- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Locating errors, suspense account and rectifying one-sided errors
Follow the textbook's steps to locate errors before and after the trial balance, open a suspense account for a difference, and correct one-sided errors found before or while preparing the trial balance.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- List the steps for locating errors before and after the trial balance.
- Use the halving and divisible-by-9 checks.
- Decide which side of the suspense account receives the difference.
- Rectify one-sided errors before the trial balance by an explanatory note.
Finding an error is often harder than correcting it. Accountants follow a fixed order of checks so that they do not miss anything, and they use a temporary account so that work on the final accounts can continue while the search goes on.
Locating errors before the trial balance
- Scrutinise entries in the journal proper.
- Scrutinise entries in the subsidiary books.
- Check the totals of the subsidiary books.
- Scrutinise postings to the ledger accounts.
- Scrutinise the balancing of ledger accounts.
Locating errors after the trial balance
If the trial balance does not tally, errors exist. The textbook's checks, in order, are: check the two column totals; check that each balance is in its proper column; halve the difference and look for a ledger balance of that amount placed in the wrong column; check subsidiary book totals (especially for differences like ₹1 or ₹100); if the difference is divisible by 9, look for transposed figures; verify debtors' and creditors' accounts; check postings from subsidiary books; check ledger balances; verify amounts carried forward; and finally verify every journal entry.
Worked example 1: the halving and nine checks
All names and amounts in the worked examples are made up for practice. (a) A trial balance shows debits ₹3,46,800 and credits ₹3,51,400. (b) Another shows a difference of ₹540.
Working (a): difference = 3,51,400 − 3,46,800 = ₹4,600. Half = ₹2,300. If a debit balance of ₹2,300 (say, carriage inwards) was put in the credit column, the debit total loses 2,300 and the credit total gains 2,300, a gap of 2 × 2,300 = ₹4,600. So look for a ₹2,300 balance on the wrong side.
Working (b): 540 ÷ 9 = 60 exactly, so a transposition is possible. For instance, ₹6,170 written as ₹6,710 gives 6,710 − 6,170 = ₹540. Swapping two digits always gives a difference divisible by 9.
Suspense account
When the trial balance does not tally and the error cannot be found at once, the difference is put in a temporary account called the suspense account. If the credit column is bigger, the difference goes on the debit side of suspense; if the debit column is bigger, it goes on the credit side. Either way the trial balance then agrees. The suspense account stays in the books until the errors are found; as each one-sided error is rectified through it, its balance shrinks, and when all are rectified it closes.
Life of a suspense account
- Trial balance disagrees Difference found
- Difference placed in suspense Debit side if credits are higher; credit side if debits are higher
- Errors located One-sided errors identified
- Rectifying entries through suspense Each one-sided error corrected against suspense
- Suspense account closes Nil balance once every one-sided error is rectified
Stages of rectification
Errors are corrected at the stage at which they are found: (1) before preparing the trial balance, (2) while preparing it, (3) after preparing it but before the final accounts, and (4) after the final accounts.
One-sided errors before or while preparing the trial balance
At stages 1 and 2 a one-sided error needs no journal entry. Only one account is wrong, so it is corrected by writing an explanatory note in that account, debiting or crediting it with the amount needed. Ask: which account is wrong, by how much, and on which side? Then put in the missing debit or credit, or reverse the excess.
Short debit: debit it. Excess debit: credit it. Short credit: credit it. Excess credit: debit it.
Worked example 2: explanatory notes
All names and amounts in the worked examples are made up for practice. Found before the trial balance was prepared:
| Error | Effect | Rectification (explanatory note) |
|---|---|---|
| (a) Sales book overcast by ₹350 | Sales account has ₹350 excess credit | Debit sales account with ₹350 |
| (b) Purchases returns book undercast by ₹120 | Purchases returns account has ₹120 short credit | Credit purchases returns account with ₹120 |
| (c) Credit sale of ₹680 to Revathi posted to her account as ₹860 | Revathi's account has 860 − 680 = ₹180 excess debit | Credit Revathi's account with ₹180 |
| (d) Total of wages account carried forward ₹1,500 short | Wages account has ₹1,500 short debit | Debit wages account with ₹1,500 |
| (e) Discount column total ₹240 on the debit side of the cash book not posted | Discount allowed account short of a ₹240 debit | Debit discount allowed account with ₹240 |
Check (c) twice: correct debit 680, actual debit 860, excess 860 − 680 = 180; to remove an excess debit, credit 180. Check (e): the discount column on the debit (receipts) side of the cash book is discount allowed, an expense, which is posted to the debit of discount allowed account.
Key takeaways: follow the fixed order of checks; halve the difference to look for a balance in the wrong column; a difference divisible by 9 suggests transposed figures. A difference that cannot be traced is placed in a suspense account, on the debit side when credits are higher. One-sided errors found before or while preparing the trial balance are corrected by an explanatory note, not a journal entry.
Check your understanding
-
1. A trial balance shows debit total ₹82,450 and credit total ₹81,950. The difference is put in suspense account on:
- the debit side, ₹500
- the credit side, ₹500
- the credit side, ₹1,000
- the debit side, ₹250
Show answer
Answer: B. Debits exceed credits by 82,450 − 81,950 = ₹500. To make the trial balance agree, ₹500 is placed on the credit side of suspense account.
-
2. A trial balance is out by ₹1,800. Applying the halving check, you should look for:
- a ledger balance of ₹900 shown in the wrong column
- a ledger balance of ₹3,600 shown in the wrong column
- an omitted balance of ₹900
- a transposition of ₹1,800
Show answer
Answer: A. A balance in the wrong column shifts the totals apart by twice its amount, so look for 1,800 ÷ 2 = ₹900 on the wrong side.
-
3. The difference in a trial balance is ₹450. Which figure pair could explain it as a transposition?
- ₹3,280 written as ₹3,820
- ₹4,100 written as ₹4,010
- ₹2,500 written as ₹2,050
- ₹7,325 written as ₹7,352
Show answer
Answer: C. 2,500 − 2,050 = ₹450, from swapping the 5 and the 0. The others give 3,820 − 3,280 = 540, 4,100 − 4,010 = 90 and 7,352 − 7,325 = 27. Each is a multiple of 9, as every transposition is, but only one equals ₹450.
-
4. Before the trial balance is prepared, it is found that a credit purchase of ₹1,450 from Mani was credited to his account as ₹1,540. The rectification is:
- credit Mani's account with ₹90
- debit purchases account with ₹90
- pass a journal entry through suspense account
- debit Mani's account with ₹90
Show answer
Answer: D. Mani's account has an excess credit of 1,540 − 1,450 = ₹90. Before the trial balance, a one-sided error is corrected by a note: debit Mani's account with ₹90.
-
5. Why is no journal entry passed for a one-sided error found before the trial balance is prepared?
- Because one-sided errors never affect profit
- Because only one account is wrong, and a journal entry needs two accounts; a note in that account is enough
- Because the suspense account is already closed
- Because the auditor corrects it
Show answer
Answer: B. A journal entry always has a debit and a credit. When only one account is wrong and no suspense account exists yet, the textbook corrects it with an explanatory note in that account.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.