• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Features of the parliamentary system

Explain the eight features of parliamentary government given in the textbook, from the nominal head of state and collective responsibility to the leadership of the Prime Minister and cooperation between parties.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the eight features of a parliamentary system.
  • Explain collective and individual responsibility of ministers.
  • Describe how the legislature controls ministers.
  • Explain how parliamentary government works in Indian States.

The PSEB textbook lists eight features of the parliamentary system, all of which exist in India. Together they show how the cabinet, the head of state, the legislature and the parties fit together.

1. A nominal head of state

The head of state may be a President, a Governor-General or a King or Queen. The textbook's examples: a President heads the state in India, France and Austria; a Governor-General (representing the Crown) in Canada, Australia and New Zealand; a King or Queen in Japan (an Emperor), England, Denmark, the Netherlands, Sweden and Norway. In law the head has great powers, but in practice the cabinet uses them and runs the administration in the head's name, carrying the full responsibility.

2. Clear majority

The party that wins a clear majority forms the government. The head of state invites its leader to become Prime Minister; the Prime Minister gives a list of ministers, and the head of state appoints them. Ministers stay only while they keep the majority in the legislature (in India, the Lok Sabha). Forming a government is easy in a two-party system but harder in a multi-party system, where no party may win a majority; then several parties join to form a coalition government, which may be less stable. The textbook adds that a government with a clear majority is a good sign for parliamentary democracy.

3. Collective responsibility

The cabinet is jointly responsible. Once the cabinet decides something, every minister must support it inside and outside the legislature, even one who disagreed in the cabinet meeting. All ministers share responsibility for every department's policy. The textbook says that if a censure motion is passed even against one minister, it is treated as against the whole cabinet, which must resign with the Prime Minister. Each minister is also individually responsible for his or her own department.

How the legislature controls ministers

  • Questions Members ask ministers about their departments
  • Motions Adjournment, call attention, censure and no-confidence motions
  • Bills and budget Legislature has full control over the budget
  • Enquiry committees Can probe charges of corruption against ministers

4. Ministers must be members of the legislature

Ministers must be members of the legislature. A person who is not a member may be appointed minister, but in India must become a member of either House within six months, or leave the post.

5. Leadership of the Prime Minister

The Prime Minister leads the cabinet and, as leader of the majority in the lower house, is also leader of the House. Ministers are appointed on his or her advice. The Prime Minister presides over cabinet meetings, decides their dates and agenda, has the final word on disputed issues, allots departments, and coordinates and supervises ministers. A minister who does not cooperate must resign, or the Prime Minister can ask the President to remove that minister. The Prime Minister is the government's chief spokesperson and keeps the President informed.

6. Political homogeneity

Usually ministers belong to one party and share the same ideology, so policies can be carried out smoothly. In a coalition, ministers come from several parties and agree on a common minimum programme. If a partner leaves, the government may lose its majority, and a new cabinet has to be formed.

7. Secrecy

Ministers take an oath of secrecy when appointed. Cabinet decisions must be kept confidential until the right time, and strict action can follow if a minister leaks them.

8. Mutual tolerance among parties

The majority party governs and the others form the opposition, whose duty is to oppose policies against the public interest and check misuse of power. The ruling party should listen to criticism patiently and correct its faults; the opposition's criticism should be positive, not criticism for its own sake, and free of provocative speeches. Since today's opposition may be tomorrow's government, the two sides need a spirit of cooperation.

In the States the same system works: the Governor is the nominal head, and the Chief Minister and council of ministers are the real executive.

Collective responsibility: the ministers stand or fall together; individual responsibility: each minister answers for his or her own department.

Worked example 1: which feature?

Question: A minister argued against a decision in a cabinet meeting, but defends it in public after it is taken. Which feature is this? Reasoning: Supporting every cabinet decision, whatever one's personal view, is the meaning of joint responsibility. Answer: Collective responsibility.

Worked example 2: the six-month rule

Question: A person who is not a member of Parliament is made a minister on 1 March. By when must he or she become a member? Working: Six months from 1 March is 1 September. Answer: Before the six months end, that is, by about the end of August; otherwise the person must leave the post.

Key takeaways: A parliamentary system has a nominal head of state, a government formed by the majority, collective and individual responsibility of ministers, ministers drawn from the legislature (in India within six months), leadership by the Prime Minister, political homogeneity, secrecy and mutual tolerance between ruling and opposition parties. Indian States follow the same pattern, with the Governor as nominal head.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In Canada and Australia, who is named by the textbook as head of state in the parliamentary system?

    1. A President
    2. The Prime Minister
    3. The Chief Justice
    4. A Governor-General
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The textbook says that in Canada, Australia and New Zealand the Governor-General is the head of state (representing the Crown), while India, France and Austria have Presidents.

  2. 2. What does collective responsibility of the cabinet mean?

    1. Every minister must support a cabinet decision, and the cabinet stands or falls together
    2. Each minister can oppose cabinet decisions in public
    3. Only the Prime Minister is responsible
    4. Ministers are responsible only to the judiciary
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Under collective responsibility, every minister supports cabinet decisions inside and outside the legislature, and all ministers share responsibility for all policies.

  3. 3. Within what time must a non-member appointed as minister in India become a member of Parliament?

    1. One month
    2. Two years
    3. Six months
    4. Five years
    Show answer

    Answer: C. In India a person who is not a member of either House may be made a minister but must become a member within six months, or resign.

  4. 4. What do ministers of a coalition government usually agree on?

    1. A single party symbol
    2. A common minimum programme
    3. Abolishing the opposition
    4. Changing the head of state
    Show answer

    Answer: B. In an alliance government ministers from several parties form a common minimum programme which they all follow.

  5. 5. In an Indian State, who is the nominal head under the parliamentary system?

    1. The Chief Minister
    2. The Speaker
    3. The Prime Minister
    4. The Governor
    Show answer

    Answer: D. In a State the Governor is the nominal or constitutional head, while the Chief Minister and council of ministers form the real executive.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery