• Practice
  • About 24 min
  • 5 practice questions

Electron movement, inductive effect and electromeric effect

Draw the three kinds of electron movement, explain the permanent inductive effect with +I and −I groups and its effect on reactivity and acid strength, and explain the temporary +E and −E electromeric effect.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Recognise the three types of electron movement shown by curved arrows.
  • Explain the inductive effect and classify groups as +I or −I.
  • Use the inductive effect to rank the strength of carboxylic acids.
  • Explain the electromeric effect and tell +E from −E.

Stability, reactivity, acidity and basicity of organic molecules depend on how electrons are displaced inside their covalent bonds. Some displacements are permanent (present in the molecule all the time) and some are temporary (appear only when a reagent comes close). The Tamil Nadu textbook groups them as the inductive effect (I), the electromeric effect (E), the resonance effect (R) and hyperconjugation.

Three kinds of electron movement

  1. A lone pair becomes a bonding pair. Example: a lone pair on the oxygen of OH⁻ forms a new bond to H⁺, giving H₂O.
  2. A bonding pair becomes a lone pair. Example: when H₂O loses H⁺, the O–H bond pair stays on oxygen as a lone pair of OH⁻.
  3. A bonding pair becomes another bonding pair. Example: the π pair of H₂C=CH₂ moves to form a new C–H bond with H⁺, leaving H₃C–CH₂⁺.

Every curved arrow in a mechanism is one of these three moves, and each one makes or breaks a σ or π bond.

The inductive effect (I)

The inductive effect is the change in polarisation of a covalent bond caused by neighbouring bonds, atoms or groups. It is a permanent effect transmitted through σ bonds. Compare ethane and ethyl chloride. In ethane the C–C bond is non-polar. In CH₃–CH₂–Cl, chlorine pulls the C–Cl bond pair towards itself, so Cl gets δ− and C1 gets δ+. To make up for this, C1 pulls the C1–C2 bond pair slightly, so C2 becomes slightly positive (δδ+). The effect fades quickly with distance: it is strongest on the next bond and almost negligible beyond about four bonds.

Electrons are not transferred from atom to atom; the bond pairs are only shifted, but the shift is permanent. Groups that withdraw electron density through σ bonds show the −I effect; groups that release it show the +I effect (hydrogen is the reference).

Inductive effect of common groups
EffectWhich groupsExamples (strongest first)
−I (electron-withdrawing)Highly electronegative atoms; groups with a positively charged atom−NH₃⁺ > −NO₂ > −CN > −SO₃H > −CHO > −COOH > −F > −Cl > −Br > −I > −OH > −OR > −NH₂ > −C₆H₅
+I (electron-releasing)Electropositive atoms; alkyl groups; negatively charged groups−C(CH₃)₃ > −CH(CH₃)₂ > −CH₂CH₃ > −CH₃; also −O⁻, −COO⁻, CH₃O⁻

The more electronegative the substituent, the stronger its −I effect; the less electronegative (more alkyl branching), the stronger its +I effect.

— Inductive effect

What the inductive effect does

Reactivity. A halogen on carbon makes the C–X bond polar (Cδ+–Xδ−); the −I effect helps a nucleophile attack the δ+ carbon. A −I group near a carbonyl carbon lowers its electron density and speeds up nucleophilic addition.

Acid strength. A carboxylic acid ionises to RCOO⁻ + H⁺. A −I group near the carboxyl pulls electron density away, spreads out the negative charge of the anion and makes loss of H⁺ easier, so the acid is stronger. A +I group does the opposite.

Worked example 1: the chloroacetic acids

Rank CH₃COOH, ClCH₂COOH, Cl₂CHCOOH and Cl₃CCOOH. Step 1: each Cl on the α-carbon adds a −I pull. Step 2: count chlorines: 0, 1, 2, 3. Step 3: more −I means a more stable anion and a stronger acid. Order: Cl₃CCOOH > Cl₂CHCOOH > ClCH₂COOH > CH₃COOH. Check with accepted approximate pKa values (lower pKa = stronger acid): about 0.7, 1.3, 2.9 and 4.8 respectively, which agrees.

Worked example 2: alkyl groups weaken an acid

Rank HCOOH, CH₃COOH, (CH₃)₂CHCOOH and (CH₃)₃CCOOH. Step 1: H in formic acid releases no electrons. Step 2: the +I effect grows as methyl, isopropyl, tert-butyl. Step 3: more electron release makes the anion less stable and the acid weaker. Order of acid strength: HCOOH > CH₃COOH > (CH₃)₂CHCOOH > (CH₃)₃CCOOH.

The electromeric effect (E)

The electromeric effect is a temporary effect seen in compounds with multiple bonds (C=C, C=O and so on) only when an attacking reagent is present. At the reagent's approach the π electron pair shifts completely to one atom; when the reagent is removed, the effect disappears.

  • +E effect: the π pair moves towards the attacking reagent. Example: H⁺ approaching ethene; the π pair forms a C–H bond and the other carbon becomes a carbocation, CH₃–CH₂⁺.
  • −E effect: the π pair moves away from the attacking reagent. Example: CN⁻ approaching the C=O of a carbonyl compound; the π pair moves onto the more electronegative oxygen, the carbon becomes electron-deficient and CN⁻ bonds to it.

Inductive effect versus electromeric effect

  • Inductive (I)
    • Permanent
    • Acts through σ bonds
    • Partial shift (δ+ and δ−)
    • Dies away after a few bonds
  • Electromeric (E)
    • Temporary; needs a reagent
    • Acts on π electrons of a multiple bond
    • Complete shift of the π pair
    • Vanishes when the reagent leaves

Worked example 3: naming the electromeric effect

In the addition of HBr to ethene, the first attacker is H⁺. Step 1: the π pair of C=C moves to form the new C–H bond. Step 2: the electrons have moved towards the attacking reagent (H⁺). Answer: +E effect. In the addition of HCN to acetaldehyde, the attacker is CN⁻ and the π pair moves to oxygen, away from CN⁻. Answer: −E effect.

Key takeaways: curved arrows show lone pair → bond, bond → lone pair or bond → bond. The inductive effect is permanent, through σ bonds, and decides acid strength (−I strengthens, +I weakens). The electromeric effect is temporary, through π bonds, and is +E towards the reagent, −E away from it.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which carboxylic acid is the WEAKEST?

    1. HCOOH
    2. CH₃COOH
    3. (CH₃)₂CHCOOH
    4. (CH₃)₃CCOOH
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Alkyl groups release electrons (+I), which destabilises the carboxylate ion and makes loss of H⁺ harder. The tert-butyl group has the strongest +I effect, so (CH₃)₃CCOOH is the weakest; formic acid, with no alkyl group, is the strongest.

  2. 2. Which acid is the strongest?

    1. Cl₃CCOOH
    2. Cl₂CHCOOH
    3. ClCH₂COOH
    4. CH₃COOH
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Each chlorine adds a −I effect that stabilises the carboxylate ion. Trichloroacetic acid has three chlorines, so its anion is the most stable and it ionises most easily.

  3. 3. Which group releases electrons through σ bonds (+I effect)?

    1. –NO₂
    2. –Cl
    3. –C₂H₅
    4. –COOH
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Alkyl groups such as ethyl push electron density towards the carbon they are attached to: +I. Nitro, chloro and carboxyl groups are more electronegative and withdraw electrons: −I.

  4. 4. Which statement about the electromeric effect is correct?

    1. It is a permanent effect acting through σ bonds
    2. It is a temporary effect that needs an attacking reagent and involves π electrons
    3. It is seen only in saturated compounds
    4. It is another name for hyperconjugation
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The electromeric effect operates only while a reagent attacks a multiple bond, and it shifts the π pair completely. Because it disappears when the reagent is removed, it is temporary.

  5. 5. When CN⁻ attacks the carbonyl carbon of acetaldehyde, the π electrons of C=O shift onto oxygen. This is an example of

    1. +I effect
    2. +E effect
    3. −E effect
    4. −I effect
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The π pair moves away from the attacking reagent (CN⁻ attacks carbon, the electrons go to oxygen). Movement away from the attacker is the negative electromeric (−E) effect.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery