• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Parliamentary and presidential government

Name the three organs of government, explain how parliamentary and presidential systems differ in the relation between legislature and executive, and describe how a cabinet depends on the confidence of the legislature.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Name the three organs of government.
  • Tell a parliamentary system from a presidential one.
  • Explain the difference between the nominal and the real executive.
  • Explain what happens when a cabinet loses the confidence of the legislature.

India has chosen a parliamentary democracy, both at the Centre and in the States. To understand what that means, the PSEB textbook first compares it with the other main type of democratic government, the presidential system.

Three organs of government

Organs of government

  • Legislature Makes laws (in India, Parliament)
  • Executive Carries out laws and runs the administration
  • Judiciary Interprets laws and settles disputes

Democratic governments are divided into two types according to the relation between the legislature and the executive.

Two types of democratic government

Parliamentary and presidential systems

  • Parliamentary (e.g. England, India)
    • Real executive is the cabinet
    • Ministers come from the legislature
    • Cabinet answerable to the legislature
    • Legislature can remove the cabinet
    • Head of state is only a nominal executive
  • Presidential (e.g. USA)
    • President is the real executive
    • Executive separate from the legislature
    • Legislature cannot remove the executive by a vote of no confidence
    • Fixed term for the executive

The parliamentary system is traditionally linked with England, and the presidential system developed in the United States of America. In a parliamentary system the legislature and executive are closely joined: the cabinet is directly and legally answerable to the legislature for its acts.

Garner's definition

The textbook quotes the political scientist Garner. In our own words, his definition says: in cabinet government the real executive - the cabinet or ministry - is directly and legally responsible to the legislature (usually its more popular, lower house) for its policies and acts, and in the end responsible to the voters; while the nominal or titular executive - the head of state - is not held responsible.

Parliamentary system: the cabinet (real executive) stays in office only while it has the confidence of the legislature; the head of state is the nominal executive.

How the cabinet depends on the legislature

  • Members of the cabinet are taken from the legislature and are heads of departments.
  • The cabinet is a team from the party with a majority, almost like a committee of the legislature.
  • A minister stays in office only as long as the legislature supports the cabinet.
  • If the legislature passes a no-confidence motion, the cabinet must resign.

After a no-confidence motion is passed

  1. Cabinet resigns It has lost the legislature's support
  2. Another leader invited The head of state asks another party's leader to prove a majority
  3. New cabinet or new election If no leader can prove a majority, fresh elections are held

The Prime Minister presides over cabinet meetings and, as leader of the ruling party, has great control over it. The textbook notes that sometimes a parliamentary government seems to be run by one person - the Prime Minister.

Worked example 1: which system?

Question: In Country R, ministers sit in the legislature and resign when the legislature votes against them, while a President signs laws but follows the ministers' advice. Which system is this? Reasoning: Ministers from the legislature, removable by it, and a head of state who acts on advice are the marks of a parliamentary system. Answer: Parliamentary.

Worked example 2: counting a majority

Question: A legislature has 120 members. What is the smallest number a party needs for a clear majority? Working: Half of 120 = 60. A majority must be more than half, so 61 members.

Key takeaways: Government has three organs: legislature, executive and judiciary. In a parliamentary system (England, India) the cabinet is the real executive, drawn from and answerable to the legislature, which can remove it by a no-confidence motion; the head of state is nominal. In a presidential system (USA) the legislature cannot remove the executive in this way.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. On what basis are democratic governments divided into parliamentary and presidential?

    1. The number of political parties
    2. The relation between the legislature and the executive
    3. The size of the country
    4. The age of the voters
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook divides democratic governments into parliamentary and presidential on the basis of the relation between the legislature and the executive.

  2. 2. Who is the real executive in a parliamentary system?

    1. The head of state
    2. The judiciary
    3. The cabinet
    4. The army
    Show answer

    Answer: C. In a parliamentary system the cabinet, headed by the Prime Minister, is the real executive; the head of state is the nominal executive.

  3. 3. What must a cabinet do if the legislature passes a no-confidence motion against it?

    1. Resign
    2. Dissolve the judiciary
    3. Ignore it
    4. Appoint new judges
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A minister stays in office only while the legislature supports the cabinet. If a no-confidence motion is passed, the cabinet has to resign.

  4. 4. The presidential form of government developed in which country?

    1. England
    2. India
    3. Canada
    4. United States of America
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The parliamentary system is traditionally associated with England and the presidential system with the United States of America.

  5. 5. In Garner's definition, the head of state in cabinet government is:

    1. the real executive responsible to voters
    2. the nominal executive who is not held responsible
    3. the leader of the opposition
    4. a member of the judiciary
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Garner says the cabinet is the real executive responsible to the legislature and voters, while the titular or nominal executive, the head of state, occupies a position of irresponsibility.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Features of the parliamentary system

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery