- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Democratic or not? Tests, examples and types of democracy
Use the textbook's examples to test whether an elected government is truly democratic, and explain the difference between direct and indirect (representative) democracy.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why holding elections alone does not make a country democratic.
- Apply four tests to the textbook's examples of Pakistan, China, Fiji and Mexico.
- Explain India's record on women's right to vote.
- Tell direct democracy from indirect (representative) democracy.
Many governments hold elections and call themselves democratic. The PSEB textbook asks a sharper question: is every government elected by the people really democratic? It answers through four examples, each failing a different test.
Four tests of a real democracy
- Power with the people's representatives: the final say must lie with elected representatives, not with an army or one ruler.
- A real choice: opposition parties must be free to exist and contest.
- One person, one vote, one value: every vote must count equally.
- Free and fair elections: periodic elections are not enough; they must be held fairly.
Four examples from the textbook
Pakistan under Musharraf: General Pervez Musharraf took power through a military coup in 1999. The textbook says he reduced the powers of the national and provincial legislatures, declared himself Chief Executive and later President, gave the President power to dissolve parliament at any time, and set up a council of military officers to watch over the legislatures. The final power did not rest with the people's representatives, so this fails test 1.
A one-party state: the textbook's example is China, where, it says, elections are held every five years but only candidates nominated by the ruling party can contest, and some army officers sit in parliament. With no opposition allowed, voters have no real choice. This fails test 2.
Fiji: under the electoral system the textbook describes, the vote of an indigenous Fijian carried more value than that of a Fijian of Indian origin. That breaks the rule of one person, one vote, one value - test 3.
Mexico: Mexico elects its President every six years and has not been ruled by the military. Yet until 2000 every presidential election was won by one party, the PRI (Institutional Revolutionary Party). Other parties could contest, but the textbook says the ruling party used unfair means: officials were made to attend its meetings, government teachers were told to press parents to vote for it, and polling booths were moved at the last moment so opposition supporters could not vote. Elections were held, but not fairly - test 4.
Which test does each example fail?
-
Pakistan (1999)
- Military ruler over parliament
- Fails: power with representatives
-
One-party state
- Only one party's candidates
- Fails: real choice
-
Fiji
- Votes of unequal value
- Fails: one person, one vote, one value
-
Mexico (till 2000)
- Unfair means in elections
- Fails: free and fair elections
India and women's vote
The textbook takes pride that in India, from 1950, when the Constitution came into force, women have had the right to vote equally with men. Developed democracies were slower: women in the United States won the vote nationally in 1920, and women in Britain gained the vote on equal terms with men only in 1928.
Types of democracy
Direct and indirect democracy
-
Direct democracy
- Citizens make laws themselves
- Worked in small Greek city-states
- Not practical for large modern states
-
Indirect (representative) democracy
- People elect representatives
- Representatives run the government
- Used by most countries today, including India
In direct democracy every citizen takes part in making laws to solve the country's problems. It worked when states were tiny, with populations in thousands, like the Greek city-states, but it is not practical today. Most countries therefore have indirect or representative democracy, in which people elect representatives who run the government.
A real democracy needs free and fair periodic elections, power in the hands of the people's representatives, an opposition, and one person, one vote, one value.
Worked example 1: applying the tests
Question: Country Q holds elections every four years with several parties, but in rural areas each vote is counted twice while city votes are counted once. Which test fails? Reasoning: Elections are periodic and parties exist, but votes have different values. Answer: It fails the test of one person, one vote, one value.
Worked example 2: how many elections?
Question: If a country elects its President every six years, how many presidential elections fall between 1976 and 2000, counting both years? Working: 1976, 1982, 1988, 1994, 2000 = 5 elections. Check: (2000 - 1976) / 6 = 4 gaps, so 4 + 1 = 5.
Key takeaways: Elections alone do not make a democracy. Power must lie with elected representatives (Pakistan under Musharraf failed this), opposition must exist (a one-party state fails), votes must be equal (Fiji's system failed) and elections must be free and fair (Mexico until 2000 failed). India gave women equal votes from 1950. Most countries today use indirect, representative democracy.
Check your understanding
-
1. Why does the textbook say Fiji's electoral system, as it describes it, was not democratic?
- Fiji had no elections
- Only the army could vote
- The vote of one group had more value than that of another
- Fiji had only one party
Show answer
Answer: C. An indigenous Fijian's vote carried more value than that of an Indian Fijian, breaking the principle of one person, one vote, one value.
-
2. What was undemocratic about elections in Mexico until 2000, according to the textbook?
- Opposition parties were banned
- The ruling PRI used unfair means to win
- Elections were never held
- Only soldiers could contest
Show answer
Answer: B. Other parties could contest, but the PRI used unfair means such as pressuring officials and teachers and shifting polling booths at the last moment. Elections must be free and fair.
-
3. Under Musharraf after 1999, why does the textbook say Pakistan's government was not democratic?
- Final power did not rest with the people's elected representatives
- Women ruled the country
- There were too many parties
- It followed one person, one vote, one value
Show answer
Answer: A. Musharraf reduced the legislatures' powers, could dissolve parliament and set up a military council to watch them, so the final power did not lie with the people's representatives.
-
4. Most countries today, including India, have:
- direct democracy
- military rule
- monarchy
- indirect or representative democracy
Show answer
Answer: D. Direct democracy suited only small city-states. Today most countries use indirect democracy, where people elect representatives who run the government.
-
5. From when have Indian women had the right to vote equally with men?
- 1947
- 1950
- 1928
- 1989
Show answer
Answer: B. From 1950, when the Constitution came into force, women in India had the right to vote equal to men. Britain gave equal voting terms only in 1928.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.