• Practice
  • About 24 min
  • 5 practice questions

Resonance (mesomeric effect) and hyperconjugation

Draw resonance structures and the resonance hybrid, classify +M and −M groups, explain the acidity of phenol, and use hyperconjugation (no bond resonance) to explain the stability of carbocations.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain resonance with 1,3-butadiene and benzene, and describe a resonance hybrid.
  • Classify substituents as +M (+R) or −M (−R).
  • Use resonance to explain why phenol is acidic.
  • Explain hyperconjugation and count hyperconjugative structures for carbocations.

Some molecules cannot be described by any single Lewis structure. Resonance and hyperconjugation are the two ideas that explain their extra stability and unusual bond lengths, and they will be used again to explain why groups on benzene direct new groups to certain positions.

Resonance

Resonance is shown by compounds with multiple bonds in suitable positions (conjugated systems). Such a compound can be written as two or more structures that differ only in the positions of π electrons and lone pairs; the atoms do not move. These are resonance (canonical) structures, and the phenomenon is also called mesomerism or the mesomeric effect. The real molecule is a single resonance hybrid that lies between them and is more stable than any one of them.

In 1,3-butadiene, CH₂=CH–CH=CH₂, a simple structure predicts that C1–C2 and C3–C4 should be shorter double bonds and C2–C3 a longer single bond. The Tamil Nadu textbook points out that the bond lengths are found to be more nearly alike than this picture allows, because the π electrons are delocalised over all four carbons. Besides the ordinary structure, two charge-separated forms can be drawn: ⁺CH₂–CH=CH–CH₂⁻ and ⁻CH₂–CH=CH–CH₂⁺. Benzene, with its six equal C–C bonds, is the classic case of a resonance hybrid.

Resonance structures differ only in the placement of electrons, never of atoms. The real molecule is the hybrid, not any one structure.

— Rule for resonance

+M and −M groups

Mesomeric effect of groups attached to a conjugated system
EffectWhat happensExamples
+M (+R)The group releases electrons into the conjugated system (electrons move away from the substituent)–OH, –OR, –SH, –SR, –NH₂, –O⁻, halogens
−M (−R)The group withdraws electrons from the conjugated system (electrons move towards the substituent)–NO₂, >C=O, –CHO, –COOH, –C≡N

A +M group has a lone pair on the atom joined to the π system, which it can share. A −M group has its own π bond to a more electronegative atom, which pulls electrons out. A group with neither, such as –NH₃⁺ in the anilinium ion C₆H₅NH₃⁺, shows no resonance effect: its nitrogen has no lone pair left.

Worked example 1: why phenol is acidic

Phenol ionises: C₆H₅OH ⇌ C₆H₅O⁻ + H⁺. Step 1, phenol: an oxygen lone pair delocalises into the ring, but every such structure puts + on oxygen and − on a ring carbon, a charge separation that costs energy. Step 2, phenoxide ion: the negative charge can spread from oxygen onto the ortho and para carbons without creating any separation of opposite charges. Step 3: resonance therefore stabilises phenoxide more than phenol, which favours ionisation. Conclusion: phenol is acidic (more than alcohols, whose alkoxide ions have no such resonance).

Hyperconjugation

Hyperconjugation is the delocalisation of σ electrons, usually of a C–H bond on the carbon next to (α to) a double bond or a positive carbon. The σ orbital overlaps with the adjacent empty p orbital or π orbital, giving an extended orbital and extra stability. Unlike the electromeric effect, it is permanent.

In propene, CH₃–CH=CH₂, each of the three C–H bonds of the methyl group can feed its σ electrons towards the π bond. Writing this out gives three extra structures of the form H⁺ CH₂=CH–CH₂⁻, in which one hydrogen has no bond to carbon. So propene has 1 ordinary + 3 hyperconjugative structures, and hyperconjugation is also called no bond resonance or the Baker–Nathan effect. These extra structures are polar.

The Tamil Nadu textbook also shows, in the same section, molecules where a lone pair or an electronegative group is conjugated with a π bond: in vinyl chloride, CH₂=CH–Cl, a chlorine lone pair delocalises towards the double bond (CH₂⁻–CH=Cl⁺), and in acrylonitrile, CH₂=CH–C≡N, the cyano group pulls π electrons towards nitrogen (CH₂⁺–CH=C=N⁻). Most chemists classify these two as resonance (+M of Cl, −M of CN) rather than hyperconjugation.

Worked example 2: counting α-hydrogens in carbocations

Each C–H bond on a carbon next to the positive carbon gives one hyperconjugative structure. Step 1, CH₃CH₂⁺ (primary): one CH₃ next to C⁺, so 3 α-H. Step 2, (CH₃)₂CH⁺ (secondary): two CH₃ groups, 2 × 3 = 6 α-H. Step 3, (CH₃)₃C⁺ (tertiary): three CH₃ groups, 3 × 3 = 9 α-H. Step 4: more hyperconjugative structures, more delocalisation of the positive charge. Order of stability: 3° (9) > 2° (6) > 1° (3), the same order as from the +I effect.

Electron displacement effects in covalent bonds

  • Permanent
    • Inductive effect: σ bonds, partial shift
    • Resonance (mesomeric) effect: π and lone pairs, conjugated systems
    • Hyperconjugation: σ C–H electrons with an adjacent p or π orbital
  • Temporary
    • Electromeric effect: complete π shift, only when a reagent attacks

Key takeaways: resonance structures move electrons, never atoms; the hybrid is more stable than each. +M groups give electrons (lone pair next to the π system), −M groups take them (π bond to an electronegative atom). Phenoxide is resonance-stabilised without charge separation, so phenol is acidic. Hyperconjugation (no bond resonance) makes 3° carbocations the most stable.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which statement about hyperconjugation is correct?

    1. It is a permanent effect involving the σ electrons of C–H bonds next to a p or π orbital
    2. It is a temporary effect that appears only when a reagent attacks
    3. It involves only lone pairs on oxygen and nitrogen
    4. It happens only in alkynes
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Hyperconjugation is the delocalisation of σ C–H electrons into an adjacent empty p orbital or π orbital; it is present in the molecule all the time. The temporary effect that needs a reagent is the electromeric effect.

  2. 2. Which group attached to a benzene ring CANNOT take part in resonance with the ring?

    1. –OH
    2. –Cl
    3. –N(CH₃)₃⁺
    4. –NO₂
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The nitrogen of –N(CH₃)₃⁺ uses all its valence electrons in four σ bonds, so it has no lone pair and no π bond to interact with the ring; it acts only by its −I effect. –OH and –Cl donate lone pairs (+M) and –NO₂ withdraws π electrons (−M).

  3. 3. How many hyperconjugative structures (from C–H bonds) can be written for the tert-butyl carbocation, (CH₃)₃C⁺?

    1. 3
    2. 6
    3. 9
    4. 12
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Three methyl groups are attached to the positive carbon and each has three C–H bonds: 3 × 3 = 9 α-hydrogens, so 9 hyperconjugative structures. This large number is one reason it is the most stable alkyl carbocation.

  4. 4. Which group shows a −M (−R) effect when attached to a benzene ring?

    1. –NO₂
    2. –OH
    3. –NH₂
    4. –OCH₃
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The nitro group has an N=O π bond to electronegative oxygen, which draws π electrons out of the ring: −M. –OH, –NH₂ and –OCH₃ have lone pairs on the atom next to the ring and release electrons: +M.

  5. 5. Why is phenol acidic while ethanol is almost neutral?

    1. Phenol has more hydrogen atoms
    2. The phenoxide ion is stabilised by resonance, but the ethoxide ion is not
    3. Ethanol has a stronger −I effect
    4. Phenol has a planar carbocation
    Show answer

    Answer: B. In phenoxide the negative charge spreads over the oxygen and the ortho and para ring carbons, so losing H⁺ is favoured. In ethoxide the charge stays on one oxygen, and the ethyl group's +I effect makes it even less stable, so ethanol hardly ionises.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery