- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Returns to scale, economies and diseconomies of scale
Explain increasing, constant and diminishing returns to scale with calculations, and classify internal and external economies and diseconomies of scale.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State the assumptions and three phases of returns to scale and identify each from figures.
- List the types of internal economies (technical, financial, managerial, labour, marketing, survival) and external economies.
- Explain internal and external diseconomies of scale with examples.
In the long run a firm can change everything: build a bigger factory, buy more machines and hire more people. If it doubles all its inputs, will output exactly double? The laws of returns to scale say it depends, and economies of scale explain why.
Laws of returns to scale
Returns to scale describe how output responds in the long run when all inputs are increased in the same proportion. Assumptions: all factors are variable except organisation; technology is unchanged; there is perfect competition; output is measured in physical units.
| Phase | Inputs increased by | Output increases by |
|---|---|---|
| Increasing returns to scale | 1% | more than 1% |
| Constant returns to scale | 1% | exactly 1% |
| Diminishing (decreasing) returns to scale | 1% | less than 1% |
Worked example 1: a garment firm grows (made-up figures)
| Move | Labour and capital units | Output (shirts) | % change in inputs | % change in output | Returns |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a to b | 1 and 1 to 2 and 2 | 100 to 250 | 100% | (250 − 100) ÷ 100 × 100 = 150% | Increasing |
| b to c | 2 and 2 to 4 and 4 | 250 to 500 | 100% | (500 − 250) ÷ 250 × 100 = 100% | Constant |
| c to d | 4 and 4 to 8 and 8 | 500 to 800 | 100% | (800 − 500) ÷ 500 × 100 = 60% | Diminishing |
Each move doubles every input (a 100% rise). Output rises by more (150%), then by the same (100%), then by less (60%). Check: 100 × 2.5 = 250; 250 × 2 = 500; 500 × 1.6 = 800.
Economies of scale
The scale of production is about the size and ratio of the factors used. Every producer tries to reduce cost, and large-scale production brings economies (cost savings), while going beyond a limit brings diseconomies (cost increases). Marshall divided economies into internal and external.
Economies of scale
-
Internal: within one firm
- Technical: modern machines, research and development
- Financial: big firms can raise capital by issuing shares
- Managerial: specialisation and delegation
- Labour: finer division of labour, higher skill
- Marketing: bulk buying, distant markets, bargaining power
- Survival: many products spread the risk
-
External: shared by all firms in the industry
- Better transport
- Banking facilities
- Growth of townships
- Information and communication networks
Worked example 2: bulk buying (made-up figures)
A small bakery buys 100 kg of flour at ₹40 a kg; a large bakery buys 5,000 kg and gets a price of ₹34 a kg. Step 1: saving per kg = 40 − 34 = ₹6. Step 2: on 5,000 kg the large bakery saves 5,000 × 6 = ₹30,000 compared with paying the small-buyer price. Conclusion: this is a marketing economy, an internal economy that only the large firm enjoys.
Diseconomies of scale
Diseconomies raise cost and can slow supply to the market. Internal diseconomies arise when a firm grows beyond its optimum size and efficiency falls (for example, management becomes hard to coordinate). External diseconomies come from outside: a transport strike stops workers reaching the factory, or rents rise sharply when many new firms crowd into a locality.
Economies versus diseconomies
-
Economies of scale
- Lower cost per unit
- Internal: technical, financial, managerial, labour, marketing, survival
- External: transport, banks, townships, communication
-
Diseconomies of scale
- Higher cost per unit, slower supply
- Internal: firm beyond its optimum size
- External: strikes, rising rents, congestion
Double all inputs: output more than doubles = increasing returns; exactly doubles = constant; less than doubles = diminishing.
Key takeaways: returns to scale are long-run laws when all inputs change together: increasing, constant and diminishing. Internal economies belong to a single large firm; external economies are shared by an industry. Growing beyond the optimum or crowding in an area brings diseconomies that raise cost.
Check your understanding
-
1. Returns to scale study output when:
- one input varies, others fixed
- all inputs are increased in the same proportion
- only technology changes
- prices of inputs change
Show answer
Answer: B. Returns to scale are a long-run idea: every input is changed in the same proportion.
-
2. Made up: all inputs rise by 50% and output rises by 30%. This is:
- increasing returns to scale
- constant returns to scale
- diminishing returns to scale
- negative returns
Show answer
Answer: C. Output rises by a smaller percentage (30%) than inputs (50%), so returns to scale are diminishing.
-
3. A large firm can sell shares to raise capital, which a small firm finds hard. This is a:
- financial economy
- technical economy
- labour economy
- external economy
Show answer
Answer: A. Easier and cheaper access to capital for a big firm is a financial economy, an internal economy of scale.
-
4. Which is an external economy of scale?
- Specialised managers in a big company
- Bulk purchase of raw materials
- Product diversification
- A new railway line serving all the factories in an industrial area
Show answer
Answer: D. Better transport benefits all firms in the area, regardless of each one's size: an external economy.
-
5. Made up: doubling inputs raises output from 400 to 800 units. Returns to scale are:
- increasing
- constant
- diminishing
- negative
Show answer
Answer: B. (800 − 400) ÷ 400 × 100 = 100%, the same as the 100% rise in inputs, so returns to scale are constant.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.