- Practice
- About 20 min
- 5 practice questions
Rectifying two-sided errors with journal entries
Use the three-step method (wrong entry, correct entry, rectifying entry) to pass rectifying journal entries for two-sided errors, including wrongly passed journal entries.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Apply the three-step method to any two-sided error.
- Pass rectifying entries for omissions, wrong accounts, wrong books and errors of principle.
- Correct a wrongly passed journal entry from its narration.
A two-sided error affects two accounts equally, so the trial balance does not reveal it and a note in one account cannot fix it. It needs a rectifying journal entry in the journal proper. The same entry is used whether the error is found before, while or after preparing the trial balance, because suspense account plays no part in a two-sided error.
The three-step method
Deriving a rectifying entry
- Step 1: Wrong entry Write the entry that was actually made (what was done wrongly)
- Step 2: Correct entry Write the entry that should have been made
- Step 3: Rectifying entry Reverse the wrong account and put the right account in its place
Accounts that are the same in both the wrong and correct entries (for example, cash) are left alone. Only the accounts that differ appear in the rectifying entry.
Rectifying entry = cancel what was wrongly debited or credited + record what should have been debited or credited.
Worked example 1: deriving entries
All names and amounts in the worked examples are made up for practice. Errors found before the trial balance: (a) Goods bought on credit from Selvi for ₹3,200 were not recorded. (b) ₹1,800 spent on repairs to the building was debited to building account. (c) Cash ₹900 received from Malar was credited to Malathi's account. (d) A credit sale of ₹1,400 to Kavin was entered in the purchases book.
| Error | Wrong entry (done) | Correct entry (should be) | Rectifying entry |
|---|---|---|---|
| (a) | Nil (complete omission) | Purchases Dr 3,200; To Selvi 3,200 | Purchases Dr 3,200; To Selvi 3,200 |
| (b) | Building Dr 1,800; To Cash 1,800 | Repairs Dr 1,800; To Cash 1,800 | Repairs Dr 1,800; To Building 1,800 |
| (c) | Cash Dr 900; To Malathi 900 | Cash Dr 900; To Malar 900 | Malathi Dr 900; To Malar 900 |
| (d) | Purchases Dr 1,400; To Kavin 1,400 | Kavin Dr 1,400; To Sales 1,400 | Kavin Dr 2,800; To Purchases 1,400; To Sales 1,400 |
Look at (d) closely. Wrongly, Kavin was credited ₹1,400; he should have been debited ₹1,400. To move from a credit of 1,400 to a debit of 1,400, debit him 1,400 + 1,400 = ₹2,800. Purchases was wrongly debited 1,400, so credit it 1,400; sales was not credited at all, so credit it 1,400. Check: debits 2,800 = credits 1,400 + 1,400 = 2,800.
| No. | Particulars | L.F. | Dr. (₹) | Cr. (₹) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| (a) | Purchases A/c Dr. | 3,200 | ||
| To Selvi A/c | 3,200 | |||
| (Credit purchase from Selvi omitted, now recorded) | ||||
| (b) | Repairs A/c Dr. | 1,800 | ||
| To Building A/c | 1,800 | |||
| (Repairs wrongly debited to building account, now rectified) | ||||
| (c) | Malathi A/c Dr. | 900 | ||
| To Malar A/c | 900 | |||
| (Cash received from Malar wrongly credited to Malathi, now rectified) | ||||
| (d) | Kavin A/c Dr. | 2,800 | ||
| To Purchases A/c | 1,400 | |||
| To Sales A/c | 1,400 | |||
| (Credit sale to Kavin wrongly entered in purchases book, now rectified) |
Worked example 2: errors of principle and wrong amounts
All names and amounts in the worked examples are made up for practice. (a) Wages ₹2,500 paid for erecting new machinery were debited to wages account. (b) Old furniture sold for cash ₹1,600 was credited to sales account. (c) A credit sale of ₹570 to Iniyan was entered in the sales book as ₹750. (d) ₹1,200 withdrawn by the proprietor for personal use was debited to office expenses account.
Working: (a) Wrong: Wages Dr / To Cash. Correct: Machinery Dr / To Cash. Rectify: Machinery Dr, To Wages ₹2,500. (b) Wrong: Cash Dr / To Sales. Correct: Cash Dr / To Furniture. Rectify: Sales Dr, To Furniture ₹1,600. (c) Wrong: Iniyan Dr 750 / To Sales 750. Correct: Iniyan Dr 570 / To Sales 570. Both accounts are 750 − 570 = ₹180 too high, so Sales Dr, To Iniyan ₹180. (d) Rectify: Drawings Dr, To Office expenses ₹1,200.
| No. | Particulars | L.F. | Dr. (₹) | Cr. (₹) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| (a) | Machinery A/c Dr. | 2,500 | ||
| To Wages A/c | 2,500 | |||
| (Wages for erection of machinery wrongly debited to wages, now rectified) | ||||
| (b) | Sales A/c Dr. | 1,600 | ||
| To Furniture A/c | 1,600 | |||
| (Sale of old furniture wrongly credited to sales, now rectified) | ||||
| (c) | Sales A/c Dr. | 180 | ||
| To Iniyan A/c | 180 | |||
| (Sale to Iniyan of ₹570 entered as ₹750, now rectified) | ||||
| (d) | Drawings A/c Dr. | 1,200 | ||
| To Office expenses A/c | 1,200 | |||
| (Proprietor's personal withdrawal wrongly debited to office expenses, now rectified) |
Correcting wrongly passed journal entries
Sometimes you are given the wrong journal entry itself, with a narration that states what really happened. Read the narration, write the correct entry, and compare. Example (made up): the entry 'Purchases A/c Dr ₹12,000, To Cash A/c ₹12,000 (computer bought for office use)' is wrong because a computer is an asset. Rectify: Computer A/c Dr ₹12,000, To Purchases A/c ₹12,000. Another: 'Elango A/c Dr ₹3,000, To Cash A/c ₹3,000 (salary paid to Elango)'. Salary is an expense, not a debt of Elango's: Salaries A/c Dr ₹3,000, To Elango A/c ₹3,000. And 'Cash A/c Dr ₹2,500, To Sudha A/c ₹2,500 (goods sold to Sudha for cash)': a cash sale is income, so Sudha A/c Dr ₹2,500, To Sales A/c ₹2,500.
Key takeaways: a two-sided error is corrected by a journal entry in the journal proper, never through suspense account. Write the wrong entry, write the correct entry, then reverse what is wrong and record what is missing. When a personal account was credited instead of debited (or the reverse), the correction is double the amount.
Check your understanding
-
1. Salary ₹6,000 paid to Kayal was debited to her personal account. The rectifying entry is:
- Kayal A/c Dr, To Salaries A/c ₹6,000
- Salaries A/c Dr, To Cash A/c ₹6,000
- Salaries A/c Dr, To Kayal A/c ₹6,000
- Suspense A/c Dr, To Kayal A/c ₹6,000
Show answer
Answer: C. Wrong: Kayal Dr / To Cash. Correct: Salaries Dr / To Cash. Cash is right in both, so debit salaries and credit Kayal to cancel the wrong debit.
-
2. A credit purchase of goods from Mugil for ₹2,000 was passed through the sales book. Which rectifying entry is correct?
- Purchases A/c Dr ₹2,000, Sales A/c Dr ₹2,000, To Mugil A/c ₹4,000
- Purchases A/c Dr ₹2,000, To Mugil A/c ₹2,000
- Mugil A/c Dr ₹4,000, To Sales A/c ₹2,000, To Purchases A/c ₹2,000
- Sales A/c Dr ₹2,000, To Purchases A/c ₹2,000
Show answer
Answer: A. Wrong: Mugil Dr 2,000 / To Sales 2,000. Correct: Purchases Dr 2,000 / To Mugil 2,000. Mugil must move from a 2,000 debit to a 2,000 credit, so credit him 4,000; cancel the sales credit (Sales Dr 2,000) and record purchases (Purchases Dr 2,000). Debits 4,000 = credits 4,000.
-
3. Why is suspense account not used when rectifying a two-sided error?
- Because suspense account is only opened after the final accounts
- Because two-sided errors are always errors of principle
- Because two-sided errors are corrected by notes
- Because a two-sided error causes no difference in the trial balance, so nothing of it sits in suspense
Show answer
Answer: D. Suspense holds only the difference in the trial balance. A two-sided error does not create any difference, so its correction involves only the two accounts affected.
-
4. A credit sale of ₹384 to Sevvanthi was entered in the sales book as ₹348. The rectifying entry is:
- Sales A/c Dr, To Sevvanthi A/c ₹36
- Sevvanthi A/c Dr, To Sales A/c ₹36
- Sevvanthi A/c Dr, To Sales A/c ₹384
- Sevvanthi A/c Dr, To Suspense A/c ₹36
Show answer
Answer: B. Both Sevvanthi and sales were recorded at 348 instead of 384, short by 384 − 348 = ₹36. Debit Sevvanthi and credit sales with ₹36 to make both right.
-
5. The entry 'Cash A/c Dr, To Sales A/c ₹8,000 (old machinery sold for cash)' was passed. The rectifying entry is:
- Machinery A/c Dr, To Sales A/c ₹8,000
- Cash A/c Dr, To Machinery A/c ₹8,000
- Sales A/c Dr, To Machinery A/c ₹8,000
- Sales A/c Dr, To Cash A/c ₹8,000
Show answer
Answer: C. Correct entry: Cash Dr / To Machinery. Cash is right; sales was wrongly credited, so debit sales and credit machinery.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.