- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
The Council of Ministers and the Prime Minister
Describe the ranks in the Council of Ministers, how ministers are appointed, their collective and individual responsibility, and the powers and limits of the Prime Minister.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the ranks of ministers in the Council of Ministers.
- Explain how the Prime Minister and other ministers are appointed.
- Explain collective and individual responsibility.
- List the powers of the Prime Minister and explain their limits.
In India's parliamentary system, the President is the nominal head of the executive. The real executive powers are used by the Council of Ministers, headed by the Prime Minister. Article 74(1) provides for a Council of Ministers, with the Prime Minister at its head, to aid and advise the President.
Ranks of ministers
Council of Ministers
- Cabinet Ministers Top rank; heads of major departments; attend Cabinet meetings; the Prime Minister is one of them
- Ministers of State Lower rank; may or may not hold independent charge; attend Cabinet meetings only when invited
- Deputy Ministers Third rank; assist Cabinet Ministers; no independent charge; do not attend Cabinet meetings
- Parliamentary Secretaries Not ministers; help ministers in their work
The Cabinet - the Prime Minister and the Cabinet Ministers - is the real executive that forms national policy. Salaries and allowances of ministers are fixed by Parliament from time to time.
Appointment of ministers
How the Council of Ministers is formed
- Lok Sabha election People elect their representatives
- Majority party chooses a leader In a coalition, the allied parties choose one leader together
- President appoints the Prime Minister The leader of the majority
- Prime Minister gives a list Names of other ministers
- President appoints ministers And administers the oaths of office and secrecy
- A minister must be a member of either House of Parliament. A non-member may be appointed but cannot remain a minister for more than six months without becoming a member.
- The Council of Ministers is dissolved when the Prime Minister resigns.
Collective and individual responsibility
The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible. The Constitution makes it responsible to the Lok Sabha (Article 75(3)); the textbook puts it as responsibility to Parliament. A policy made for one department is the responsibility of the whole Council, and if the House withdraws its confidence, the whole Council must resign. The textbook adds that a censure motion passed against one minister is treated as against the whole Council.
Each minister is also individually responsible for his or her department. If a department's work is poor, the Prime Minister can ask that minister to resign, and if the minister refuses, can advise the President to remove him or her.
The Prime Minister
The Prime Minister is the real executive and the leader of the nation. After a Lok Sabha election the President appoints the leader of the majority party (or of an alliance) as Prime Minister, who is also the leader of the Lok Sabha. The textbook observes that voters often feel they are choosing a Prime Minister rather than just a party. Pt. Jawaharlal Nehru was the first Prime Minister of free India.
- Forms the Council of Ministers.
- Allots portfolios (departments) to ministers and can change them.
- Coordinates the work of ministers and settles disputes between departments.
- Can ask any minister to resign and can reorganise the Council.
- Is the link between the President and the Council: informs the President of Cabinet decisions; a minister meets the President on official matters only with the Prime Minister's permission.
- Decides the agenda of Cabinet meetings and presides over them.
- Can advise the President to dissolve the Lok Sabha.
With so much power, some critics call this 'Prime Ministerial government'. The textbook disagrees: the Prime Minister can act only within the Constitution, takes an oath to uphold it, and must face public opinion. But public opinion can check power only if citizens are educated, alert and aware - the success of democracy depends on them.
The Council of Ministers stands or falls together and is answerable to the Lok Sabha; the Prime Minister leads it, but only within the Constitution.
Worked example 1: who attends?
Question: Which of these normally attend Cabinet meetings: a Cabinet Minister, a Minister of State who has not been invited, a Deputy Minister? Reasoning: Only Cabinet Ministers attend as of right; Ministers of State come only when invited; Deputy Ministers do not attend. Answer: Only the Cabinet Minister.
Worked example 2: what happens when the Prime Minister resigns?
Question: A Prime Minister resigns. Do the other ministers stay in office? Reasoning: The Council of Ministers is formed around the Prime Minister and is dissolved by the Prime Minister's resignation. Answer: No. The whole Council of Ministers goes, and a new one must be formed.
Key takeaways: Under Article 74(1) the Council of Ministers, headed by the Prime Minister, aids and advises the President. It has Cabinet Ministers, Ministers of State and Deputy Ministers, helped by Parliamentary Secretaries. Ministers must be MPs (or become one within six months). The Council is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha, and each minister is individually responsible for a department. The Prime Minister forms and leads the Council but must act within the Constitution and face public opinion.
Check your understanding
-
1. Under which article is a Council of Ministers provided to aid and advise the President?
- Article 52
- Article 79
- Article 74(1)
- Article 360
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 74(1) provides for a Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister to aid and advise the President.
-
2. Which rank of minister does not take part in Cabinet meetings and has no independent charge?
- Deputy Minister
- Cabinet Minister
- Minister of State with independent charge
- Prime Minister
Show answer
Answer: A. Deputy Ministers are third in rank; they help Cabinet Ministers in their departments, do not attend Cabinet meetings and are not given independent charge.
-
3. Who presides over the meetings of the Cabinet?
- The President
- The Speaker
- The Vice-President
- The Prime Minister
Show answer
Answer: D. The Prime Minister decides the agenda and presides over Cabinet meetings.
-
4. To which House is the Council of Ministers collectively responsible under the Constitution?
- Rajya Sabha
- Lok Sabha
- The Supreme Court
- State Legislative Assemblies
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 75(3) makes the Council of Ministers collectively responsible to the House of the People, the Lok Sabha.
-
5. What happens to the Council of Ministers when the Prime Minister resigns?
- Only the Prime Minister leaves
- The President takes over as Prime Minister
- The whole Council of Ministers is dissolved
- The senior-most minister automatically becomes Prime Minister
Show answer
Answer: C. The Council of Ministers is formed around the Prime Minister, so it is dissolved when the Prime Minister resigns.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.