- Practice
- About 22 min
- 5 practice questions
Carbocations, carbanions, free radicals, nucleophiles and electrophiles
Give the hybridisation, shape and stability order of carbocations, carbanions and alkyl free radicals, and classify reagents as nucleophiles or electrophiles with their electron-rich or electron-poor site.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State the hybridisation and shape of a carbocation, a carbanion and an alkyl free radical.
- Arrange alkyl carbocations, carbanions and radicals in order of stability.
- Define nucleophiles and electrophiles and relate them to Lewis bases and Lewis acids.
- Pick out the electron-rich or electron-poor atom in a given reagent.
Bond fission produces three kinds of carbon intermediates. How each is shaped and how stable it is explains the products of many reactions you will meet in the next two units. The reagents that attack them fall into two families: those that bring electrons and those that seek electrons.
Shapes of the three carbon intermediates
| Intermediate | Electrons on the central carbon | Hybridisation | Shape |
|---|---|---|---|
| Carbocation, e.g. CH₃CH₂⁺ | 6 valence electrons (three bonds), positive charge | sp²; an empty p orbital is left | Planar (trigonal) |
| Carbanion, e.g. CH₃CH₂⁻ | 8 valence electrons (three bonds and a lone pair), negative charge | sp³; the lone pair is in one sp³ orbital | Pyramidal |
| Alkyl free radical, e.g. CH₃CH₂• | 7 valence electrons, neutral | sp² (unpaired electron in p) or sp³ | Planar or pyramidal |
Because a carbocation is flat, with the empty p orbital above and below the plane, a nucleophile can attack it from either face. This fact will matter when you study the SN1 reaction in Unit 14.
Stability orders
Alkyl groups push electron density towards the carbon they are attached to (you will meet this as the +I effect and hyperconjugation in lessons 3 and 4). Extra electron density helps a positively charged or electron-poor carbon, but hurts a negatively charged carbon that already has too much. That single idea gives all three orders.
- Carbocations: ⁺C(CH₃)₃ > ⁺CH(CH₃)₂ > ⁺CH₂CH₃ > ⁺CH₃ (tertiary most stable).
- Free radicals: •C(CH₃)₃ > •CH(CH₃)₂ > •CH₂CH₃ > •CH₃ (same order as carbocations).
- Carbanions: ⁻C(CH₃)₃ < ⁻CH(CH₃)₂ < ⁻CH₂CH₃ < ⁻CH₃ (the reverse: methyl most stable).
Carbocations and radicals: 3° > 2° > 1° > methyl. Carbanions: methyl > 1° > 2° > 3°.
Worked example 1: which carbocation forms more easily?
Compare the cations from 2-bromopropane and 1-bromopropane. Step 1: 2-bromopropane loses Br⁻ to give (CH₃)₂CH⁺; the charged carbon carries two methyl groups, so it is secondary. Step 2: 1-bromopropane would give CH₃CH₂CH₂⁺; the charged carbon has one alkyl group, so it is primary. Step 3: more alkyl groups mean more electron release to the positive carbon. Answer: (CH₃)₂CH⁺ is more stable and forms more easily.
Nucleophiles: nucleus-loving reagents
A nucleophile has a high affinity for an electron-poor (positive) centre. It owns an atom with an unshared electron pair and uses that pair to form a new covalent bond. Nucleophiles are negative ions or electron-rich neutral molecules with lone pairs. All Lewis bases act as nucleophiles.
| Type | Examples | Electron-rich atom |
|---|---|---|
| Neutral, with a lone pair | NH₃, amines RNH₂ | N |
| Neutral, with a lone pair | H₂O, alcohols ROH, ethers ROR | O |
| Neutral, with a lone pair | H₂S, thiols RSH | S |
| Negative ions | Cl⁻, Br⁻, I⁻ | Halide ion |
| Negative ions | HO⁻, RO⁻ (alkoxide), RCOO⁻ (carboxylate) | O⁻ |
| Negative ion | CN⁻ | The atom with the negative charge and lone pair |
Electrophiles: electron-loving reagents
An electrophile is attracted to a negative or electron-rich centre. Electrophiles are positive ions or electron-deficient neutral molecules. All Lewis acids act as electrophiles. A molecule such as SnCl₄ can also behave as an electrophile because tin has vacant d orbitals that can accept electron pairs.
| Type | Examples | Electron-poor atom |
|---|---|---|
| Neutral | CO₂, dichlorocarbene :CCl₂ | C |
| Neutral | AlCl₃, BF₃, FeCl₃ | The metal or boron (incomplete octet) |
| Positive ions | Carbocations R⁺ | C⁺ |
| Positive ions | Proton H⁺, nitronium ion NO₂⁺, nitrosonium ion NO⁺ | H⁺, N |
Nucleophile or electrophile?
-
Nucleophile
- Electron-pair donor (Lewis base)
- Negative ion or lone-pair molecule
- Seeks a positive centre
- Examples: OH⁻, CN⁻, NH₃, H₂O
-
Electrophile
- Electron-pair acceptor (Lewis acid)
- Positive ion or electron-deficient molecule
- Seeks an electron-rich centre
- Examples: H⁺, NO₂⁺, BF₃, AlCl₃
Worked example 2: sorting a list of reagents
Sort BF₃, CH₃OH, NO₂⁺ and CN⁻. Step 1, BF₃: boron has only six valence electrons (three B–F bonds), so it accepts a pair: electrophile. Step 2, CH₃OH: oxygen carries two lone pairs: nucleophile. Step 3, NO₂⁺: positively charged and electron-seeking: electrophile. Step 4, CN⁻: negative ion with a lone pair: nucleophile. Answer: nucleophiles CH₃OH and CN⁻; electrophiles BF₃ and NO₂⁺.
Key takeaways: carbocations are sp² and planar, carbanions sp³ and pyramidal; alkyl groups stabilise carbocations and radicals but destabilise carbanions. Nucleophiles are Lewis bases that give electron pairs; electrophiles are Lewis acids that accept them.
Check your understanding
-
1. What is the approximate bond angle around the positively charged carbon in the tert-butyl carbocation, (CH₃)₃C⁺?
- 90°
- 109.5°
- 120°
- 180°
Show answer
Answer: C. The positive carbon uses three sp² orbitals for its three C–C bonds and keeps an empty p orbital. Three sp² orbitals point to the corners of a flat triangle, 120° apart, so the cation is planar.
-
2. Which carbanion is the most stable?
- ⁻CH₃
- ⁻CH₂CH₃
- ⁻CH(CH₃)₂
- ⁻C(CH₃)₃
Show answer
Answer: A. Alkyl groups release electrons. A carbanion already has an extra electron pair, so every alkyl group makes it less stable. The methyl carbanion has no alkyl groups and is the most stable of the four.
-
3. Which list contains only electrophiles?
- H⁺, NO₂⁺, AlCl₃
- NH₃, H₂O, Cl⁻
- CN⁻, OH⁻, BF₃
- CH₃OH, H⁺, NH₃
Show answer
Answer: A. H⁺ and NO₂⁺ are positive and seek electrons, and aluminium in AlCl₃ has only six valence electrons, so all three accept electron pairs. Every other list includes a lone-pair donor such as NH₃, H₂O, CN⁻, OH⁻ or CH₃OH.
-
4. Which of these is a NEUTRAL electrophile?
- NH₃
- H₂O
- FeCl₃
- CH₃OH
Show answer
Answer: C. Iron in FeCl₃ can accept an electron pair (it is a Lewis acid), so it is an electrophile even without a charge. NH₃, H₂O and CH₃OH each have lone pairs to donate and are nucleophiles.
-
5. What is the hybridisation of the positively charged carbon in the allyl carbocation, CH₂=CH–CH₂⁺?
- sp
- sp³
- sp³d
- sp²
Show answer
Answer: D. Like every carbocation, the CH₂⁺ carbon forms three σ bonds and keeps an empty p orbital, so it is sp² hybridised. That empty p orbital lines up with the neighbouring π bond, which is why the allyl cation is extra stable.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.