- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Errors of principle, compensating errors and their effect on the trial balance
Recognise errors of principle and compensating errors, and sort errors into those the trial balance discloses and those it does not, using the idea of one-sided and two-sided errors.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain and give examples of errors of principle.
- Explain compensating (offsetting) errors.
- Say whether a given error will make the trial balance disagree.
- Distinguish one-sided errors from two-sided errors.
A trial balance that agrees gives comfort, but not proof. Some errors leave the debit and credit totals equal. Knowing which errors the trial balance can catch tells you where to look when it does not agree, and warns you that agreement alone does not mean the books are right.
Errors of principle
An error of principle is a mistake in applying a basic accounting principle, most often confusing capital items (assets) with revenue items (goods and expenses). The textbook lists four typical cases:
- Purchase of an asset entered in the purchases book (an asset treated as goods).
- Sale of an asset entered in the sales book.
- Capital expenditure treated as revenue expenditure, for example building a new room debited to repairs.
- Revenue expenditure treated as capital expenditure, for example repairs to a machine debited to machinery account.
An error of principle puts the right amount on the right side, but in an account of the wrong class. The trial balance still agrees, yet profit and the balance sheet are both wrong.
Compensating errors
Compensating errors (also called offsetting errors) are two or more errors that cancel each other's effect. An excess debit in one account is matched by an excess credit, or a short debit, of the same amount somewhere else. The accounts involved may be related or unrelated. Example: the purchases book and the sales book are both overcast by the same amount.
Which errors does the trial balance disclose?
The rule of thumb: one-sided errors (affecting only one account, or both sides unequally) make the trial balance disagree. Two-sided errors (affecting two accounts equally on opposite sides) leave it in agreement.
Errors and the trial balance
-
Disclosed (trial balance disagrees)
- Posting only one side of an entry
- Posting to the wrong side of an account
- Posting twice in an account
- Over-casting or under-casting a subsidiary book
- Posting a wrong amount to an account
- Wrong carry-forward of a page total
- Wrong balancing of an account
- Not posting an entry from a subsidiary book
-
Not disclosed (trial balance agrees)
- Complete omission of a transaction
- Errors of principle
- Compensating errors
- Entry in the wrong subsidiary book
- Entry twice in a subsidiary book or journal
- Wrong amount in the journal or subsidiary book
- Correct amount posted to a wrong account on the correct side
Note the last item on the right. Posting a correct amount to the wrong person's account but on the correct side is an error of commission, yet it does not upset the trial balance, because a debit is still a debit of the same amount. So not every error of commission is disclosed.
One-sided error: trial balance disagrees. Two-sided error: trial balance still agrees, so its agreement is not proof of accuracy.
Worked example 1: classify and test
All names and amounts in the worked examples are made up for practice. (a) Wages of ₹4,000 paid for installing a new machine were debited to wages account. (b) Sales book overcast by ₹700 and purchases book overcast by ₹700. (c) Furniture bought on credit from Pugazh Traders for ₹9,000 was entered in the purchases book.
Working: (a) Installation wages are part of the cost of the machine (capital), but were treated as revenue: error of principle. Wages has ₹4,000 too much debit and machinery ₹4,000 too little, so the debit total is unchanged and the trial balance agrees. (b) Sales has ₹700 excess credit and purchases has ₹700 excess debit; the two cancel: compensating error, trial balance agrees. (c) An asset was treated as goods: error of principle; purchases is debited instead of furniture with the same amount, so the trial balance agrees.
Worked example 2: will the trial balance agree?
All names and amounts in the worked examples are made up for practice. (a) The total of the sales returns book, ₹1,250, was not posted. (b) A cheque for ₹3,000 received from Sivaranjani was posted to the credit of Sivaraman's account. (c) A credit purchase of ₹580 from Vetri was posted to his account as ₹850.
Working: (a) Sales returns account is short of a ₹1,250 debit while the customers' accounts are credited: one-sided, the debit column is short by ₹1,250. (b) Wrong account, correct side, correct amount: two-sided in effect, the trial balance agrees. (c) Vetri's account has ₹270 excess credit while purchases has the right debit: the credit column is ₹270 too high, so it disagrees.
Key takeaways: errors of principle confuse capital and revenue items; compensating errors cancel each other. One-sided errors (partial omission and most errors of commission) are disclosed by the trial balance. Complete omission, errors of principle, compensating errors, wrong entries in the books of original entry, and correct-side postings to a wrong account are not.
Check your understanding
-
1. Repairs of ₹2,500 to a machine were debited to machinery account. This is an error of:
- principle
- partial omission
- compensating nature
- complete omission
Show answer
Answer: A. Repairs are revenue expenditure. Debiting them to an asset account treats revenue expenditure as capital: an error of principle.
-
2. Which of these errors will make the trial balance disagree?
- Purchase of a computer entered in the purchases book
- A transaction omitted completely
- Sales book under-cast by ₹300
- Purchases and sales books each overcast by ₹500
Show answer
Answer: C. Under-casting the sales book gives sales account a short credit of ₹300 while customers are correctly debited: a one-sided error, so the trial balance disagrees. The other three leave it in agreement.
-
3. Purchases book and sales book are both overcast by ₹1,200. The effect on the trial balance is:
- debit side higher by ₹1,200
- credit side higher by ₹1,200
- debit side higher by ₹2,400
- no difference
Show answer
Answer: D. Purchases gets ₹1,200 excess debit and sales gets ₹1,200 excess credit. Both columns rise equally, so the errors compensate and the trial balance still agrees.
-
4. A trial balance that agrees proves that:
- there are no errors in the books
- the books are free of one-sided errors of the kinds that upset the totals, but other errors may remain
- all transactions have been recorded
- capital and revenue items are correctly classified
Show answer
Answer: B. Agreement only shows debits equal credits. Complete omissions, errors of principle and compensating errors can still be present.
-
5. A correct amount posted to the wrong customer's account, on the correct side, is:
- an error of commission not disclosed by the trial balance
- an error of principle disclosed by the trial balance
- an error of partial omission
- an error of commission disclosed by the trial balance
Show answer
Answer: A. Posting to a wrong account is commission. The debit is still a debit of the right amount, so the totals agree; the trial balance does not reveal it.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.