- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Definitions and basic principles of democracy
Recall the definitions of democracy given by Lincoln, Seeley, Hall, Dicey and Bryce, and explain the basic principles on which every democracy rests.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Match five thinkers with their definitions of democracy.
- Explain the basic principles of democracy in your own words.
- Apply the principles to decide whether a government action is democratic.
Political thinkers have defined democracy in many ways. No single definition captures all of it, so the PSEB textbook first gives several definitions and then lists the basic principles that together describe democracy fully.
Five definitions
Government of the people, by the people, for the people.
| Thinker | The main idea |
|---|---|
| Abraham Lincoln | Government of the people, by the people and for the people |
| Seeley | A government in which everyone has a share |
| Hall | A political organisation in which public opinion is in control |
| Dicey | A government in which the governing body is a fairly large part of the whole nation |
| Bryce | Rule of the whole people, who express their sovereign will through their votes |
Notice the common thread: power comes from the people as a whole, not from one person or one class, and the people express it mainly through votes and public opinion.
The basic principles
The textbook lists twelve principles. They fall naturally into four groups.
Basic principles of democracy
-
Freedom and tolerance
- Freedom of speech and expression, to criticise and to differ
- Tolerance of other views
- Dignity of the individual, protected by rights
-
Peace, not force
- Disputes settled peacefully
- Against violence, even in the name of welfare
- Suppression in the name of welfare is not democratic
- Government changed only by constitutional means
-
Power of the people
- Sovereignty lies with the people
- Representatives elected by adult franchise (age 18)
- Majority rules, but minority rights are protected
-
Constitution and welfare
- Government works by the constitution the people accept
- Aims at the welfare of all sections of society
Freedom and tolerance
Democracy gives people the right to speak, to criticise and to disagree. It rests on tolerance: everyone is free to express an opinion, even one others dislike. It also raises the dignity of the individual, which is why citizens are given many kinds of rights.
Peace, not force
Democracy settles disputes, at home and between nations, by peaceful means. It is clearly against violence, even if someone claims violence would serve society. A government that uses unfair, suppressive power in the name of social welfare is not democratic. And in a democracy the government can be changed only by constitutional methods, such as elections, never by violent ones.
Power of the people
Sovereignty lies with the people. The government is made of representatives elected through adult franchise: in India, every adult who has reached 18 years can choose a representative without fear or pressure. In practice democracy is majority rule, but the interests and rights of minorities are protected.
Constitution and welfare
A democratic government works strictly according to the constitution accepted by the people, and aims at the greatest welfare of all sections of society, not just a few.
Worked example 1: testing an action
Question: A government jails newspaper editors who criticise it, saying this keeps society calm. Which principles does it break? Reasoning: Step 1 - jailing critics denies freedom to criticise and to differ. Step 2 - it uses suppression in the name of welfare. Answer: It breaks the principles of free expression and tolerance, and the rule that suppression in the name of welfare is not democratic.
Worked example 2: majority and minority
Question: In a town council, 12 of 20 members vote to close a school that serves a small language community, without hearing that community. Is the decision fully democratic? Reasoning: Step 1 - 12 of 20 is a majority (more than half), so majority rule is followed. Step 2 - but democracy also protects the interests of minorities, and they were not heard. Answer: Majority rule was followed, but the principle of protecting minority interests was ignored, so the decision falls short of democracy.
Key takeaways: Lincoln, Seeley, Hall, Dicey and Bryce all place power with the people as a whole. The basic principles are freedom and tolerance, peaceful change, sovereignty of the people through adult franchise with minority rights protected, and government by an accepted constitution for the welfare of all.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who defined democracy as a government in which everyone has a share?
- Lord Bryce
- Hall
- Dicey
- Seeley
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook gives this definition from Seeley. Hall stresses control by public opinion, Dicey a large governing body and Bryce rule of the whole people through votes.
-
2. Which thinker's definition focuses on control by public opinion?
- Hall
- Abraham Lincoln
- Seeley
- Dicey
Show answer
Answer: A. Hall describes democracy as a form of political organisation in which public opinion has control.
-
3. According to the principles of democracy, how may a government be changed?
- By a military coup
- By violent protest
- By constitutional methods such as elections
- Only when the ruler dies
Show answer
Answer: C. Democracy allows the government to be changed only by constitutional methods. It opposes changing governments by violent means.
-
4. Democracy is described in practice as majority rule. Which condition goes with it?
- The minority must leave the country
- The interests and rights of the minority are protected
- The minority cannot vote
- The majority can change the constitution at will
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook's principle is that democracy is practically a rule of the majority in which the interests and rights of the minority are protected.
-
5. A government uses force to silence protesters, saying it is for the good of society. According to the principles, this government is:
- democratic, because its aim is welfare
- democratic, because it was elected
- democratic, if the protesters are few
- not democratic, because suppression in the name of welfare is not allowed
Show answer
Answer: D. One principle says a government that uses unfair suppressive power in the name of social welfare cannot be called democratic. Good intentions do not excuse suppression.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.