- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Hurdles to democracy and conditions for its success
Explain the main obstacles to democracy, such as illiteracy, poverty, casteism and indifference, and the conditions, such as literacy, equality and an independent judiciary, that help democracy succeed.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the hurdles in the way of democracy listed in the textbook.
- Explain the conditions necessary for democracy to succeed.
- Match each hurdle with the condition that overcomes it.
Democracy may be the best form of government, but it does not succeed automatically. The PSEB textbook names the serious problems that hold it back, and then the conditions that make it work well.
Hurdles in the way of democracy
| Hurdle | Why it is harmful |
|---|---|
| Regionalism | Narrow loyalty to a region placed above national interest harms national unity |
| Illness | People suffering from long illness lose interest in public affairs |
| Casteism and communalism | Spread hatred and tension; fatal to national unity |
| Illiteracy | People cannot understand national problems and fall for false promises |
| Poverty | The poor may be pushed to sell their votes and cannot speak freely |
| Indifference | Lazy or uninterested citizens do not vote or take part |
| Other problems | Weak party ideals, corruption, loss of faith in parties, negative opposition, falling patriotism |
Look closely at illiteracy and poverty, which the textbook explains in most detail. An illiterate person, it says, may not fully understand the economic, social and political problems of the nation, may be misled by selfish politicians' false promises and so cannot do full justice to the right to vote. A poor person may be forced to sell the vote, may not express views freely, and sometimes does not vote at all, while the rich can buy votes.
Conditions for the success of democracy
What democracy needs to succeed
-
Freedom and equality
- Political freedom: speech, assembly, association, criticism
- Economic equality: basic needs met, no exploitation
- Social equality: no discrimination by race, caste, sex, religion or birthplace
-
Good citizens and leaders
- Literacy
- High moral values
- Enlightened, alert citizens
- Honest, wise leaders
-
Sound institutions
- Local self-government
- Independent, impartial judiciary
- Rule of law
- Decentralisation of power
- Organised parties based on principles
Economic equality: the textbook says political democracy without economic equality is meaningless. Complete equality is not possible, but everyone's basic needs must be met, exploitation must end and national wealth must not remain in a few hands. Social equality: no citizen should face discrimination on the basis of race, caste, sex, religion or place of birth.
Literacy, morals and alert citizens: educated citizens understand national problems and think liberally. If people and leaders are corrupt, democracy collapses like a pack of cards. Citizens must know their rights and do their duties; if they are not alert, rulers may turn into dictators. Ideal leaders must be honest and wise and able to decide rightly at the right time.
Institutions: village panchayats, panchayat samitis, zila parishads and municipal committees train people in administration. An independent and impartial judiciary protects citizens' rights and stops the government from becoming dictatorial; Lord Bryce held that a government's quality is best judged by how well its courts work. Rule of law means no one is above the law and all are equal before it. Decentralisation lets people share in administration so that no office becomes absolute. Political parties are the backbone of democracy, and they should stand on principles, not on caste or community.
Hurdles: illiteracy, poverty, casteism, communalism, regionalism, illness and indifference. Cures: literacy, economic and social equality, alert citizens, honest leaders, an independent judiciary, rule of law and decentralisation.
Worked example 1: matching a hurdle to a cure
Question: In a village many voters cannot read and believe whatever promise a candidate makes. Which hurdle is this, and which condition helps? Reasoning: Step 1 - inability to read and understand issues is illiteracy. Step 2 - education lets people judge promises. Answer: Hurdle: illiteracy. Condition: literacy (and enlightened citizenship).
Worked example 2: rule of law
Question: A powerful businessman breaks a traffic rule and expects the police to let him go because of his wealth. Which condition of democracy says he must be treated like anyone else? Reasoning: Rule of law means no one is above the law and everyone is equal before it. Answer: Rule of law.
Key takeaways: Regionalism, illness, casteism and communalism, illiteracy, poverty, indifference and corruption weaken democracy. It succeeds with political freedom, economic and social equality, literacy, high morals, alert citizens, honest leaders, local self-government, an independent judiciary, rule of law, decentralisation and principled parties.
Check your understanding
-
1. How is poverty a threat to democracy, according to the textbook?
- Poor people are not allowed to vote by law
- A poor person may be forced to sell the vote and cannot express views freely
- Poor people always vote for the same party
- Poverty makes elections unnecessary
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says a poor person may be compelled to sell the vote, may not speak freely and sometimes does not vote, while the rich can buy votes.
-
2. Which of these is a condition for the success of democracy rather than a hurdle?
- Indifferent attitude
- Casteism
- Regionalism
- Decentralisation of powers
Show answer
Answer: D. Decentralisation lets people share in administration and prevents any office becoming absolute, so it helps democracy. The other three are hurdles.
-
3. Why does the textbook call political democracy without economic equality meaningless?
- Because great economic inequality can lead to revolution and exploitation
- Because only the rich should vote
- Because equality is written only in economics books
- Because every person must earn the same salary
Show answer
Answer: A. Large economic gaps can cause revolution. Complete equality is impossible, but basic needs must be met and exploitation ended for political democracy to have meaning.
-
4. Which bodies does the textbook name as local self-government that trains people in administration?
- Supreme Court and High Courts
- Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha
- Village panchayats, panchayat samitis, zila parishads and municipal committees
- Election Commission and Finance Commission
Show answer
Answer: C. Local bodies such as village panchayats, panchayat samitis, zila parishads and municipal committees educate and train people in administration.
-
5. What does an independent and impartial judiciary do for democracy?
- It makes all the laws
- It protects citizens' rights and stops the government from becoming a dictator
- It runs elections
- It chooses the Prime Minister
Show answer
Answer: B. An independent judiciary protects citizens' rights and checks the government, preventing it from becoming dictatorial.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.