works best. |
| nuisance | a thing or person that causes annoyance | Loud horns at night are a nuisance. |
Worked example 1: why did the writer need quiet?
Question: Why did the writer need reasonable silence in the compartment? Working: what was he reading, and why? A Blue-book, as work, not for pleasure. What does such reading need? Concentration. Answer: he was studying an official report as a task, and reading as a task, unlike reading a good novel, needs quiet to concentrate.
Worked example 2: 'a judicious mixture of both'
Question: What does the writer mean by saying we must be a judicious mixture of both? Working: 'both' means anarchist and socialist. Find his examples: personal choices (school, subjects, games) belong to him; refusing all education harms society, so society may step in. Answer: we should insist on freedom in personal matters but accept society's control where our actions affect others.
A reasonable consideration for the rights or feelings of others is the foundation of social conduct.
Key takeaways: The talkative passenger lacked social sense. A learner may practise the guitar but must reduce the nuisance. Some clashes have no easy answer. We need a wise balance of personal and social liberty, and small daily manners show whether we are civilised.
Check your understanding
-
1. What was the writer reading on the train?
- A detective novel
- A newspaper
- A Blue-book, an official report, as part of his work
- A letter from a friend
Show answer
Answer: C. He was studying a Blue-book - an official report - not for pleasure but as a task.
-
2. What, according to Gardiner, was wrong with the loud passenger?
- He was dishonest
- He lacked social sense and did not think of others
- He was a thief
- He spoke a foreign language
Show answer
Answer: B. He meant well but did not consider that others might want quiet - he was not 'clubbable'.
-
3. How should a person learning the guitar practise, according to the essay?
- In the front room with the windows open
- In the street at midnight
- Only at a friend's house
- In the attic with the window shut, keeping the nuisance small
Show answer
Answer: D. He has the right to learn at home but the duty to reduce the noise reaching the neighbours.
-
4. Why can Gardiner not settle the street-piano dispute?
- Liking street pianos is as reasonable as disliking them
- The lady is his sister
- Street pianos are illegal
- His friend X moved away
Show answer
Answer: A. He says both tastes are equally reasonable, so he cannot say whose liberty should give way.
-
5. Where, according to the conclusion, do we show whether we are civilised?
- In great acts of heroism
- In the books we read
- In small matters of everyday conduct
- In how rich we are
Show answer
Answer: C. Heroic moments are rare; our little daily habits towards others make life sweet or bitter and show if we are civilised.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.